3 ms·
Well, in order to nationalize their power they would first need to be a nation. To be honest I don't know why one giant utility for an entire state is a desirab
by chrisco255 7y ago
Well, in order to nationalize their power they would first need to be a nation. To be honest I don't know why one giant utility for an entire state is a desirable thing. In most places I've lived in, each community runs their own utility company. I've had cooperatives, city owned utilities, and private utilities. The best experience by far was the co-op. Since the customers owned the utility, we would get the profits back as credits on our bills usually during the middle of summer when power usage is highest in Florida.
- CameronNemo 7y ago>in order to nationalize their power they would first need to be a nation A nation is a social construct that California could certainly fit into. Hell, Jerry Brown called it one. Examples of nations: Palestine, the Kurdish nation, Tibet. The legal construct is called statehood. States can bind themselves into larger legal entities by giving up some of their own rights. Examples include: the US federal government, the European Union, and the United Kingdom.
- chrisco255 7y agoSorry, no. A nation is a legal construct, and California is not a sovereign nation. If it's a social construct then I'm founding my own nation tomorrow. I don't know anything about Jerry Brown but he doesn't sound very bright.
- selimthegrim 7y agoI believe J. Biafra wrote a song or two you might want to look into
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CameronNemo 7y ago>A nation is a stable community of people, formed on the basis of a common language, territory, history, ethnicity, or psychological make-up manifested in a common culture. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation I studied these topics at a university level. A nation is not a legal entity. Sovereignty is a legal property, and it can be applied to nations.
- chrisco255 7y agoCalifornia is part of the United States. The nation is United States. Sorry, I know Texans and Californians both think they're big enough to be exceptions, but they're still just states. The stable community is the USA. We share highways, military resources, language, government, traditions, laws, etc. This is a ridiculous argument.
- briandear 7y agoInterestingly, the Texas grid is independent.
- CameronNemo 7y ago>The stable community is the USA I highly disagree with this sentiment. Very few of the US institutions are well designed, and I suspect that there will be a decline of American hegemony worldwide.
- perl4ever 7y agoPeople can, and frequently do, make distinctions between nations and states. Hence the term "nation-state" to refer to those nations which are also states. If there wasn't a distinction, the combined term wouldn't be necessary.
- anigbrowl 7y agoYou're hung up on a silly semantic argument about the correct term for a state takeover of a utility. Jerry Brown was Governor of California, for four terms, and not knowing who he is in this context seems rather ignorant.
- nostrademons 7y agoA nation is a group of people with a common culture, identity, and usually language. A state is a legal construct implying self-governance and monopoly of force. "Nation" has become colloquially synonymous with "nation-state", which lead to your confusion. But the legal aspect is from the "state" part, not the "nation" part. There have been historical states (eg. the Holy Roman Empire, Hapsburg Austrian Empire, Ottoman empire) that were not nations, and there are present day nations (the grandparent mentioned some: Palestine, Kurdistan, Tibet, as well as Basques, Zulus, and others) that are not states. Some present day nation-states (eg. Germany & Italy) were nations since medieval times but did not achieve unified statehood until quite recently (1871). The U.S. started as a state (technically, 13 states and one federated government) but did not really become a nation until after the Civil War. If you can convince other people to identify with you, you absolutely can found your own nation. It won't be a state, though, so while might have your own customs good luck on having your own laws.
- sseveran 7y agoThe US was most definitely a nation before the Civil War. And the Civil War was waged to prevent people that identified with each other from founding their own nation.
- SI_Rob 7y ago> one giant utility for an entire state PG&E is big, but it doesn't cover the entire state. For example, much of San Diego is served by SDG&E, much of LA is served by SoCal Edison, and several larger LA satellites like Riverside (~400k pop) have their own city-managed power utilities.
- mullen 7y agoTechnically, all of San Diego County is served by SDG&E.