5 ms·
Hold on a minute! This seems to contradict the often-repeated assertion here on HN that shipping doesn't contribute to air pollution. Despite burning the dirtie
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Hold on a minute! This seems to contradict the often-repeated assertion here on HN that shipping doesn't contribute to air pollution. Despite burning the dirtiest fuels possible and producing more pollution than all of automotive transportation, the smoke was supposed to somehow settle out and not get into the upper atmosphere.
This article claims there're 2X lightening strikes over shipping lanes, because of additional particulates in the upper atmosphere.
How do we reconcile this?
- Doxin 7y ago> This seems to contradict the often-repeated assertion here on HN that shipping doesn't contribute to air pollution. That assertion seems ridiculous on the face of it. Even if the particles settle you're still polluting the ocean. Besides aren't gasses the main pollution problem anyways? People confuse me sometimes...
- gojomo 7y agoGases are plenty bad, long-term & for the overall climate. But I'm pretty sure the particulates are even worse, in terms of causing both immediate discomfort & diagnosable illnesses in the short- and medium- terms.
- Doxin 7y agoSure, but that doesn't really affect the silliness of the assertion that shipping doesn't contribute at all.
- gojomo 7y agoThe Wired article itself mentions that the particles in question settle within a few weeks. To the extent that's mostly over the ocean, that could be consistent with claims that shipping particulate pollution has a minimal effect on the health of land-based humans.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoSettle within a few weeks, whilst we constantly top up with permanently active shipping lanes. You might measure similarly near roads and highways. Trouble is there are no few week breaks in the schedule that ever let it actually settle out.
- tlb 7y ago> often-repeated assertion here on HN that shipping doesn't contribute to air pollution Could you provide a citation?
- Symmetry 7y agoSeriously. You can be talking about air pollution as CO2 or particulate or sulfur dioxide or a number of other things and which sort of pollution you're talking about makes a big difference in how polluting you should consider container ships to be. Also whether you're comparing tanker ships to other forms of freight or to overall pollution emissions or to the hunter gatherer lifestyle.
- amflare 7y agoIt doesn't contribute in that it burns the dirtiest fuels out in the middle of nowhere, both causing the effect to be much more diluted, and allowing cleaner fuel to be used in dense areas. If we reversed it, it would not be a measurable difference to over-sea pollution, but it would drastically increase over-land pollution.
- dredmorbius 7y agoThe issue isn't that shipping doesn't cause air pollution. It's what kind of pollution does it create (few articles state this explicitly), and with what consequences. In general, you have the following emissions from any fossil-fuel combustion process: - Water vapour. This is virtually never harmful. - CO2. This is not immediately toxic, but is a greenhouse gas, and net emissions must be reduced globally. - Other combustion chemical products. Generally small fractions total emissions, though potentially hazardous to humans, including NOx (nitrous oxides), SO2 (sulfur dioxide), O3 (ozone), and trace pollutants such as mercury. All are bioactive or biotoxic. - Physical emissions. In particular, fine particulate matter, essentially soot, most especially PM2.5 (2.5 micron particles). These are physical irritants and can contribute to lung injury and disease, among other factors. Stating "ships emit X amount of pollutants" without specifying the pollutants is worse than useless, and often deliberately misleading. Total CO2 emissions are wholly a function of the amount of fuel burned. Shipping is about 3% of total fossil fuel consumption, and hence, of total CO2 emissions. On net, and especially based on the total tonnage and value of goods moved, shipping is the most efficient form of transportation available. It is low polluting in terms of CO2. Where ships trail, badly, is in particulate and chemical emissions. Ship fuel is "bunker oil", basically the last grade of petroleum above asphalt, and having a consistency when cold of tar or even a solid. Worse, it's also typically high in impurities, including sulfur, mercury, and other elements and chemicals. And when burnt tends to product high amounts of particulates. Given the regulatory environment, multinational, international waters, diverse, and often a race-to-the-bottom of bare minimum standards, marine emissions of these pollutants is high. As a somewhat saving grace, these pollutants do tend to settle out quickly, and hence don't reside long in the atmosphere. Some, especially mercury, do reside in (and worse, bioaccumulate and concentrate) in life, which is why eating carnivorous fish (tuna, shark, swordfish) is not recommended. But the full picture on shipping is that its pollutant levels vary greatly, compared to other sources, and in environmental impacts depending on the specific pollutants in question.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAgain, isn't the assertion that the 'settle out' contradicted by the lightening maps?