7 ms·
Senator Al Franken: No joke, Comcast trying to whack Netflix
- patrickgzill 16y agoMaybe I should send the Senator my comment on Comcast's blog when they posted their letter complaining about Netflix, which did not get approved by their moderator: ==== I am a Comcast residential HSI customer, and have many clients who are business HSI Comcast customers. At the same time, I do maintain servers in my own racks at a datacenter. What is not mentioned in this letter, is that Comcast is already being paid - by me, and by every other customer, for access to the content. Note that Comcast has never said that the Level3/Netflix issue is about users exceeding their allotted bandwidth (currently at about 250GB/month for residential); presumably, were a Comcast user to use 249GB of bandwidth downloading cute pictures of cats, Comcast would have no objection. It appears to be the specific issue that Netflix is a possible competitor to Comcast's TV business, that somehow causes Comcast to decide that there is a problem. Understand this: every Netflix video to be streamed, is specifically requested by a Comcast user, operating under the Comcast-advertised "High Speed Internet" service and presumably within the bandwidth caps that Comcast's own contract allows. That Comcast presumes to have the right to limit, modify, or decide for me which pieces of the Internet I can have access to, removes Comcast's common carrier protections, calls into question the truth of your (meaning Comcast) advertisements for the HSI service, and raises the issue of whether Comcast is dealing in bad faith with each and every Comcast HSI subscriber. ====
- mikeryan 16y agoI'm probably going to get downmodded for this because its unpopular to side with the big guys. But.. The Netflix/Level3/Comcast dustup was not a net neutrality issue. It was a peering disagreement. Comcast pays Level3 to be a transit provider, so they pay to connect to Level3's network. Traditional CDN's such as Akamai and Limelight pay Comcast in order to get a direct pipe into Comcast's network. Level3 in the meantime was charging Netflix as a CDN since they already had a direct pipe into Comcast's network as a transit provider. So in essence Comcast was paying Level3 to act as a CDN as opposed to the other way around. While Level3 quickly screamed "Net Neutrality" when Comcast wanted to fix the agreement, that was just a smokescreen for a peering issue. EDIT (Shimon has covered this as well http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2121472 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2121472)
- mattmcknight 16y agoPeering agreements have been falling apart for years. There are numerous cases where it is not clear, even to a disinterested observer, who should be paying whom. If we get net neutrality or the like, I think at some level the thing that will ultimately disappear is the unlimited traffic packages available to the consumer as the heavily connected are being subsidized by those paying for a high speed connection but not sucking large amounts of data. If the ISPs can't charge the providers of those packets, they are going to have to charge the people requesting them.
- patrickgzill 16y agoThe reality is that Comcast never raises the issue over transit to e.g. ICanHasCheezburger. Do you not see that Netflix competes directly with the Comcast sister offering of cable TV and video on demand? This is a test case to determine how to "tax" every content provider for access to Comcast customers; who as I mention, are already paying for access to the Internet.
- mikeryan 16y agoComcast never raised this issue with Netflix specifically. They raised it with everyone using Level3 as a CDN, if ICanHasCheezburger is using Level3 as a CDN then it got raised. Netflix's volume of traffic over Level3 is likely what made it a pressing concern. I'm well aware of Comcast's dislike of Netflix. Probably better then most. But a vast amount of data being thrown around on these networks is video, most of it by Netflix. While there are net neutrality concerns there, there are also legit network stability and infrastructure concerns.
- patrickgzill 16y agoYou say "there are also legit network stability and infrastructure concerns" I would like to ask, "how do you know this"? Also, would reference my original point - "Comcast has a residential cap of 250GB/month as being acceptable usage by a customer" - if a Netflix user is staying within that limit, and if Comcast is having problems - they deliberately under-engineered their network, yes?
- dantheman 16y agoYou clearly don't know what you're talking about. Do you think Akamai should pay to transfer data to Comcast? (They Do) If yes, why shouldn't L3? If not, then how should peering agreements work?
