3 ms·
Why does what seems likes every commenter / blogger on this site feel the need to write a think piece about how they no longer trust Apple and all those other t
by Gorbzel 7y ago
Why does what seems likes every commenter / blogger on this site feel the need to write a think piece about how they no longer trust Apple and all those other times they weren't the one complaining? (Hint: they were.)
It's always the same – this time out:
• Guy installed beta software and it was buggy. STOP THE PRESSES!!!!
• "I'm a pro user, I've functionally given escalated privs to apps that steal my data, every Electron container POS ever written, and 100 open standards only Chrome supports. How DARE Apple ask desktop users for permissions on upgrade!?!?!? Keep that security stuff for smartphone users – filthy casuals."
• Forgot Password. #classic
• Somehow my hostname changed during a system update.
And the cycle continues. Comments section without fail: 4-5 commenters who maybe used a Mac once are somehow experts on MBP keyboards, no one likes the Touch Bar, software quality, here's a Linux laptop I like (obligatory distro discussion in reply), "Services Company", a WWSJD for good measure, blah blah blah, Apple is DOOOOMED!
Sure, the public at large loves drama, but the ethos of Hacker News supposedly assumes some higher quality of posts + commentariat due to an audience of those involved in building software, startups, products, and hacks that require technical knowhow. Rather, the tendency of the vocal minority who post these anti-Apple Medium articles and comments is quite perverse:
- rail against the mythical "manager" strawperson who hates software quality and is just out to steal money, jobs, or some other vague emotional rallying cry from all us hard working devs.
- "empathize" by infantilizing the industry and software engineers. Neither devs nor tech companies have any responsibility for speaking up on scope, making well-justified technical decisions, keeping in mind the end user or world around them, or voting with their feet, etc.
You hate to see it. Since it's the exact same platform war crap that's been going on forever, it's always big, bad, Cupertino that's at fault...
...and yet, I've been using Catalina (on a separate machine until a late beta), treat my personal accounts as production, assume every process and line of code might be a potential attack vector, and support reasonable software policies which respect I'm both an end user and a software professional.
Isn't perfect, but stable enough for both development and production, just like software since time immortal. Not broken.
- saagarjha 7y agoI’ve been using a Mac for years and I agree with most of the points in the article. (I’m still using Catalina, FWIW; I have a high tolerance for bugs and annoyances.)
- bloody-crow 7y agoI don't know if you just skimmed the article or deliberately misrepresenting its arguments to make your point. Either way, this behavior deserves a downvote in my book. > Guy installed beta software and it was buggy. STOP THE PRESSES!!!! The author is describing the experience on the stable point-zero release of the OS. He only mentions beta to set up the context. > "I'm a pro user, I've functionally given escalated privs to apps that steal my data, every Electron container POS ever written, and 100 open standards only Chrome supports. How DARE Apple ask desktop users for permissions on upgrade!?!?!? Keep that security stuff for smartphone users – filthy casuals." That's pretty much the opposite of what the author is actually saying in the article. You're misrepresenting quite agressively. > Forgot Password Sure, that's possible. It's also entirely possible, given poor overall quality of the release, that it's an OS' fault. > Somehow my hostname changed during a system update. Are you saying it's not an issue worth mentioning? I disagree.
- jonahss 7y agoThe author seems to do a lot of unusual and roundabout things with the software on their personal mac. It's cool to see somebody fully exploring personal software and customization, but what they're doing sounds weird to me. From another post[0] on their blog: >You’ll be able to upgrade to version 2.0 for a one-time purchase of $6.99 – no subscriptions here! No subscriptions here, just me rewriting the app and deciding to charge for the new version every so often. [0] https://tyler.io/reviving-an-old-mac-app/ https://tyler.io/reviving-an-old-mac-app/