3 ms·
>You're pretty invested in being an American, skin in the game, manifest destiny etc. That's probably where you lose most of the US audience. One of the bigges
by whatshisface 7y ago
>You're pretty invested in being an American, skin in the game, manifest destiny etc.
That's probably where you lose most of the US audience. One of the biggest differences between American and Chinese culture is that manifest destiny is mostly dead in America, but it isn't in China. Of course America has multinationals jockeying for global power, but that doesn't reflect how the voters think.
- glitchc 7y agoAmericans still think of themselves as the best in the world. If that is not manifest destiny, then what is it?
- whatshisface 7y agoFrom Wikipedia, >Manifest destiny was a widely held belief in the 19th century United States that its settlers were destined to expand across North America. The average American does not think that America should expand any further throughout the world, nor do they think that America has an irresistible duty to remake the world in its image. The theme of "the special virtues of the American people and their institutions" is only one part of the definition of manifest destiny. Also, if you've ever read an HN thread on public mass transit, I think there is evidence against the claim that Americans think that all of their institutions are the best in the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manifest_destiny https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manifest_destiny
- glitchc 7y agoA thread on HN is a far cry from what a typical American thinks. America doesn’t need to take over other nations in the parochial sense. Rather the number of bases the US has established throughout the world accomplish manifest destiny in a modern fashion. No other country has or has ever had this level or scale of military deployment.
- sho 7y agoI didn't really want to bash on the US too hard but yeah. America has over five hundred overseas military bases. To say no other country even comes close is an understatement. I'm not even saying the US overseas forces are bad. They've been misused, yes, but I don't want to argue about that - it's complicated. To disclaim America's outsize global ambitions, however - for whatever purpose - is just laughable.
- yazaddaruvala 7y agoThe American government may have some “outsize global ambitions” however the American people don’t want any global expansion. In fact I hear more about Cascadia or Texas seceding than I do about the USA adding new states or territories.
- CrystalLangUser 7y agoThat has nothing to do with manifest destiny or even the average American. People are almost completely unaware of how many bases we have abroad, etc. You are trying to paint a portrait of Americans in general that is flagrantly false.
- glitchc 7y agoI didn’t think I was bashing or portraying a negative statement, rather shedding light on an objective truth. I can understand that Americans don’t know much at all about those bases. But they do know how much their military is costing (in broad terms) and are happy to continue supporting that. Much evidence points to the sentiment that the US behaves like a modern-day Rome and has attempted (or is attempting) to achieve “Pax Americana” globally. Again, not necessarily a bad concept as the world could always use more stability.
- munmaek 7y ago> But they do know how much their military is costing (in broad terms) and are happy to continue supporting that. Many people explicitly hate this and want to see money diverted from that to stuff like education, etc. Americans aren't one singular unit that agree on issues, especially things like foreign policy.
- blakesterz 7y agoI think maybe not everyone outside the US thinks of "manifest destiny" the same way? In the US we learned "Manifest Destiny" as a part of US history, and very specific time in our country's history. It's the name of a time period, not just someone thinking about "manifest destiny". (at least that's the feeling I get from reading the comments here, I could be wrong, just hoping to clarify)
- stronglikedan 7y agoPatriotism. A noble trait that everyone should possess and covet.
- yazaddaruvala 7y agoUnclear if you’re sarcastic or not. At least in North American high schools we are taught pretty thoroughly that Nationalism was the root cause of both WW1 and WW2. I’m Canadian and while we are proud to be Canadian, Nationalism is looked at very skeptically and Nationalism for its own sake would make me think the person preaching it is uneducated.
- stronglikedan 7y agoPatriotism isn't nationalism.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jbattle 7y agoGo read the comment section on Breitbart or Fox or Red State. American Exceptionalism is still gospel truth for ~half the country
- whatshisface 7y agoAmerican exceptionalism isn't the same thing as manifest destiny. Republicans might be patriotic but most do not support wars of conquest or global expansionism. In fact, the "America first" slogan that recently helped win an election has been attacked as isolationist.
- jbattle 7y agoYou're right. I read 'manifest destiny' as short hand for "USA USA!" boosterism. China obviously isn't an expansionist colonial power either. But I concede the point that Manifest Destiny really hasn't been an active doctrine in our lifetime. Maaaaybe if you look at the Project for the New American Century with the right lens.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mistermann 7y ago> China obviously isn't an expansionist colonial power either. Maybe not colonial in a ~legal sense, but some of the deals they're doing with weaker countries seem designed to grant them significant power.
- sho 7y ago> American exceptionalism isn't the same thing as manifest destiny Sorry, you're probably right. I confess I'm not really aware of the exact difference. I meant the general feeling of "America is the best", which I think is pretty undeniable, at least as the rest of the world experiences it. My point was to contrast it with the Chinese, who have the exact same feeling.
- bhauer 7y ago
- pwinnski 7y agoYou might be getting hung up on the words "manifest destiny," but the belief definitely persists even though the label has fallen out of favor.
- ukoki 7y agoAre you sure? "America First" was a pretty popular Trump slogan (that spawned some excellent parodies: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELD2AwFN9Nc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELD2AwFN9Nc)