5 ms·
I think that w3w is over optimized and suffers from a large number of failure modes that interact poorly with a typical human's memory. For example, it is real
by thelittlenag 7y ago
I think that w3w is over optimized and suffers from a large number of failure modes that interact poorly with a typical human's memory.
For example, it is really easy to mis-remember and accidentally pluralize or re-order words. Our memories just don't maintain that kind of precision. Yet w3w will happily accept your mis-pluralized word, or re-ordered words, and spit out a location, with no indication that maybe you made a mistake.
w3w forces you to remember and use exactly the 3 words they gave and nothing else, without risking a garbage-in-garbage-out scenario.
In fairness, they do try to put similar words very far from each other, but unfortunately this only mitigates the risk and doesn't eliminate it.
Our design is resilient to these issues in human memory with the geohashphrase. If you re-order words in the phrase, pluralize (or singularize) a word, or even go so far as to change part-of-speech (e.g. noun a verb) then you'll still get back the same geohash.
Btw we hope to offer 4-base-word phrases for well populated locations. Those phrases should be easy enough to use in everday situations. Outside of that you can get complete coverage with a 5-base word phrase.
- Andrew_nenakhov 7y agoWell, w3w is far from perfect, sure. They have little to offer other than catchy branding and a ///very.nice.format btw, search.qalocate.com (as advertized in a video) does not work, and also has an incorrect certificate. Please fix, would be nice to toy with it.
- thelittlenag 7y agoWe're working on the implementation (as time permits). Once we have that it will be published and accessible from search.qalocate.com. The cert is "wrong" because I redirect back to qalocate.com and that cert only covers the base domain. We have another for all the sub domains but that isn't used by our main site. My hope is that we'll have something in the next few weeks but its only me (fulltime) and another guy (spare free time), so things move slowly. Btw, thank you so much for watching the video! I hope it was useful.