2 ms·
>> Yet another puzzle is Leonidas’ decision to stay and die. That's probably the easiest question to answer: the Spartans were war-crazy. This is well-documen
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> Yet another puzzle is Leonidas’ decision to stay and die.
That's probably the easiest question to answer: the Spartans were war-crazy.
This is well-documented, and the tales of Leonida's wife asking him what to do if he doesn't return, and the 300 celebrating their own funerals, etc, are par for the course, for Spartans. Their whole society was hyper-militarised, their highest ideal was bravery in battle, to kill their enemies with no regard for their own life (in the service of the City, of course). They drilled their children from a young age to this mindset and they all became mad with it. So when the time came to choose between ditching their shield and running to fight another day, or staying and dying, the Spartans stayed and died. "Ή ταν, ή επί τας" as a Spartan mother said to her child ("with it, or on it"; "it" being his shield: either he carried it home, or they carried him home on it).
It is perhaps difficult to interpret this mindset from the point of view of a rational actor, because in terms of a strategy that maximises rewards and minimises losses, heroism does not compute. But a good general must take into account the fact that people are not perfectly rational, that they are in their most irrational when faced with death, that men with their backs to the wall fight to the death to a man. And that, at the end of the day, some troops will never break and run.
Remember also the Sacred Band of Thebes.
- dragontamer 7y ago> the Spartans were war-crazy. Consider the source. The tales being told at the time amount to war-propaganda. In practice, you want to appear as if you were a war-crazy state, but actual behavior is extremely unusual. The modern equivalent would be looking at North Korean documentation of the North Korean military. Probably not the best source. It would be one thing if the Persians documented the battle, because then we'd have an outside viewpoint proving the war-craziness. (Or perhaps another example: the Assyrians were well documented by many cultures of being actually war-crazy). But we only have Greek propaganda / Greek tales to tell one side of the story. Obviously, things are lost in history, and the battle of Thermopylae was not a strategic hindrance at all to the Persians. So it makes sense that it was only really documented by the Greeks. Still, it would be nice to have some non-Greek viewpoints into the battle.