2 ms·
Given, but flight envelope protection has it's warts too, and I don't wish to (and probably chose my words poorly to convey my true meaning) turn this into a Bo
by salawat 7y ago
Given, but flight envelope protection has it's warts too, and I don't wish to (and probably chose my words poorly to convey my true meaning) turn this into a Boeing v. Airbus design philosophy flame war.
Where your examples pass my test of acceptable fly-by-wire, is that even in their most automation crippled state, (direct law), the airframe demonstrates longitudinal stability, and the automation doesn't induce undesired behavior detrimental to flying the plane. Thereby it can be thought of as a Hardware Abstraction Layer between the inputs and the control surfaces that faithfully represent pilot inputs to output behavior.
Boeing's MCAS fails this sniff test. If the input sensor breaks, it actually generates dangerous input that actively detracts from the flyability of the plane. The airframe itself necessitates this dangerous subsystem because uncorrected, no test pilot would be willing to sign off that it was consistent with the older 737's handling characteristics.
Just wanted to be clear: I'm not anti-Airbus. I'm anti-"Hey let's automate this, but do it with minimum scrutiny and reckless levels of awareness building for the end operator."
Which is what happened with the MAX, and seems like a page torn out of McDonnell Douglas playbook.
- PaulHoule 7y agoIt is not Boeing vs airbus, it is the 737 vs all other modern airliners. FBW on the 7x7 (for x>3) is not that different from Airbus airliners except Airbus has sidestick controls that are not mechanically connected whereas Boeings have jokes that are mechanically between the two pilots. If Boeing used the same flight controls that they use on all post 1970 planes it would be ok, Airbus has nothing to do with it.
- foldr 7y ago>FBW on the 7x7 (for x>3) is not that different FBW refers simply to the lack of a hydraulic/mechanical connection between the flight controls and the control surfaces. The 747 has such a connection. Thus, the 747 is not a FBW aircraft (although I think some control surfaces on the 747-8 may be FBW).