5 ms·
Well, I think it's a fact¹ that a large majority of "science" stories that go viral turn out to be wrong. So the rational approach to them is "what might be wr
by BurningFrog 7y ago
Well, I think it's a fact¹ that a large majority of "science" stories that go viral turn out to be wrong.
So the rational approach to them is "what might be wrong with this one?".
¹ Citation Missing
- tekmate 7y agofrom my experience, when science stories that go viral turn out to be wrong it's some secondhand reporting by people misunderstanding or misrepresenting the actual firsthand report
- kortilla 7y agoThe replication crisis says otherwise.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 7y agoBoth of those phenomenona are common. They aren't mutually exclusive.
- BurningFrog 7y agoThat's definitely also a factor.
- jsight 7y agoI tend to agree, and this article is no different. Articles often report the underlying research in misleading ways.
- josephdviviano 7y agoIf you want to avoid this, just read the paper. I don't understand why technical people waste their time complaining about this stuff. We all have the acumen to read, understand, and debate research.
- chibg10 7y agoBecause there’s only 24 hours a day? Because my tax dollars are often funding this research? Why not take this farther and just do the research myself, eh?
- gwd 7y ago> I don't understand why technical people waste their time complaining about this stuff. We all have the acumen to read, understand, and debate research. But to be honest, the reason I read the comments (at least on a place like HN) is to get the key insight / failure without reading the article.
- josephdviviano 7y agoWhen scientists disagree among themselves, it's hard to use this strategy.
- moultano 7y agoIt's paywalled. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0095069619301901 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00950... If I had access, I'd try to dig into more depth into how they approached decoupling this from temperature, because that seems like a really strong confounder. I'm also a bit curious about the underlying physical cause of the change in pollution levels, (weekends? summertime?) because that seems like it could also be a confounding common cause. Alas, I'm not interested in paying $35 for the paper.
- johnfactorial 7y agoThe rational approach to all peer review is to assume there's a flaw and look for it. Quite a few commenters seem bothered by this reflexive reaction to published research, when the entire point of publishing research is to have it picked apart by critical thinkers everywhere.