4 ms·
I'd be really concerned about failure modes here. Like with rear-view cameras, it's not uncommon in heavy snow for it to be obscured. That's not much of an issu
by ineedasername 7y ago
I'd be really concerned about failure modes here. Like with rear-view cameras, it's not uncommon in heavy snow for it to be obscured. That's not much of an issue when you still have traditional read-view & side-view mirrors to rely on.
So I can imagine cameras further supplementing mirrors, but not replacing them. At least not for human-driven cars. Self-driving cars are another issue, but I'm also willing to bet there's robust failure detection among sensors, lidar, and cameras, and the car would safely shutdown in the presence of an issue.
- CDRdude 7y ago> Like with rear-view cameras, it's not uncommon in heavy snow for it to be obscured. In heavy snow, this can also happen to mirrors and your rear window. Usually you open the driver door so you can look behind you.
- organsnyder 7y agoOne of our cars doesn't have heated mirrors. It's not uncommon for the mirrors to be unusable during the winter, especially in the morning and after any amount of ice accumulation.
- behringer 7y agoI use my scraper on them. It's very dangerous to drive without mirrors.
- cannonedhamster 7y agoWe can barely get people to clean the snow off their cars before driving on highways. Not sure the tech is the real problem with snow rain, and other weather.
- organsnyder 7y agoWhen the ice is really glazed on, it's difficult to scrape it all off; and I'm nervous about damaging the linkage in the adjusting mechanism. Thankfully, I finally have space in the garage that this winter it won't be an issue.
- bborud 7y agoI drive a lot in heavy snow. Mirrors have to be clean and unobstructed to work. During winter, before I get into my car in the morning, I have to clean the mirrors. The rear view mirror is often compromised by my rear window being gunked up, overwhelming the wiper. So as for failure modes, nah, not terribly worried.
- peter303 7y agoThey are so dang cheap now crucial cameras could be redundant.
- dmix 7y agoCadillac's camera based rear mirror and slides into a traditional mirror if needed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QcJQ_7VFb0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QcJQ_7VFb0 The test driver in the video said it was probably that way for regulatory/safety reasons and sometimes needed when the sun is shining too brightly on the camera. But it's better if someone is sitting in the backseat as well as giving you a wider view than the rear window + mirror alone could.
- scardine 7y agoI guess you can have heated lens just like you have heated mirrors (I'm living in Brazil so I don't have this problem). I like to use darker film in side windows, but it makes hard to use the side mirrors at night, I would love to replace them with cameras. Things like night mode and anti-glare would be pretty cool as well.
- mlindner 7y agoThat can happen worse with mirrors in snow. They get frosted over and you can't see anything from any mirror.
- peeters 7y agoYeah let's not forget that mirrors are supplemental to begin with and already can fail. The failure mode is that you have to look around you more. As long as a manufacturer can't use this as an excuse to add more blind spots I don't see a huge difference.
- godelski 7y ago> I'd be really concerned about failure modes here. I'm so happy failure is being addressed. Because to me (as a former engineer) this is one of the most important factors. In addition to failure due to snow, what about it just breaking? A small rock or crack is not going to greatly obscure a mirror's view. More annoying, but you can still get most information. A smaller lens does have the advantage of a smaller target area but more potential for complete failure. It is also more complex and with more complexity there are more modes of failure. For example: I used to drive an old truck. The mirror adjustments just did not work, but I could manually move them. Dead simple and the purpose of the device is still achieved even when something broke in the device's chain. With a camera you have the screen (which can seriously affect your night vision! I'm EXTREMELY annoyed about this in my current car), every point of connection from screen to camera (software and hardware), the camera, and the lens. I'm under the impression that not much can go wrong here in the product chain and you still have a functioning device. BUT the camera does have clear advantages! You can use IR so you can see at night. No glare. Better angles. Software that can do object detection and help you avoid accidents. It is a matter of trade off. Typically in machines that can easily lead to fatality we tend to me more risk adverse.
- plopz 7y agoI see people driving around constantly with fogged up mirrors or have a broken mirror hanging off the side of their car, or snow packed around every window with only a small area cleared out on the windshield. So I'm not super convinced that failure modes are all that important, at least to your average driver.
- bryanmgreen 7y ago100%. Just drove a car with multiple sensors and cameras and it wouldn't stop freaking out in the rain. Even while parked in an empty lot. It also slammed the brakes automatically while I was driving. Scared the crap out of me so I immediately turned it off after that incident.
- aidenn0 7y agoEven without snow, within a day or 2 of being washed, my RVC is unusable when there is any "above ambient" light source shining on it. During the day, that means the sun is anywhere in the 180 degrees behind my car and at night it means anyone has headlights pointed at me.