5 ms·
Wingo is responding to an argument that could be made by some readers, and which Wingo believes is asserted by "many (most?) GNU developers". He does not believ
by eesmith 7y ago
Wingo is responding to an argument that could be made by some readers, and which Wingo believes is asserted by "many (most?) GNU developers". He does not believe it to be a valid argument.
Under your definition of straw man (which I believe is incorrect; see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man ), it would be a straw man only if so few people were presenting that argument that it doesn't make sense to even bring up, in order to reject it.
I believe there are enough people who believe that Stallman is the leader of the GNU project that it's worthwhile to bring up.
I think a "strawman argument" is more like one where I point out that Stallman says he is involved in making GNU project decisions, and ask when those decisions are, then you point out that he cannot be involved in making GNU license changes which break legally binding obligations.
The structureless essay has come up many times before on HN - search the archive for comments.