3 ms·
When did he stand up to the CIA? As far as standing up to the FBI, the impetus behind that was to cover up another lie. Apple had told customers "it's not techn
by lern_too_spel 7y ago
When did he stand up to the CIA? As far as standing up to the FBI, the impetus behind that was to cover up another lie. Apple had told customers "it's not technically feasible" for Apple to respond to data requests and got a mountain of free press for it. The FBI showed a method by which Apple could obtain the encrypted data on those devices. Soon after, that claim disappeared from Apple's "Privacy" marketing page. https://gizmodo.com/apple-wont-turn-over-your-phones-data-to-police-if-your-1636197341 https://gizmodo.com/apple-wont-turn-over-your-phones-data-to...
Complying with the data request would have given users who had their data obtained standing to sue Apple, so Apple's willingness to litigate the issue went so far as the cost of the lawsuits it wanted to avoid. The FBI dropped the case not because it didn't think it could win but because it could access the data more quickly using another vendor's data extraction service.
- panda88888 7y agoMy mistake. It was just FBI.
- ikeboy 7y ago>Complying with the data request would have given users who had their data obtained standing to sue Apple This is wrong. Complying with a court order doesn't open you up to any liability; furthermore, the users the FBI was after in this case were already dead.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> Complying with a court order doesn't open you up to any liability It does if you've told your customers that you can't. > the users the FBI was after in this case were already dead. The owner of the device you're talking about was the user's (singular, not plural) living employer, but I wasn't talking about that user in the sentence you quoted. After implementing the data extraction procedure the FBI described, Apple would have been asked to extract data from many other devices. Most of the users of those devices are alive, and some might even be innocent of the crimes that were being investigated.
- ikeboy 7y ago>It does if you've told your customers that you can't. Not really. First of all, a suit is unlikely when the person who'd bring a lawsuit is someone that committed a crime with probable cause. Second, damages from having your illegal actions uncovered aren't recoverable when there's a valid warrant, it would be clearly against public policy. They wouldn't be liable at all; if somehow there was a theory of liability it would be capped at the cost of the phone, which is negligible. It doesn't add up as a motivation for Apple.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> committed a crime with probable cause Your error is that you don't know the difference between committing a crime and probable cause.
- ikeboy 7y agoThat was clumsily worded. I mean someone who a judge has decided there is probable cause that they committed a crime.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoI understand now. Thanks for the clarification. > Second, damages from having your illegal actions uncovered aren't recoverable when there's a valid warrant, it would be clearly against public policy. As I said, some of them are innocent and don't have any illegal actions to uncover. > if somehow there was a theory of liability it would be capped at the cost of the phone, which is negligible. They can sue for additional damages due to loss of privacy. > It doesn't add up as a motivation for Apple. The direct cost of the lawsuits includes not just the damages but the legal costs. On top of this, the press that Apple would get from the lawsuits would possibly do more than completely reverse the free press from its initial lie.
- ikeboy 7y agoI'd think public policy prevents liability from complying with a valid court order in any event. In the counterfactual world where Apple made the software, I doubt there'd be any suits against Apple for it, and it likely wouldn't even be public. Remember, the only times they would get a warrant is when they already have the phone in their possession, and there'd be no reason to let the suspect know they cracked the phone unless it actually goes to trial and they need to disclose where they got the evidence from. Plus, if your theory of liability is correct, shouldn't Apple be equally as liabile for making phones that the police can crack, even if they don't use Apple to crack them? Which happened quite often, yet we've seen no lawsuits related to that.