3 ms·
Good, thorough observations. A couple things I'd chime in on: > I was under the understanding aviation used a radically different development process specifica
by bumby 7y ago
Good, thorough observations. A couple things I'd chime in on:
> I was under the understanding aviation used a radically different development process specifically designed to avoid this type of thing.
I think this is confusing the development process with the oversight process. It's possible for the development team to follow more traditional approaches and still leave the FAA in the dark.
> Active participation of an adversarial regulator is absolutely essential.
Completely agree, but unfortunately regulators often perceive themselves (or are pressured) to be facilitators as much as overseers. When the incentives of the regulators and the manufacturers align too much ("lets get this out the door for cost/schedule/lobbyist reasons") the cultural adversarial aspect is watered down. Layer on top of that a bootstrapped regulator who has to cover down on multiple systems and they may no longer be technically capable of fulfilling a staunch adversarial role and are relegated to ensuring the process "checks the boxes"
> This is straight up unwillingness to test
I feel like when cost/schedule pressure hits, thorough testing is the first thing to go. Good quality oversight helps prevent bad things from happening. When it's been a long time since bad things last happened, people begin to think that quality oversight is no longer necessary without making the connection that it may be the direct cause of that 'goodness'. This feels very much like a human psychology problem rather than a technical issue, similar to the cultural issues that resulting in the Space Shuttle Challenger/Columbia disasters. We need to realize these (sometime painful) oversight mechanisms are meant to save us from ourselves and not lose sight of that when the recent success gives us a dose of hubris.
> evidence of a potentially deliberate regulatory hack...that decision maker needs to be held to account.
My hunch part of the problem will be this won't be hung on one "decider". The responsibility for these decisions often get diffused across multiple people and it doesn't become crystal clear who ultimately bears responsibility. (This may play into the cultural aspect as well; I wonder if there was a clear distinction that these decisions land on one single person, if the weight of that responsibility would give them more pause.) A good leader understands the buck stops with them...I'll wait and see if that actually plays out.