3 ms·
I agree with your poing, but Mars is earth-like and it could have carried life ... There is evidence that Mars once carried liquid water on its surface, it's f
by bad_user 16y ago
I agree with your poing, but Mars is earth-like and it could have carried life ...
There is evidence that Mars once carried liquid water on its surface, it's formed out of the same materials (carbon, hydrogen, water) and had all the elements needed for life. Mars lost its liquid water because (contrary to earth) it lost its atmosphere because it also lacks active plate tectonics (also, contrary to earth).
So our solar system has 2 earth-like planets ... with one that became a desert and died, but that was once very much like Earth, with some people still hoping to find microscopic life at the poles.
That's not too shabby. Basically it is considered that if a planet holds liquid water, then it can carry life (liquid water implies other things, like the presence of an atmosphere). Bigger solar systems may contain even more earth-like planets, but I agree: an average of 2 is way too high.
EDIT:
Also, one other thing: if Mars wouldn't have lost its atmosphere, then oxygen would have spread faster than on earth, because the planet is smaller, which means the transition from microscopic life to macro would have been faster.
- eru 16y agoOr the oxygen would have just managed to kill everything.
- chc 16y agoVenus is also very Earthlike (potentially much more than Mars in the past) and could have had liquid water and life before the runaway greenhouse effect.
- jerf 16y agoThat's what I meant by "it depends on your definition of Earth-like". Mars and Venus are at least debatable, many of the planets being reported as "Earths" in the media aren't. (Yet. I freely acknowledge this will change, and soon. I have no doubt that we will find rocky planets of the approximate right size in the approximate right orbit in the near future. Getting a bead on their chemistry and such is going to be a lot harder for a while, though, but we'll crack that too, eventually.) I tend to favor "actually capable of supporting life" but the equation doesn't seem to actually require that. Mars has the strike against it that it is arguably on the frozen side of the zone of life. Earth is actually already on the somewhat cold side and has spent a fairly large portion of its life as an ice planet; some have speculated that our frequent ice ages have contributed to our diversity of life by moderately predictable periodic mass extinctions, but of course this is just a theory in all the bad senses of that phrase. Venus is possibly too far on the hot side but I have an easier time envisioning life on a relatively hot planet than a relatively cold one. We have extremophiles here on Earth and who knows what they'd be able to evolve into if they weren't in such a small niche? Whereas cold really puts a stopper on life; a critter can evolve that can survive being frozen and possibly even carry on simple life functions but only at a very slow rate, and for all we talk about how fast and robust life is it does not take very much slowdown of life before you can't get an intelligent civilization evolved before the sun ceases to support life. Life is thought to be ~3.5 billion years old here, and it's hard to pin down exactly how long the sun could sustain non-intelligent life but it could be as little as ~1 billion years. Cold life has a real challenge getting to intelligence in time. (Also why I don't spend any time wondering about life in nebulas; they may be a science-fiction staple but at the rate they could live they don't have enough time to evolve into anything interesting before the heat death of the universe.)