3 ms·
I'm not British but from a country where public schools == state schools. I know in the US "public" means something else, but I often end up confusing myself.
by the_af 7y ago
I'm not British but from a country where public schools == state schools. I know in the US "public" means something else, but I often end up confusing myself.
This is what I don't understand (correct me where I'm wrong):
- Public schools are allegedly too regulated / lack accountability (or so I understood from your comment). They receive public funding.
- Charter schools are less regulated (is this a good thing?) and more accountable (to whom?). They also receive public funding. Are charter schools operated for profit?
I agree more accountability is a good thing, bit I'm seriously unconvinced about less regulation. But even then, if these traits are positive, why not handle public schools like this and get rid of charter schools?
Education is both a right and a strategic asset of any country. If a way of doing regulations/accountability is shown to be the best, why not use this in public education?
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Charter schools are less regulated (is this a good thing?) and more accountable (to whom?). They are definitely less regulated (that is literally what the “charter” refers to: they are publicly-funded schools with charters granting exemptions from the usual requirements for such schools), but are less accountable as a direct result of being less regulated. > Are charter schools operated for profit? Often, but not always. Charters may be private for-profit, private non-profit, or public. > But even then, if these traits are positive, why not handle public schools like this and get rid of charter schools? Sure, the idea of charter schools (well, the idea for those that don't oppose public education and see it as a tool to dismantle it) is to enable experimentation, identify things that work, and then apply them more generally. Scaling up things done in “successful” charter schools (whether in wider charter implementations or by copying things that seem to work in public schools) never seems to work, and the fairly obvious reason is that (like most other variation in school outcomes) the “success” of charter schools that seem to be getting good results has nothing to do with teaching, and everything to do with student selection.
- the_af 7y agoThanks for the explanation (this and your other comment explaining public/private/charter). It clarifies a lot of things. It seems charter schools are something I would oppose in my country (and they exist in some form, now that I think about it). I come from a country where while public/state education is under attack from the usual suspects, it's historically one of our core values, one we feel strongly about.
- microcolonel 7y ago> I come from a country where while public/state education is under attack from the usual suspects, it's historically one of our core values, one we feel strongly about. Charter schools are public education, even private schools that take vouchers are public education. If your local government isn't particularly good at administrating schools efficiently, then a more private or corporate school which is directly accountable to the students' guardians is likely to have better outcomes. It's that simple. If your local government does a spectacular job of directly administrating schools, then who would bother? but public education is a qualitative goal, not a specific type of institution. The goal of public education is to educate the public, but the administrative reality of state schools in many regions is that they tend to enrich public sector unions and their senior members more than the public at large.
- the_af 7y agoIt's my national government, and it's publicly funded state schools. Sorry for the confusion: I'm not from the US, and in the non-English-speaking world we tend to mean something different by "public" [1]. I addressed this confusion in another of my comments. > If your local government isn't particularly good at administrating schools efficiently, then a more private or corporate school which is directly accountable to the students' guardians is likely to have better outcomes. It's that simple. Strongly disagreed. ---- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_school#Latin_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_school#Latin_America
- microcolonel 7y ago
- microcolonel 7y agoA sibling comment describes charters as "less accountable", and that's sometimes true from the perspective of the government. I meant that they are more accountable to the students and their guardians, which to me seems more likely to have a positive impact. The government has an incentive to misrepresent the performance of state schools.
- the_af 7y agoWhat matters is the state, not the government. The government is only a part of the state. Direct accountability limited only to the students and their guardians is not necessarily a good thing. For example, a school which excluded certain socioeconomic classes of students may be totally accountable to the students it did accept -- but it wouldn't be right or democratic.
- microcolonel 7y ago> For example, a school which excluded certain socioeconomic classes of students. But this is not even an option for what we're talking about.