4 ms·
> That's very hard to do automatically. When you run a worldwide network that has significant potential for abuse and spreading misinformation I would consider
by Nextgrid 7y ago
> That's very hard to do automatically.
When you run a worldwide network that has significant potential for abuse and spreading misinformation I would consider it to be your duty to monitor it and guard against these kinds of things. If it costs too much then maybe you shouldn't be in business or should change your business model so that you can afford to clean up the damage your business is doing to society.
- jeegsy 7y agoThe allegation here is that its the government doing it. Do you really think Twitter wants to take on governments?
- birksherty 7y agoShutting down bots that spread misinformation is not against gov. If they do, it will mean they acknowledge that gov is behind all these.
- wutbrodo 7y agoCan you point out what identifies these tweets' content as "misinformation", in a way that's consistently operationalizable among the massive scale of frontline human reviewers that you're expecting? On its face, the content of the tweets is "the Indonesian govt built roads in West Papua", which hardly qualifies as misinformation. The author's analysis that this is more sinister than simply a promotional campaign is, of course, correct: the coopting of the genocide hashtag to promote the government and the use of fake, international-sounding accounts are both skeezy as all hell. But to get to that conclusion, you have a professional journalist doing a level of post-automation analysis that's too complex to operationalize at scale. It requires too much critical thinking and discretion, and throwing a million human reviewers at it will just result in the kind of capricious false positives that are also railed against on HN and elsewhere (perhaps rightfully), with an undoubtedly high amount of false negatives too. There are constant ignorant-layman calls for magical tech moderation that only touches bad targets and never steps on the good little guy, but none of the people making these blithe demands ever stop and think about whether this is possible, beyond "they're rich and smart, they definitely know how to do it".
- Zenst 7y agoIssue is if you run such automation with aggresive settings that would pick up this - you also increase false-positives and those for such a business could have a more negative impact than a few small bot nets. So you do need people somewhere in the loop to handle these things. What would be nice though would be if social media offered rewards for identifying such abuse, after all - they happily pay bug bounties, why not abuse bounties! That would get them lots of zero-hour/non-contract workers doing their job for them and big companies love that it seems and to be able to do that in a PR way that has positives. Well, it works for BUG bounties, why not incentivise the populus to police the populus against abuse as well.
- dmix 7y agoExactly, of course they’d have automated it by now if they could. This isn’t like spam mail, it’s propaganda that looks a whole lot like legitimate dissent or information, that’s the whole point. They won’t be full of spammy referral links and easily identifiable keywords for products or scams.
- cat199 7y ago> you also increase false-positives ... > if social media offered rewards for identifying such abuse couldn't this also be gamed for false positives, and create an incentive for groups to form smear-for-profit entities which try to spin small communities as 'bad' to the benefit of others?
- Zenst 7y agoWhen life is a game, everything is gameable. However, as humans are good at adapting, you are playing one large mass of people against a lesser mass of bad players. So whilst you may get gaming of the system, that would still stand out to others who would investigate. But let us not forget, things like posting IP and client and other such details that may prove useful in identifying such abuse, may well elude public investigation. So it would be these niche area's in which Twitter could then focus upon. However, as an example of a slightly comparable problem - wiki editing and the weighted credibility of editors over time, we may well end up creating a hidden social media based upon a small subset of society and perhaps yielding a bias in some direction or another in judgment of what is abuse.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 7y agoYes, tech companies do not get to hide behind “we can’t do it because with humans.” Apple spends a significant amount of resources on human evaluation, and Twitter should not be allowed to shrug its shoulders and say “we are trying, but detection is hard.” It is not unreasonable to take the top 5k accounts/hash tags and manually evaluate the top replies and retweets. Human evaluation can be very streamlined with clean evaluation rules, and these human evaluations get fed back to machine learning models.
- big_chungus 7y agoApple charges one thousand dollars for a phone; twitter is free. Is it unreasonable to expect a lower quality of service? Twitter didn't make its first annual profit until last year, whereas Apple has staggering amounts of cash burning a hole in its pocket. And after all that, Apple's recent products have been somewhat lackluster. Catalina is currently a dumpster-fire; a friend installed it and had his machine just sit frozen for a while along with a huge number of other problems. Keyboard design, too. Doesn't sound to perfect to me.
- Nextgrid 7y agoHowever, Apple’s failures don’t affect anyone that hasn’t bought into the ecosystem. Twitter’s failures on the other hand affect everyone - misinformation spread through their platform can and does affect society at large regardless of whether you’re using Twitter yourself.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 7y agoIt sounds like Twitter needs to charge more. If we (society?) cannot support a free website enough for it to be viable, so be it.
- jacquesm 7y agoSpot on. So, the equation runs as follows: ethical people running such networks will realize that they can't do it profitably and properly and so will shut down. The unethical ones don't give a fuck, don't do it properly, make gobs of money and claim victory. This happens much more often than you might think, there are a quite a few examples of this effect.