3 ms·
I'd take issue with that -- the US Military was able to put up certain goalposts and make a credible claim that they hit them. The problem was that the point of
by Spooky23 7y ago
I'd take issue with that -- the US Military was able to put up certain goalposts and make a credible claim that they hit them. The problem was that the point of the conflict was poorly defined, and victory was even more poorly defined. Bodycount was used as a metric for doing something.
IMO, Vietnam was a vanity war against an idea ("Communism"), and remote warfare is bad because it lowers the cost of vanity conflicts dramatically.
If I need metrics in a historical narrative to keep score, nobody is winning. That's the problem.
- randcraw 7y agoOne of the first rules you learn when working for the US military is, if your kick doesn't go between the goalposts... find a way to move the goalposts. Every military contract/mission officer wants one thing: to claim success for their project at the end of the year. They quickly learn the best way to do this is to reshape the metrics for success so that, whatever the outcome was for that year, you can claim that was the real objective all along. In the space of R&D contracting, it turns out that "blind the generals with flashy demos" does that rather well. Of course, that also requires that the original mission objective be phrased in ambiguous terms so "goalpost" and "kick" remain freely fungible concepts. To that end, in 1964, "Defeating Communism" fit the bill nicely. Today it's "Defeating Terrorism".
- mr_tristan 7y agoRight, the more technology you add, the more kinds of metrics you can track, and it just adds complexity that allows for more "reshaping" of results. Since "victory" is often very hard and messy to define, I just expect the more tech we offer, the more we're going to "win", because of this effect.