5 ms·
> Why the notion that gov't should be the provider & arbiter of all? Because the government is democratically elected. Billionaires are not. > Why do none of
by AlexandrB 7y ago
> Why the notion that gov't should be the provider & arbiter of all?
Because the government is democratically elected. Billionaires are not.
> Why do none of the "they don't pay enough taxes" crowd not realize the rich do so much of, and more efficiently, what the gov't purports to with massive overhead?
[citation needed] In fact, there's an easy counter-example. Healthcare. More expensive than any public system, with worse outcomes for the general population.
- thrower123 7y agoDemocracy just means you managed to convince more idiots to say A rather than B. It's not like it is really an admirable state of affairs. Billionaires have to at least be competent enough to make their money, and shelter it from the thieving governments and other leeches that are trying to suck it away from them.
- SolaceQuantum 7y ago"Billionaires have to at least be competent enough to make their money, and shelter it from the thieving governments and other leeches that are trying to suck it away from them." Is this actually true? At having that much money you can hire someone to be competent for you in wealth management.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>It's not like it [democracy] is really an admirable state of affairs. So, what is an "admirable state of affairs" if democracy is so objectionable to you?
- ctdonath 7y agoIndividual liberty. Individuals choosing to engage in mutually beneficial activities, rather than being told at implied gunpoint to do what a bunch of ignorant strangers, or a tyrannical dictator, decided.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>Billionaires have to at least be competent enough to make their money, and shelter it from the thieving governments and other leeches etc etc etc and >rather than being told at implied gunpoint to do what a bunch of ignorant strangers You are clearly emotionally driven on this issue so it's probably best that I step out of this discussion. You have a good day guy.
- ctdonath 7y agoI'm fact driven. Democracy is, literally, a majority deciding what laws all must adhere to. They don't know/care about a minority's circumstances/needs/choices, yet impose their ill-informed will through the police power of the state (to wit, obey or we'll use force increasing up to and including death). Show me how that's not true.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> Show me how that's not true. Stating an insane position, even one with internal logic, and then saying "show me how that's not true" does not make your position either correct or convincing. What's more, your position is very much the one in the minority. It is incumbent upon you to convince us, or else you will simply be ignored. You haven't done anything like a credible attempt to do so.
- jazzyk 7y agoI agree with you on the democracy point, however: Only 56% of all billionaires are self-made. Others inherited their money (the Walton family, the Rockefellers, eetc.) https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/10/wealthx-billionaire-census-majority-of-worlds-billionaires-self-made.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/10/wealthx-billionaire-census-m...
- malvosenior 7y agoI trust politicians as much as I trust billionaires: not at all. In fact as the OP points out at least the occasional billionaire will do something productive for society. The same can't be said for the government. > [citation needed] In fact, there's an easy counter-example. Healthcare. More expensive than any public system, with worse outcomes for the general population. The only reason health care is so expensive in the US is because of government regulations. From doctor accreditation, FDA approval, health insurance "marketplace" rules... The government is the single largest force pushing up the price of health care.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> The same can't be said for the government. Sure, if we pretend roads, emergency services, public schools, safer cars, hell, the very Internet we're posting on don't exist. > The only reason health care is so expensive in the US is because of government regulations. And yet, highly regulated, government-run European healthcare costs half what it does here.
- marmadukester39 7y agoSo you want uncertified doctors, unvetted medications and health insurers to be able to do whatever they want to their captive customers. Got it.
- roenxi 7y agoYou seem to have grasped the essence of the argument, except that health insurers wouldn't have captive customers because the captivity is enforced largely by government regulations. The point is that mandatory certification of doctors, medications vetted through a highly risk averse process and having no flexibility in dealing with health insurers all secure better outcomes at a cost that nobody apart from the government thinks is reasonable. If anyone had a choice, which they do not, they would probably choose something cheaper. It is lovely that surgeons are all wealthy, articulate, over-educated polymaths with numerous hobbies and interests (and can probably play a musical instrument, I don't know), etc, etc, except it isn't actually obvious why they need all that. At the end of the day a surgeon needs experience, steady hands and an aversion to doing things that are not necessary. And when tested people will prefer cheap with a good reputation to overqualified but approved by some guild. It isn't like accidents don't already happen. Can't escape from risk using bureaucracy; minimising risk at all costs is a sign that people are making bad decisions.
- rayiner 7y ago> More expensive than any public system, with worse outcomes for the general population. That presupposes the US would have a cheaper system if it were public. (Also most European systems aren’t “public systems” but that’s a separate issue.) We spend more per student on our public education system than almost every other OECD country, to get far worse results. Our public transit systems spend several times as much money per mile to build transit, again to get worse results. There are scant few examples of the US public sector being competitive with those of well-run European countries. (In fact I can’t think of any.) Remarkably, Canada’s non-military government spending per person is lower than America’s non-military government spending, and Canada offers significantly more services for less money. I don’t think it is at all clear that costs wouldn’t go up under a public healthcare system in the US.
- bilbo0s 7y ago>I don’t think it is at all clear that costs wouldn’t go up under a public healthcare system in the US. I'm a simple mathematician, so I'll admit that I tend to look at issues where numbers are involved a bit too simply sometimes. Having mentioned that, shouldn't it be self-evident that costs will go up? You'd essentially be playing an actuarial/insurance game and on-boarding an enormous number of new beneficiaries. Naturally costs will go up. Costs per capita will go up as well due to issues like logistics. Issues that are avoided currently by, for example, simply not providing services in certain areas. (I suppose issues like logistics are not so much "avoided", as they are "offloaded". For instance, people in rural america where senior citizens sometimes have to drive 60 miles to get emergency services.) On the flip side of all that, I suppose the entire point of government healthcare is to provide necessary services for people who are not currently being served. So at least we can see the benefits of the extra money in the goveernmental case. ie - everyone is served. Which can't be said for the current system despite its enormous expense.
- smeyer 7y agoI'm not an expert on what costs would do under a public healthcare system, but I think "self-evident that costs will go up" is very much wrong. You add new beneficiaries, but you also change major cost centers. For example, the healthcare industry spends a lot of time and money on medical billing, on the side of providers sending bills and insurers paying them. Clearly some of this would be reflected in new and different bureaucracy, but probably less of it (and certainly not self-evidently more). Also, preventative care can be much better than reactive care. Sure, a public health care provider would have to spend more money on insulin for diabetics when all of them are covered, but maybe it will spend less on emergency room visits for patients who suffer serious complications of poorly managed diabetes and can't pay the ER bill.
- jandrewrogers 7y ago> More expensive than any public system, with worse outcomes for the general population. US public schools are also more expensive than any public system, with worse outcomes for the general population. These are operated by the government. There is little evidence that making a service "public" will make it less expensive to operate, quite the opposite. The underlying cause of relatively expensive US services is not who is operating it, as they are expensive no matter who does.
- ctdonath 7y agoBecause the government is democratically elected. Tyranny of the majority is a bad thing.
- aries1980 7y ago> Because the government is democratically elected. Billionaires are not. Billionaires are as much democratically elected via purchase. Noone put a gun to our head to use AWS use Google or buy a car. On the other hand, political party campaigns require billionaires' cash. Doesn't look so democratic.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> > Why the notion that gov't should be the provider & arbiter of all? > Because the government is democratically elected. We didn't democratically elect them to be the provider and arbiter of all. In fact, we deliberately designed a system where there are limits on what the government can do, because we didn't want the government to be the provider and arbiter of all.
- foogazi 7y agowhat is more democratic than letting people choose we’re their money goes to directly?