4 ms·
It’s an interesting hypothetical. Even in a world where people went for it, I’d worry about the implementation, though—for I don’t know of a single example of a
by derefr 7y ago
It’s an interesting hypothetical. Even in a world where people went for it, I’d worry about the implementation, though—for I don’t know of a single example of a country where wards of the state (i.e. children in orphanages or “in the foster system”) have even average educational attainment or lifetime salary growth. Governments—even the very nice ones that top the OCED indices—don’t seem to be very good at producing educated, productive wards.
(Which is strange, actually, because the outcomes are completely different for kids that go through most governments’ military academies. Maybe no government is held to a standard where it needs to take the civic education of wards seriously; but is motivated to train the members of its military regardless of extrinsic motivation?)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Governments—even the very nice ones that top the OCED indices—don’t seem to be very good at producing educated, productive wards. I think this is in large part due to the simultaneous existence of children raised in the traditional fashion, often by the politicians crafting the system for the wards. A generous imagination would suppose that when the entire society relies on the system and is itself a product of that system, there'd be higher incentive to make it effective.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoEven with the most generous imagination to the incentive toward making the system effective, that doesn't mean that the results would be good. What happens when your kid needs a hug? You give them a hug. What happens when a ward of the state needs a hug? In the age of "me too", of awareness of abuse of the helpless by those with power, the person in charge of the children may not be allowed to give them a hug. Even if they are, they may have 30 kids. Hugs will therefore be less frequent per kid, because the adult doesn't have the time to do that plus take care of the 30 kids in all the other ways that are needed. Kids need to be loved. Bureaucrats don't love. Even day care workers don't love in the way that parents love. But this much is true: If all the children were raised as wards of the state, then the children involved would have average educational attainment and lifetime salary growth, by definition. That doesn't mean that the outcome would be good, though.
- watwut 7y agoReality check: kids in orphanages were not lovingly hugged prior meetoo. They were often abused, physically and verbally by both adults and other kids. They were also sexually abused.
- wbl 7y agoSparta did it. At age 7 children would live in the barracks until adulthood.
- watwut 7y agoSparta was effectively fascistic system. Not even some kind of super succesfull. Not really success overall if you care about peoples well being. Communists took a lot of kids to institutions too and it was crap too.