5 ms·
> American universities graduated 100,000 new PhDs but only created 16,000 new professorships Here we go again - this weird idea that the only purpose for doin
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> American universities graduated 100,000 new PhDs but only created 16,000 new professorships
Here we go again - this weird idea that the only purpose for doing a PhD is to become a professor.
- lallysingh 7y agoAgreed. CS PhDs don't typically identify themselves with a Dr prefix, so our population (I have one, I don't use a Dr prefix) is rather hidden. People don't know how many of us there are. When I was at Google, about 25% of googlers had PhDs.
- jhbadger 7y agoIn many fields, that's actually not far from the truth, though. Yes, PhDs in computer science, engineering, and natural sciences can find jobs in industry, but it's not like anyone getting a PhD in 19th century German literature can easily find a job using that other than in academia.
- michaelmior 7y agoHowever, computer science is also one of the fields with the largest need for professors partially because of the competition with industry jobs. My experience from a Canadian perspective was that computer science PhDs also tend to be better funded than those in the social sciences so the overall risk is much lower.
- barry-cotter 7y agoThe risk may be lower but the forgone income is a lot greater. The median admit to a CS Ph.D. programme, even the worst ones in the US, can probably get a job at Google and can definitely get a job programming for a living if they have the right to live in the US. If they’re from a less developed country a Ph.D. stipend and the possibility of staying afterwards probably looks pretty great.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> The median admit to a CS Ph.D. programme, even the worst ones in the US, can probably get a job at Google Hah I think the hiring bar for Google is higher than the bar for a PhD viva!
- barry-cotter 7y agoFor real? Because people have been hired directly from Lambda School and App Academy to Google and one would get the impression that https://elementsofprogramminginterviews.com/ https://elementsofprogramminginterviews.com/ and leetcode would do, which is maybe six month’s work from a standing start.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWell I know a lot of people with PhDs who couldn't pass a Google interview. Of course it's harder to tell how many can pass a Google interview but can't pass a PhD, because people don't tend to simply 'fail' a PhD except in extreme circumstances, and people who drop out of a PhD weren't necessarily going to fail. I have a PhD and I don't think I could pass the famous Google interview! I'm just not that good.
- michaelmior 7y agoThis is very true about income. Although I think it's safe to say that the lifetime earnings of a PhD graduate in CS are likely to be well above average across the whole population even if significantly lower than those who skipped the PhD.
- barry-cotter 7y agoA Ph.D. is professional training for being a professor, or at a push, a researcher. If you don’t get yours from a top programme your chances of getting a professor job are quite low in the US, though other countries vary. A Ph.D. will at absolute minimum take three years on top of a Bachelor’s in the UK. In the US it’s common for it to take six years including a two year Master’s portion. Many fields have large numbers of people taking nine years, like literature or anthropology. Even three years is a huge cost in forgone income never mind six or nine. Then in many fields there’s a post doc before you can get a shot at a professor job and then you spend six years trying for tenure, which you often won’t get. That’s fine if you’re willing to live like a monk because you love what you do for most of your twenties and if you could be guaranteed a job at the end of ten years plenty of people would take that offer but many very talented people spend close to a decade, or more, in training for a job they never get. A Ph.D. for fun, for consumption purposes is fine if you come from money or are supported by a working spouse with a real job but for a great many people they end up with nothing after enormous effort.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> A Ph.D. is professional training for being a professor, or at a push, a researcher. It's professional training for being a researcher. You can do that in industry or academia. It doesn't make a huge difference, really. Becoming a professor is something that only a tiny minority of people are ever going to do, perhaps after another decade or more after their PhD.
- analog31 7y agoUnfortunately, there are also not a huge plethora of jobs for researchers in industry either. At least, it's hard to find posted job openings. It may be that a lot of the people in industry who are doing researchy work started out as clerks and worked their way into their positions over time.
- barry-cotter 7y agoAnd yet the system is set up for a time when every Ph.D. who wanted a job as a professor would get one. That ended in the 70s. Now you have people doing three post docs before giving up to go into industry as they could have straight after the Ph.D. which many would never have done if they’d known where they’d end up. And you have humanities Ph.D.s doing jobs that in no way require the training and social science Ph.D.s doing jobs they could have ended up in if they’d never gone to graduate school though it’s not quite as bad because at least they often end up getting jobs that require the six or so years of experience they spent in grad school, earning a lot less money.
- bart_spoon 7y agoIt's certainly true that there are reasons for getting a PhD other than becoming a professor, but it's also true that in many fields having a PhD is also completely unnecessary. And yet in many fields there seems to a qualification arms race where, due to the glut of PhDs and lack of jobs where PhDs are truly required, jobs for which a PhD is not necessary or beneficial are starting to become expected. I've definitely begun to see this in the fields of machine learning and data science. I'm sure other fields are similar.
- Rerarom 7y agoA PhD is like a vocational arts school for being a professor/researcher. The fact that you can do something else with it is a bonus, not a purpose.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- spodek 7y ago> > American universities graduated 100,000 new PhDs but only created 16,000 new professorships > Here we go again - this weird idea that the only purpose for doing a PhD is to become a professor. Or that professors need PhDs. Time spent getting a PhD deprives future educators of skills beyond academic ones that will serve many students better than academic skills.
- buboard 7y agoIt's the one job that requires a phd so it's not weird
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't think that's really an absolute requirement - there are full professors without PhDs.
- brudgers 7y agoI think the characterization is a side effect when students ask "What do I do next?" After about four years pursuing a non-vocational degree, a lot of students have job prospects inconsistent with a meritocratic opportunity worldview. But not just students, their professors also recognize that barista is a median outcome for many new graduates without connections...the people who most depend on meritocracy to provide access to good jobs. The Phd as a route to professorship is a way of maintaining the idea of meritocratic access to stable and fulfilling careers. The belief meets everyone's need to believe that people will just give money to the deserving intellect.