- jbri 16y agoInterestingly, if Akamai had decided to terminate their peering agreement with Comcast and route their traffic through Level 3 instead, the situation from Comcast's end would be basically the same. Would that still be justification to cry foul? Would Level 3 be abusing their situation as a top-level transit provider by ... providing transit?
- wmf 16y agoIt appears to be the specific issue that Netflix is a possible competitor to Comcast's TV business, that somehow causes Comcast to decide that there is a problem. Actually, I think Comcast's plan is to increase profit margins by squeezing everyone, regardless of what business they're in. Hence the deliberately congested Tata transit links. removes Comcast's common carrier protections Sigh. Common carrier never applied to ISPs to begin with.
- patrickgzill 16y agoThe congested Tata links are a problem. I am close to dumping Comcast and going with the other monopoly (DSL via telco) but am not sure how switching between two companies in what is essentially a duopoly helps things... They are not common carriers, but, they are given protection similar to common carrier in both the DMCA and certain other laws/regs that cover similar ground.
- Locke1689 16y agoThey are not common carriers, but, they are given protection similar to common carrier in both the DMCA and certain other laws/regs that cover similar ground. The protection is similar but the concept is completely different. Common carrier is based on providing a public or general service and, in return, being indemnified from certain damages. ISPs have no such requirements or responsibilities, they just have complete indemnity. You seem to think they have a responsibility to not discriminate. They don't. They never have. That's what net neutrality is trying to do, but until then they're basically free and clear.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 16y agoAl Franken is not "informed". He is a hollywood shill who happens to fall on Netflix's side this time. http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20101118/10291211924/the-19-senators-who-voted-to-censor-the-internet.shtml http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20101118/10291211924/the-19...
- loewenskind 16y agoThat's a pretty strong ad hominem attack. I didn't like Al Franken until he got elected and started doing a lot of things that make sense (e.g. his proposed bill to fix how rating agencies work, while not getting rid of rating agencies as a private market).
- protomyth 16y agoI watched his housing rants he gave (a couple were on C-SPAN) where he was talking about loans being "too hard" to get. How banks needed to loan to poorer people. This was before the collapse and we all discovered the opposite was true. His voting is pro-Hollywood and he seems to have an influence on MN's other Senator. It isn't ad hominem when he votes and speaks to the point.
- loewenskind 16y agoSo he's more social, while believing in protecting artists. That doesn't make him a "shill" per se. One might find his politics naive but you're accusing him of being disingenuous. Everything I know about him (admittedly not a great deal) says he's at least consistent.
- protomyth 16y agoWell, you probably missed the whole "fined for not carrying workers' compensation insurance" episode. He spouts one thing and does another in practice. I would say that is fairly disingenuous.
- mark_l_watson 16y agoI am reading Tim Wu's excellent book "The Master Switch" right now that is relevant to Franken's concerns. Covers corporate takeovers of information systems starting in the late 1800s.
- joelhaus 16y agoTim Wu recently discussed these issues on CSPAN and I posted his interview on Charlie Rose a few days ago (videos): http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/TheMas http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/TheMas http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2080742 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2080742 Warning: put in a historic context, he predicts a somewhat disheartening outcome. A cringe worthy update from the CEO's of Time Warner and AT&T. Straight from horses mouth [starts at 18:40], the two share their perspectives on regulation, innovation and the net (recorded on 1/12/11): http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/InnovativeI http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/InnovativeI Summary: Innovation requires less tax, less regulation. Pleased with recent FCC rules on net neutrality.
- shimon 16y agoLevel 3 did a great job spinning this into public outrage. Here's what actually happened: 1. Level3 started offering CDN services. By leveraging their existing peering relationships (as a tier 1 ISP) they could essentially subsidize the transit costs of the CDN business, compared to e.g. Akamai which had been paying Comcast for peering to reach Comcast customers. 2. Netflix got a good offer for CDN services from Level3, and switched a bunch of their content from Akamai to Level3's CDN. 3. Comcast therefore saw a bunch of paid traffic turn into unpaid traffic overnight, and complained. This is a business dispute between two self-interested parties. Is it really fair for Level3 to use their position in the ISP business to undercut competitors in a new CDN business? Was it fair a few years ago when Akamai caved and agreed to pay Comcast for peering? Will it be fair for Comcast to use a newly acquired media property to exact revenge on Netflix/Level3? The problem with Network Neutrality is that it takes a complex issue, the product of many complex business relationships, and frames it in a black-or-white context. The history here is complicated, and the only thing I'm sure of is that everyone's a bad guy sometimes.
