4 ms·
It's really not a matter of ideology, it's a matter of law. They either comply with Chinese law, or they risk their employees being arrested for breaking the la
by simonh 7y ago
It's really not a matter of ideology, it's a matter of law. They either comply with Chinese law, or they risk their employees being arrested for breaking the law, or they stop doing business in China.
I think they would argue that, given that all phones are subject to state surveillance, iPhone users in China are no worse off than if they were using another phone. Also since iPhones are generally a lot more secure than other phones against non-state attacks, they are actually better off than they would otherwise be.
That's a tough call. I have family in China, since my wife is Chinese, and they have iPhones. Would they be better off if Apple pulled out of Chine or worse off?
Well, they chose iPhones and they are more secure so isn't it up to them? They wouldn't thank me if I took their iPhones away. On the other hand, if Apple pulled out of China on privacy grounds, it would be massive news. It would not be something the Chinese government could ignore, and might conceivably raise awareness of pervasive state surveillance in China.
But people in China are already very much aware of pervasive state surveillance. They even have a social credit system based on watching everything they do. Chinese state control of public narratives is so total, I actually doubt it would make any difference.
- Krasnol 7y agoWasn't it "the law" also when they came up with the privacy claim around that terrorist case where the FBI needed access to a device? I mean, in the end it's the same thing as the classic "I didn't do anything wrong, I've been following orders".
- saagarjha 7y agoThe FBI specifically asked Apple to backdoor that device, rather than handing over encryption keys that they already kept.
- simonh 7y agoI'm finding it difficult to parse what you mean here. In that case Apple successfully fought the FBI demand, within the law. Had the law required them to render assistance I'm sure they would have done so, otherwise they would have been requiring their employees to break the law. Under what circumstances do you think it is acceptable for a company to require it's employees to incriminate themselves?
- Krasnol 7y agoNot really, "appealed the ruling, but then dropped the case on April 22 after it was given the correct passcode". > Under what circumstances do you think it is acceptable for a company to require it's employees to incriminate themselves? Human rights violations should be more than enough.
- m0xte 7y agoThere's a fatal flaw to this approach though. The world is regressing into surveillance because quite frankly the mechanisms are already there and it's easy. What happens if someone in the US or the UK start using the justification of "well you did this in China so we'll legislate so you do that here". Someone has to make a stand and the people running the apparatus purposed to make this possible are morally culpable for the outcome to some degree for making it technically possible to do so. The world is not that a big place. It doesn't take a lot for this to end up on everyone's laps and then it's too late to say I told you so.
- simonh 7y agoApple don't run the apparatus in China, they refused to do so. iCloud services in China are run by a Chinese company. We can't outsource our responsibility as citizens of democracies to a corporation. Apple has done a heck of a lot more than most of us on HN in this fight, by standing up to unreasonable law enforcement requests for access to iPhone data, when the other phone companies rolled over. How much have you done on that front recently? A heck of a lot less than Apple, I'm willing to wager.
- m0xte 7y agoSo refusing to run it then franchising it out to a less respectable organisation under the same brand is an approach that is morally acceptable? Let's skip the whataboutism in these threads. That solves nothing. Incidentally I do a lot more than most people do on this matter.
- bduerst 7y ago>It's really not a matter of ideology, it's a matter of law. The FBI requesting a backdoor to terrorist iphones was the exact same: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_San_Bernardino_attack#Phone_decryption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_San_Bernardino_attack#Pho... Apple decided to comply with China to keep access to the market.