4 ms·
So instead of being 'banked' by some institution with actual businesses in places they now have to make sure their phone is always on/loaded when it has to, ha
by LargoLasskhyfv 7y ago
So instead of being 'banked' by some institution with actual businesses in places they now have to make sure their phone is always on/loaded when it has to, have to rely/trust some online services which probably costs them money for transactions/credit, and whatnot else. So instead of being unbanked they are banked online which has other hassles.
I can see conventional banking shrinking where i am, by closing off branch offices, offering appcrap instead.
I RESIST! Because it changes parts of the banks responsibilities over to me, reversal of evidence/shifting the burden of proof. Over to gadgets which are inherently incecure. Nice try...
- scarface74 7y agoHave you actually read anything about mobile banking in developing countries? https://hbr.org/2012/04/innovations-in-mobile-banking https://hbr.org/2012/04/innovations-in-mobile-banking https://www.huffpost.com/entry/how-mobile-banking-is-tra_b_12944438 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/how-mobile-banking-is-tra_b_1...
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoYes, i have. Looked interesting at first, like skipping the technological steps older economies had to develop, and are stcuk with it because of sunken costs, regulatory capture, thereby overtaking them. Sounded reasonable, intelligent, smart. But i also recently read something about debt traps, maybe even here. But am to tired to search for that now. Anyways, would it matter? Should i have to hide my opinion behind some link i can point at, and say 'there, they said so too!' Edit: Anyways, cash is king. It's simple. It works. Electronic cash seems simple, and may work. Or not.
- scarface74 7y agoExcept cash is easily stolen, and can’t be sent over along distance safely. What do you think “cash” is? It’s just a common accepted way to store value. Do you really get paid in paper currency and keep it all on you all the time?
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoAnd your gadget is safe from being stolen? And you can't be forced to give the pin, password, fingerprint, whatever? I don't know where you are, but from the place where i am this whole paypal thing made no sense because we already had the possibility to 'wire' money relatively fast and cheap. Which can work even faster now with SEPA instant payments. Not to forget: credit cards! I know i'm sounding old and cranky, but most of that new stuff made NO REAL SENSE WHATSOEVER for most people in my region. That is why they are slow to adopt, because they don't need to! There is no need for something like 'payday loan checks' around here. And no need to plug in some upstarts which are trying to circumvent established infrastructure by going exclusively mobile, while in reality using established credit card companies also. They are just one additional man in the middle, snorkeling up data, and adding fees. What do you think Apple Pay is? Edit: Of course i don't carry all my money with me all the times. Why should i? I do have a banking account. But when i need it, there usually is an ATM somewhere within 10 minutes max pedestrian distance from a network called 'Cash Group' which my bank is a member of. You know? Physical ATMs, installed in branch offices of members of Cash Group. If not there are others, and i maybe have to pay EUR 1 for drawing EUR 100, or something like that.And not some freestanding suspicious thing, riddled with skimming devices and dirty, operated by some suspicious entity. I'm used to this sort of physical infrastructure and think that is how it should be. Not out of stubbornness, but after evaluating the pros and cons of alternative systems. Going fully cashless may appeal at first because of convenience, and in theory it may be implemented right. But usually history shows 'worse is better'. Where does that leave the 'unbanked'? Yah, well, with something worse? Edit: Maybe i'd see it different when i'd have traveled to Sweden, the Megapolises of China, or having used some card for a public transportation network which doubles as convenience cash for other things as transport. But it wouldn't change my principal criticism of that stuff. If only usable by Smartphone you are F..... when that is without power, broken, stolen, stuck in some digital mess by either Telco/ISP, online banking account by upstart which does banking in a lazy way, or some such. I repeat: cash is simple. It works. Use it when you can. Maybe think about antifragility and resilience for a while.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd your gadget is safe from being stolen? And you can't be forced to give the pin, password, fingerprint, whatever? I don't know where you are, but from the place where i am this whole paypal thing made no sense because we already had the possibility to 'wire' money relatively fast and cheap. So you wire money to every random merchant? And what's the difference between wiring money and mobile payments? If your gadget is stolen they still need to get your authentication information. The money is not stored on your gadget. They just pick up another $10 phone and log into their account. This isn't a new thing. Developing countries have been doing this for a decade. installed in branch offices of members of Cash Group. If not there are others, and i maybe have to pay EUR 1 for drawing EUR 100 And if you're talking about euros, you're not in a "developing country". You know the whole topic of the conversation? The "upstart online banking infrastructure" has literally been in place for a decade in some developing countries. What do you think happens if the credit card infrastructure goes down? Of course you can still get paper currency. Not to forget: credit cards! I know i'm sounding old and cranky, but most of that new stuff made NO REAL SENSE WHATSOEVER for most people in my region. That is why they are slow to adopt, because they don't need to!( To use credit cards you have to have credit. To have credit, you have to have a "credit history". To have a credit history, you have to have a reliable infrastructure to record your history of payments.... There is no need for something like 'payday loan checks' around here. And no need to plug in some upstarts which are trying to circumvent established infrastructure by going exclusively mobile, while in reality using established credit card companies also.* Payday loans have nothing to do with mobile payments. Neither are they using the (non existent) credit card companies to facilitate mobile banking. I do have a banking account. So you have a central authority to hold your money and then you can transfer your money to pay your goods. Exactly how mobile banking works. They are just one additional man in the middle, snorkeling up data, and adding fees. What do you think Apple Pay is? Apple Pay is no different than any other "merchant account" that's been around forever. Every merchant goes through a middle man to get on the credit card network. They have forever.