- wmf 16y agoI agree that either Akamai and Level 3 should both pay (for all traffic flowing into Comcast; whether it's "CDN" traffic or "regular" traffic makes no difference) or neither should pay. Since they're both saving Comcast money, I'm leaning towards neither. It's unfortunate for everyone else that Akamai apparently set this precedent.
- leot 16y agoThe problem with Network Neutrality is that it's very easy to see the development of a monopoly/oligopoly that will have near complete control of the world's most valuable man-made resource. When it comes to the corporate behavior, only the most cynical predictions have been at all reliable. Those sanguine about the result of absolute freedom-of-action by internet providers clearly have little sense of history. God forbid that internet access become a relatively unprofitable commodity rather than an utterly complicated, multi-tiered service in which profit is extracted through the creation of an artificial shortage.
- 16y ago
- btipling 16y agoI don't understand why the government should create regulation to tell private companies what to do with their property in this case. I think a lot of the 'net neutrality' hubbub is irrational driven panic. If you don't like the service they provide just pay for something else that does. Running to the government every time a company does something that inconviences you as a user strikes me as dangerous. This isn't life saving health care, the vast majority of the arguments and infographics highlight the many shows you might not be able to watch or websites you might not be able to access. I'm sorry but your need to catch the latest Glee or access your friends update on Facebook aren't a convincing enough argument to agree to letting the feds regulate what private companies do with their business. Let the downvotes commence.
- yequalsx 16y agoHere's the problem, in my view, with your position " If you don't like the service they provide just pay for something else that does. " In many localities there aren't many options for high speed internet service. The fear is that ISPs will find it easier to form a cartel and exact tolls than to compete with each other on service.
- dantheman 16y agoThen that is the problem, ask yourself why that is? Oh yeah, its because the local government gives monopolies to certain companies. That is the root of the problem, address it there instead of bandaid hacks that break core system.
- tomkinstinch 16y agoIt is not explicit granted monopolies, but more so de facto monopolies arising because the costs for a competitor to enter the ISP business are prohibitively expensive. With material costs, labor costs, and easement costs, it takes a major investment to run a mile of cable. My question is this: Why are fiber lines not administered by public utilities? It works for power and roads.
- ck2 16y ago"Now is the time to decide if we want four or five companies owning and delivering all of our information and entertainment" Way, way too late. It went from 10 to 5 a few years ago. http://www.sarahstirland.com/archives/mediacon.htm http://www.sarahstirland.com/archives/mediacon.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20071025061940/http://www.thenation.com/special/bigten11.swf http://web.archive.org/web/20071025061940/http://www.thenati... http://www.nowfoundation.org/issues/communications/tv/mediacontrol.html http://www.nowfoundation.org/issues/communications/tv/mediac... https://docs.google.com/gview?url=http%3A%2F%2Fadage.com%2Fimages%2Frandom%2Fmediafamilytree07.pdf&docid=416850233c18c6eeebf6c81208b81d38&a=bi&pagenumber=1&w=2000 https://docs.google.com/gview?url=http%3A%2F%2Fadage.com%2Fi... Remember it makes no difference if it's Republican or Democrat they are both pro massive-corporation. Wait until Comcast starts moving it's call centers overseas to increase their profit by reducing US labor costs. If politicians aren't going to fight corporate control of health care decisions for the nation, why do you think they are going to bother about something like the internet.
- billybob 16y ago"they are both pro massive-corporation" More specifically, they are both pro-campaign donations. And it's much easier to court a few big players than thousands of small ones. They may even think they're being fair and objective. But they can only chat with so many lobbyists a day, and the most polished, friendly, helpful, professional ones are - surprise - hired by huge companies.