6 ms·
> I am quite impressed with it so far. Installation was a breeze, it compiles the kernel on 32 cores from spinning rust in 4m15s Does anyone know how this comp
by nicoburns 7y ago
> I am quite impressed with it so far. Installation was a breeze, it compiles the kernel on 32 cores from spinning rust in 4m15s
Does anyone know how this compares to a recent x86 machine? This seems quite fast for the entire kernel, but I have no idea what typical build times are like.
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoIt's competitive with x86_64. Here are some more comprehensive benchmarks: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=blackbird-power9-4c&num=1 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=blackbir...
- greatpatton 7y agoThis one is a little more relevant for a server: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=rome-power9-arm&num=1 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=rome-pow...
- mrslave 7y ago2m3.673s; default config with loadable modules disabled; make -m 32. This is on a second-last generation 24C/48T Xeon (albeit a slower one) with all of the known speculative execution vulnerabilities mitigated except spec_store_bypass, and SMT still enabled (because htop is prettier with more pretend CPUs).
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoWhat's the I/O situation? I did my build from an HDD, WD Blue. Also, kernel config matters a lot - I used yesterday's master branch from Linus, with Alpine Linux 3.10's ppc64le config, plus olddefconfig to catch it up.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tpearson-raptor 7y ago24 core ppc64le system, 5.4-rc2, defconfig, loadable modules on and built: real 1m55.267s Run from tmpfs, all protections from Spectre etc. on. Not too bad, really!
- JackRabbitSlim 7y agoThe trick is far fewer modules and compile time options. A fun benchmark would be a Power9 Vs a X86_64 cross compiling the same ARM64 kernel. I wouldn't bet heavily on the Power9...
- smcl 7y agoI agree, but I’m really curious if this is just because the commonly used compilers & libraries aren’t particularly optimised for ppc64le (which is a guess) or whether the hardware itself cannot match the equivalent Xeon and Ryzen offerings Not that this matters to the end user, but it is still interesting IMO
- tpearson-raptor 7y agoI might take that bet core for core, matched node size (i.e. 14nm), run out of tmpfs or NVMe storage, and with both systems protected against Spectre, Meltdown etc. (i.e. no cheating by ignoring the ISA specifications)... Slightly OT, but if you limit the playing field to open ISA / fully owner controlled systems, POWER9 is so far out front in terms of performance that it looks like an outlier. ;)
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoA race of one is easily won :)
- tpearson-raptor 7y agoWell, to be fair I was thinking of the SiFive RISC-V board as one of the competitors, since my understanding was they did finally open the rest of their firmware a while back. However, yes, by far most of the remaining owner controlled systems are even smaller -- some of the smaller (older) ARM Chromebooks (sans GPU, of course), the BeagleBone black, those kinds of systems.
- Sir_Cmpwn 7y agoYeah, I also have a HiFive Unleashed which is totally open, but it doesn't really aim to compete with Raptor iiuc. Until recently it also won out on open ISA, too, and the Blackbird has to be bootstrapped by the ARM BMC - which is a nonfree ISA. Power consumption is another story as well. Raptor systems is definitely the only realistic competitor to x86_64, though, for desktop and server use-cases.
- rwmj 7y agoIt'll depend on the kernel configuration. I don't know about the Raptor, however I have some experience with IBM's POWER9 servers and they do have tremendous single thread performance and many cores, and are quite a bit faster than Intel Xeons (although at a considerably higher price, but the customers usually need the performance and aren't too sensitive about price).
- loudmax 7y agoIncidentally, I'm pretty sure that Sir_Cmpwn meant 32 threads, not 32 cores. Raptor sells an 8-core CPU bundle, and those cores are SMT4 capable, meaning 4 threads per core. So it will appear as 32 CPUs if you run `htop` or `cat /proc/cpuinfo` in Linux. Raptor does sell a 22-core SMT4 capable CPU, which, Yikes! that's a lot of computing power. That Blackbird bundle seems like a beast. The Phoronix benchmarks show it outperformed by high end x86 chips though. I wonder if some of that comes down to gcc optimizations because x86 has been around longer.
- loeg 7y agoSpinning rust may well be the bottleneck here.