3 ms·
The best response to the Drake opinion, IMO, is Tipler's point that if even one civilization created and sent out a von Neumann machine just a million years ago
by btilly 16y ago
The best response to the Drake opinion, IMO, is Tipler's point that if even one civilization created and sent out a von Neumann machine just a million years ago, they'd be here by now. So the fact that we don't see them all over suggests that they do not exist at all.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Neumann_probe#Implications_for_Fermi.27s_paradox http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Neumann_probe#Implications_....
It should be noted that if our civilization survives another few hundred years, we are likely to send out von Neumann machines.
- Confusion 16y agoWe are? I find that a rather bold assertion. The main problem of the von Neumann machine is gathering and transforming enough materials on its own. If we need enormous amounts of ore and factories to do that, so does the machine. It would need to be mindboggingly huge, also because it needs enough fuel to reach new sources. A tiny machine won't work, because it can't refine it's own materials. Really, the practical problems are being hugely underestimated.