3 ms·
>The first priority is always profits or growth. When Apple split with Google, they did so over access to customer data. At the time wall street was salivating
by simonh 7y ago
>The first priority is always profits or growth.
When Apple split with Google, they did so over access to customer data. At the time wall street was salivating over the huge profits to be gained from mining customer data, and Google was dangling billions of dollars in front of Steve Jobs' face to get him to fold. He didn't, and also turned down lucrative deals offered by Facebook.
That was all at a time when user privacy was widely seen as a marginal issue, and long before big privacy breaches regularly got into the mainstream press. Apple could have made huge amounts of money, but instead they turned those deals down and instead spent billions of dollars building their own maps and engineering iMessage with end-to-end encryption. No other tech company has come even close to Apple's record on user privacy and security. I can't even think of another one that's even tried.
That's what's so upsetting for me over this HK Maps issue. I know they have a lot at stake, including the livelihoods and safety and security of thousands of employees in China, but I still think they made the wrong call on this.
iMessage is pretty secure, but there are practical limits to how secure it can be, while also enabling cloud backups and data recovery options. Here's a somewhat sensationalised take, which does go into the practical reasons for the limitations. What it doesn't point out is that if you don't enable iCloud backup (maybe just backing up to iTunes), your secure keys never go to the iCloud servers so there is actually a way to stay secure even in China.
https://medium.com/bob-kfir-tech/how-secure-is-imessage-8cc7f6d40d8e https://medium.com/bob-kfir-tech/how-secure-is-imessage-8cc7...
- PeterStuer 7y agoApple could never out-Google Google, and they knew it. Accepting Google's suit without their own alternatives by default would have relegated their platform to be just another Google app launcher for key functionalities. They instead opted to pursue a business model that played to their own strengths. You seem to believe that Apple's iMessage service is somehow exempt from Lawful Intercept requirements. Let me quote from those in the EU (China's requirements could be more lenient, but I somehow doubt that): "3.3 If network operators/service providers initiate encoding, compression or encryption of telecommunications traffic, law enforcement agencies require the network operators/service providers to provide intercepted communications en clair." https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:C:1996:329:FULL&from=EN https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:C...
- simonh 7y agoOn iPhones running google services, either Apple is in it just for the money or they aren't. Apple maps cost them a fortune and makes them no money, that's just a fact. They could also have easily played Google, facebook and twitter against each other, instead they said no to them all. Lawful Intercept has a fatal flaw. It doesn't require the service provider to have encryption keys for the traffic, and they can't provide what they don't have.
- PeterStuer 7y agoLawful Intercept has no such flaw. It does not let you of the hook just because you think you are clever and say "Oopsy, I can't". If your service can't comply with regulation when requested or inspected, then your service will be disallowed until you can.