4 ms·
>The gov't tries shows of force on rare occasion, and is reminded that's a bad idea. Sorry, when did the US government try a "show of force" on its own soil on
by krapp 7y ago
>The gov't tries shows of force on rare occasion, and is reminded that's a bad idea.
Sorry, when did the US government try a "show of force" on its own soil only to be "reminded" that it was a bad idea?
I don't recall any popular uprisings or coups in the US in recent memory, despite gun owners swearing blood and violence constantly in regards to gun control laws, the IRS, the Supreme Court and any Democrat in office, and the Federal government won the only civil war on record.
As far as I can tell, the only people who have arguably successfully resisted the armed might of the American government have been people who were not Americans, and, ironically, who did so without Second Amendment rights.
- kevinmershon 7y ago> when did the US government try a "show of force" on its own soil only to be "reminded" that it was a bad idea? https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/nov/29/standing-rock-protest-north-dakota-shutdown-evacuation https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/nov/29/standing-roc...
- krapp 7y agoSince we're talking specifically about the Second Amendment doing the "reminding", where are the mass casualties taken by the police and government forces by the armed militia? I'll grant you that it's a protest, but most of the alleged violence described in that story seems to have been committed by the police. Peaceful protesters being beaten and mauled by attack dogs by definition don't count towards a valid argument for the effectiveness of the Second Amendment. The protestors also lost - the pipeline was built, regardless.
- mythrwy 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupation_of_the_Malheur_National_Wildlife_Refuge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occupation_of_the_Malheur_Nati... This probably would have gone down differently had the occupants not been armed. Then the main perpetrators were not convicted in court either.
- krapp 7y ago>This probably would have gone down differently had the occupants not been armed. I don't know, being armed didn't help at Waco or Ruby Ridge. Maybe there were other factors at play in the government's behavior than simply being afraid of an armed group?
- ctdonath 7y agoGov’t was dissuaded from such tactics for long after those & similar instances.
- krapp 7y ago...but not by an effective, armed resistance. So not because the Second Amendment worked as advertised.
- ctdonath 7y agoStop adding qualifiers. Armed citizens, be they ineffective & disorganized, were enough to dissuade heavy handed gov't tactics for a long time - lest effective & organized arise.
- krapp 7y agoWe are discussing your assertion that due to the Second Amendment, an armed populace has "reminded" the American government that its use of force is "a bad idea" on multiple occasions. The purpose of the Second Amendment is to guarantee the capacity of a "well regulated militia" to commit armed violence "in defense of a free state." Resistance and protest which does not involve armed violence against the state by definition is not relevant to discussions about the effectiveness the Second Amendment. This is not adding a "new qualifier," it's merely taking the intent of the Second Amendment seriously. >Armed citizens, be they ineffective & disorganized, were enough to dissuade heavy handed gov't tactics for a long time - lest effective & organized arise. This is an assumption on your part which willfully ignores evidence to the contrary. You're like Batman, thinking the bat costume works because "criminals are a superstitious and cowardly lot", only with guns and the government. Until you can actually prove that the government - which has been militarizing and becoming more aggressive since 9/11, mind you, not less, and which shoots unarmed civilians in the streets in broad daylight with impunity and often gets commended by the gun community for doing so - has changed its tactics out of fear of an armed populace and an effective uprising, I'm going to consider further conversation to be fruitless.