5 ms·
> [...] this is roughly the slap in the face I feel when politicians talk about abolishing vouchers or charter schools [...] I'm not from the US and I'm unfami
by the_af 7y ago
> [...] this is roughly the slap in the face I feel when politicians talk about abolishing vouchers or charter schools [...]
I'm not from the US and I'm unfamiliar with the concept of charter schools. If I understand Wikipedia correctly, these are privately owned and operated schools which receive public funding, is that right? If so, in which way would they help or improve any of the hardships associated with Middle School?
- sli 7y agoThey don't, they just get a lot larger budgets thanks to wealthy parents. In some states, they also get state funding on top of that. I'm not sure if it's still the case now, but there was a time when public funding for schools in Arizona would transfer to a charter school with a student, but if a student left, the funding would not transfer back to the public school system. So the money flowed one way and simply acted to drain funding from public schools.
- lucaspm98 7y agoDo charter schools actually get funding from parents? I thought they only used the fraction of the government funding that transferred over from public school, and generally got much better results than public schools using this.
- lazyasciiart 7y agoThey actually vary hugely by state, because each state created them under a new law. You have to specify a state to have a good discussion.
- lucaspm98 7y agoThat's totally fair. My perspective is from the North Carolina system, where they can hold fundraisers like any public school but mostly start off building their facilities through bonds.
- didgeoridoo 7y agoCharter schools are not for the wealthy. In fact, they enroll a significantly greater proportion of underprivileged and ethnic minority children than do traditional public schools.[0] Their outcomes are mixed, but unlike public schools, underperforming charter schools face consequences for failing their students. That’s why many lower-SES parents are beating down the door to get their kids in. [0]: https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d17/tables/dt17_216.30.asp https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d17/tables/dt17_216.30.a...
- lucaspm98 7y agoIt provides competition. The charter schools must attract students to apply as they get a certain dollar amount per student, and that amount is a fraction of what public schools receive per student. Even with this funding handicap, the education is so overwhelmingly better in that at least in my area all but the worst of charter schools have a lottery system for admission and a long waiting list.
- microcolonel 7y agoThe parent comment complained about operating schools like prisons. Charters can't assume attendance, so they often perform better from the perspective of standardized testing and student approval. Charters tend to do better because of the crushing regulation and lack of meaningful accountability of the public schools (if you're British: what you'd call state schools). Some people are under the mistaken impression that charters perform better due to larger budgets, but typically the well-performing ones cost the state less than state schools, and cost the parents nothing.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Charters tend to do better because of the crushing regulation and lack of meaningful accountability of the public schools No, they tend to “do better” because and to the extent they cherry-pick students, either by more restrictive admissions, by being more free to remove students that being their aggregate results down, by not having mandates to serve special needs students, or by selecting for students with parents who are higher socioeconomic status and more involved and place higher priority on education, which they often do simply by being a non-default choice requiring active choice that is less conveniently located than the default-by-residence-location public school. Charters (which can be publicly or privately operated) have strictly less accountability than regular, non-charter public schools.
- the_af 7y agoNot from the US here: what is a publicly operated charter school? I'm very confused now :( Or is any school outside the official educational program a "charter school"?
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Or is any school outside the official educational program a "charter school"? Charter schools are schools within the official public education system (whether operated by the public authority or some other entity) which possess a charter exempting them from some of the otherwise-applicable provisions of that system. There are also private (both for- and non-profit) schools outside the official public education system (in some jurisdictions, these may get partial public subsidies for students via vouchers.)
- stevenwoo 7y agoThere is a popular theory (with some statistical backing) that the main purpose of charter schools is to continue-increase segregation. The history of the USA is marked by the original sin of slavery- it’s in our founding documents and has powerful influence on politics even today. Schools for under 18 is publicly funded but private schools are nominally not publicly funded, so they do not have to obey a lot of strings attached to federal assistance. Charter schools are used in some areas as a work around to get segregation publicly funded.(where poor people are excluded and it turns out surprise - a lot of those people are not white.) of course there are exceptions or charter schools in urban areas that are majority Minority but even 20 years ago when I lived in Texas charter schools were transparent segregation to exclude minorities. Public schools have to take everyone. A school that doesn’t allow everyone in can eliminate low performing kids and juke the stats so it looks like a great school on paper.
- lemmsjid 7y agoThis rings true, and the reason you will see some charters with minorities is that it is classist as well as racist. When deciding to send our child to public school, suddenly people around us were feeding us with this really cloudy liberal version of classism/racism. Which was basically that: "While we love underprivileged people, if your child is in a school full of underprivileged people, they might not thrive as well as if they were in fancy charter school X." Prefaced by a few sentences started by the wonderful pseudo-scientific canard, "studies have shown...!" I have come to the belief that this country is ultimately not culturally committed to the notion that equal opportunity comes from education, and that every child should actually get equal opportunity. Even for the most 'liberal' people, it's wrapped up in so much existential fear around their child succeeding in an increasingly competitive rat race that requires absolute educational and developmental perfection until they get into a prestigious university. The recent celebrity college admission scandals are a symbol of this kind of thing, especially given that the families involved were already wealthy enough to support their children into adulthood. I hope I am wrong.
- the_af 7y agoWow. It's not just your country, it's like you're talking about mine! In my country the same conversations take place, only it's "public school" vs "private schools". And public schools used to be top notch here, but thanks to decades of lowering budgets and teacher salaries they are now in critical condition :( This of course reinforces this notion that they are ok for underprivileged people, but if you have the money you should send your kids to a private school :(