4 ms·
You can't have 99.99% reliable power, cheap power, transmission through tinerboxes, and hold the utility liable for fires. I expect parts of the Bay Area not i
by dehrmann 7y ago
You can't have 99.99% reliable power, cheap power, transmission through tinerboxes, and hold the utility liable for fires.
I expect parts of the Bay Area not in the hills to not lose power because if you can't clear brush around the high-voltage lines going to urban centers, you have no business being a utility.
- lubujackson 7y agoI'm surprised to see so much unconsidered support for PG&E here. It's not about holding the utility "liable for fires", it is holding them liable for gross negligence by failing to perform critical or routine maintenance. These aren't difficult or impossible problems. The Camp Fire was caused by a system that was significantly overdue for upgrading: https://www.wsj.com/articles/pg-e-knew-for-years-its-lines-could-spark-wildfires-and-didnt-fix-them-11562768885 https://www.wsj.com/articles/pg-e-knew-for-years-its-lines-c... Time and again, PG&E ignored maintenance requirements and funneled profits to execs and stockholders. The San Bruno pipeline explosion was also entirely preventable: https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/How-PG-E-missed-chance-to-avert-San-Bruno-blast-6283494.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/How-PG-E-missed-chanc... What's more, PG&E falsified safety records as a matter of course: https://www.cnn.com/2018/12/15/us/pge-falsifying-records/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/12/15/us/pge-falsifying-records/ind... So PG&E showed tidy profits by ignoring their infrastructure and doing it so completely that their people on the street simply lied about maintaining things because no one cared... until stuff began to systematically began to blow up and burn down: https://www.abc10.com/article/news/investigations/the-history-of-pges-problems/103-b7badd6e-8eea-4ae3-a935-8628ba98b87e https://www.abc10.com/article/news/investigations/the-histor... The problem is one of accountability. PG&E execs roll from court case to court case but face no risk of personal jail time for decisions that have caused tens to hundreds of preventable deaths: https://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-pge-criminal-20160810-snap-story.html https://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-hiltzik-pge-c... So the courts get more and more frustrated, fining PG&E larger and larger amounts. But the utility never actually fix their known problems, they simply pass the bill back to their customers, declare bankruptcy and, at this point, turn off the power preemptively as some sort of power move to try to force government compliance.
- dgoldstein0 7y agoThe thing that bugs me is that as much as we can blame PGE, we also have done an excellent job building flammable houses surrounded by flammable landscaping which makes it very easy for wildfire ashes to collect in nooks and shrubbery and ignite houses from there. That's not PG&E's fault. Building codes apparently changed about a decade ago and are helping the situation, but most of our housing stock is much older. Anyhow there are signs of some political movement on the subject, such as funding for retrofitting. I'm hopeful that pick up. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.denverpost.com/2019/04/11/california-building-code-wildfires/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.denverpost.com/2019/04/11/c...
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>I'm surprised to see so much unconsidered support for PG&E here. California hasn't woken up yet so you've got Europe and the east coast who are mostly impartial observers looking at it and going "yup, while probably not ideal this is not an unreasonable outcome considering the situation."
- yabadabadoes 7y agoyes, though I actually do think it is about as ideal as it can get. The reason Enron didn't change the discussion about privatization into how to undo it is that the US wants privatization to remain legitimate so it can force it on other nations via the IMF and extract wealth like a bad pay day loan company. Companies being afraid to deal with privatization, courts destroying companies for doing it wrong, etc are all gettig the precedent necessary give developing nations options to protect themselves from exploitation that largely originates from California.
- Domenic_S 7y agoCheap? PG&E?
- product50 7y agoWell if you want 100% foolproof fire insulation, PG&E would be multiple times what they are today.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Domenic_S 7y agoWe pay some of the highest power rates in the nation. CA isnt the only state with trees.
- craftyguy 7y agoI realize your comment is not contributing to the discussion, but surely you must know that it's still far cheaper than running your own power plant to generate enough energy to power your home, right?
- dehrmann 7y agoPlaying devil's advocate, someone might point out rooftop solar. The problem with solar is if you're going to play utility, you need batteries. The cost of the panels, installation, batteries, and maintenance add up to enough that if it were cost-effective, utilities would build out more solar. The economies of scale make it cheaper for utilities to manage. You can sell excess power to the utility, but don't expect that to last in its current form. When 95% of customers use at least 10 kWh per day, you can bill for use and ignore the connection fee. When 50% of customers net-use almost zero, the utility still has to maintain the connection and the network, so expect either connection fee or wholesale producer prices. Net metering doesn't scale. Now, if you're in a remote area or one prone to wildfires, solar might actually be cheaper, and PG&E might look more like Solar City for those communities.
- outworlder 7y agoI'm in a city that's not served by PG&E, it's Silicon Valley Power. It's much cheaper than PG&E, more reliable, and as far as I know has not started any fires.
- Pinckney 7y agoSVP has 55 miles of transmission lines. PG&E has 18,466.