2 ms·
Coming up with logical reasons for the behavior of social animals is I think wrong when you consider how evolution works. Evolution doesn't do logical analysis
by Gibbon1 7y ago
Coming up with logical reasons for the behavior of social animals is I think wrong when you consider how evolution works.
Evolution doesn't do logical analysis.
I think there is also this trap that we want theories to be logically/mathematically complete without external side effects. If you're looking for that you want a neat tidy theory that explains why a humpback whale would save a seals bacon.
Evolution though doesn't care about that either.
And then there is a bias Westerners have towards zero sum analysis. (I think this is a legacy of the Victorian and Gilded Age) Reality is for an adult humpback whale messing with a killer whale costs him likely nothing.
If something has no cost evolution doesn't operate off it.
So you're just left with humpback whales like protecting their young, or anything else really. Especially from killer whales in particular.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> Evolution doesn't do logical analysis. Sure, but it rewards and institutionalizes behavior that benefits the genes of the individuals.
- jacobush 7y ago... by the mechanism of emotions, for instance.