8 ms·
Twitter analysis: identifying a propaganda bot network
- markdown 7y agoSurprising to see this on here. The ongoing genocide of the West Papuan people by Indonesia has largely been ignored by the West. BTW the propaganda team behind this bot network has also been very active on reddit.
- nencrystation 7y agoEvery now and then bellingcat covers a "lesser" news story like this one, so they can pretend their main purpose isn't to push for regime change in Syria.
- howard941 7y agobellingcat made its mark documenting the MH17 shootdown. https://www.bellingcat.com/tag/mh17/ https://www.bellingcat.com/tag/mh17/ has the exhaustive history
- lazyjones 7y agoThis narrative is falling apart lately with the Dutch parliament pushing unanimously to investigate the role of Ukrainian forces in the attack, Bellingcat is apparently just a pro-US propaganda tool.
- codezero 7y agoI am not super up to speed on this news, but I had a quick look and my guess as to why you are being downvoted, is without context, it sounds like you are implying Ukraine may have had some role worth investigating in the shooting down of MH17. That is not the case. It sounds like the consensus is that pro-Russian troops brought a missile over from Russia, and shot down MH17. What the Dutch parliament is proposing an investigation into, is whether Ukraine should have officially shut down its airspace. Implying that Ukraine is at fault for shooting down an airliner because they did not shut down the airspace seems like blaming someone for being raped and shot because they didn't lock their front door, which is patently absurd.
- Udik 7y agoLet's say they seem to be consistently on one side of the Russia - USA disputes, of which Syria has been one of the issues. Just a quick browsing of the articles published in the last few months show that the vast majority of the investigations is focused on various malfeasances of Russia, Syria or Iran.
- varjag 7y agoBellingcat investigations on Syria predate Russian involvement in Syria.
- Udik 7y agoBellingcat was founded in July 2014, while Russia has been siding with Assad from the start of the war- vetoing sanctions, providing weapons and preventing an open attack by the US in 2013.
- varjag 7y agoRussia did not enter Syria until 2015. Bellingcat's founder was already publishing on Syrian conflict in 2012.
- varjag 7y agoIt's not just chemtruthers and Assadists that are mad on Bellingcat. They stepped on plenty of toes elsewhere.
- Udik 7y agoExamples?
- varjag 7y agoOuting the Russian GRU operatives in Novichok affair. Tracking the cross border movement of Buk TELAR that likely shot down MH17. Investigations on C14 and other associated neo-Nazi groups of Ukraine. Sources of Italian Lega Nord financing. Aleppo mosque bombing by USAF. etc etc
- peteretep 7y agoSo?
- adipginting 7y agoYou need to check the definition of "genocide" before saying that it is on going. There are human right abuses and neglect by the central government. These used to be happened all over Indonesia and still are but not just in Papua. The government is trying to fix the situation. There will be no another independence to another province of Indonesia
- guelo 7y agoAre you a member of the Indonesian propaganda team?
- adipginting 7y agoWell, that is not the point but I am just a regular citizen
- brogrammer5 7y agoDefinitely sound's like something a propagandist would say.
- adipginting 7y agoIt looks like but I am not. You can verify my identity :D Genocide is a strong word. There's no intention of Indonesian government to eradicate any people today. The last time we did commit genocide was 1965 during the communist purge. Guess what? Australia, UK, and USA blessed the act.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThough I can't keep up with every political conflict I'm particularly interested in the intersection of genocide, propaganda, and social media. It's OK to gmail me with tips or questions.
- eecc 7y agoUh, from the article: why is he using sudo to run a python script? sudo twint -u bellanow1 –media -o papuabots1 –csv Not good
- speps 7y agoTheory: he's a reporter, someone showed him the command, one time it didn't work and the other person said to use "sudo" possibly because he was trying to write a file somewhere he needed access to. Now he always uses sudo because it always works...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pp19dd 7y agoBecause confusing state of version management in 2019: https://twitter.com/noneprivacy/status/1168955093934399493 https://twitter.com/noneprivacy/status/1168955093934399493 > If you used sudo because you installed the package "system wide", try with "pip3 install --user twint" which will install twint in your home directory, and so you'll not be asked to use sudo
- vernie 7y agoI do not like the color of this bikeshed.
- cat199 7y agobecause sudo improves security over 'su' and raw root logins, obviously
- luckylion 7y ago> This exact sentence was published by many of the other bots in their own individual tweets using the hashtags #westpapuagenocide and #freewestpapua. A clickbaity video "what the government is trying to hide" that contains pro-gov messages ("they've developed an app for personal finance management and are giving villages more opportunities", "they are helping the food industry") posted under those hashtags. Is that attempting to influence people that are looking up those hashtags (presumably expecting to find info on "the genocide"), or is that just to add noise to the hashtag? It looks too high quality for just noise (so it's probably too expensive to produce a lot of that content), but on the other hand, I can't imagine someone saying "woah, there's a genocide going on in west papua? I better check twitter. Ah, here's a video ... mhh, they are deploying an app to help people with finances and there's something about the food industry? I'm now convinced there is no genocide". Like, is that some "if only people knew about our app, they wouldn't mind the crimes" thinking? Does that work?
- Jsharm 7y agoIf it's possible to do this analysis why does twitter not routinely shutdown these networks?
- scribu 7y agoThe analysis in this post is only on two rather small hashtags (a very small percentage of the whole of Twitter). It also involves a lot of "eyeballing", particularly the part where the author looks at the graph and notices a weird pattern. That's very hard to do automatically.
- molmalo 7y agoThis. And also, the cynic in me tells me that closing millions of accounts does not look good in your quarterly report on user base growth/active users.
- g96alqdm0x 7y agoPerhaps, but I think you would agree that "shareholder value" is a relic of the 80s and a poor metric to optimize for.
- jandrese 7y agoThey also get political blowback when they do this. There is an inevitable flurry of "Twitter is silencing our voices" posts when they shut down botnets. Congressmen start making statements about it. https://grrrgraphics.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/jack_dorsey_twitter.jpg https://grrrgraphics.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/jack_dor... https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DTmD9bmVMAA9M19.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DTmD9bmVMAA9M19.jpg https://static.thefederalistpapers.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/conservative-bias-google-tech-companies.jpg https://static.thefederalistpapers.org/wp-content/uploads/20...
- catalogia 7y agoDoes twitter really deserve the trust though? I remember a lot of people I know complaining about getting locked out of their twitter accounts a year or two ago, with twitter demanding a phone number for them "for security". Then a few days ago it comes out that they were using those phone numbers for advertising purposes. Do they really deserve the benefit of the doubt on this?
- ailideex 7y agoNot a bot, Twitter recently blocked my account that had almost no activity without providing any reason and now I cannot delete it which is in contravention of GDPR.
- peteretep 7y ago> I cannot delete it which is in contravention of GDPR Go on. They’ve refused your removal request with appropriate ID sent to their office, or?
- ailideex 7y ago> They’ve refused your removal request with appropriate ID sent to their office, or? I have sent my email address to their support system while being logged in and they did confirm it. So yes. And they have not even responded so clearly in contravention with GDPR. > Go on. With?
- megous 7y agoAppropriate ID is username/password if real-life ID was not previously linked to an account directly.