15 ms·
Back when I worked in IT many years ago, one of the things I did each week was run JohnTheRipper on our password file. If it cracked your password, it sent you
by jedberg 7y ago
Back when I worked in IT many years ago, one of the things I did each week was run JohnTheRipper on our password file. If it cracked your password, it sent you an email saying your password was weak and you had to change it.
If you were in the next week's batch, it emailed you and told you "your password is foobar, which we discovered by cracking the password file, and it is weak. You must change it". Yes, I emailed them their password in plain text using our internal email system. Jury's still out on whether that was a good idea. :)
The next week we just disabled your account and you had to come to IT to fix it.
One guy actually got fired for his password. He was already being super creepy and making the girl who sat across from him uncomfortable, but she never told anyone. Then we cracked his password, which was a very naughty phrase about the girl who sat across from him. I reported it to HR, who asked the girl, who then said he was creepy, and so they acted swiftly on the reports and got him out of there.
- mongol 7y agoI don't know what to think about this. A password is supposed to be secret so I don't know what a naughty phrase in secret is a violation of? It is not very different from writing something naughty in a private diary, or even thinking a naughty thing.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThe guy wasn't fired for the password, he was fired for the sexual harassment of a coworker. And nothing you do on a work computer is secret from your employer. It's not a "private diary" if you're using your employer's hardware.
- mongol 7y agoIf he was fired for sexual harassment, that is one thing. But a naughty password on its own? That was maybe not the case here but that is what I have doubts about.
- swampthinker 7y agoAnd people wonder why tech has a massive issue with sexism...
- mongol 7y agoWhat does it have to do with tech? Everyone has passwords, and they are used all the time.
- sterkekoffie 7y agoWhat if it was violent, bigoted, or suicidal? Passwords are secret but they aren't necessarily private. If you wouldn't want to verbally verify it with your administrator you probably shouldn't use it.
- mongol 7y agoI have seen many password policies that says that you never should disclose your password. I have never seen a password policy say that it must not be naughty. As for violent or suicidal, I am less sure. I guess I would reason like a doctor, who has a patient's privacy to consider, but when certain lines are crossed he can contact the police if he think there is risk of crime.
- sterkekoffie 7y agoThen I think our only difference in opinion is whether making sexually aggressive statements about your coworkers is crossing a line or just "naughty."
- mongol 7y agoThe difference is maybe that I don't see a password as a statement. There is no intent to let anyone know it. The only purpose it serves is to be difficult to guess / crack and easy to remember.
- AlexTWithBeard 7y ago
- reedwolf 7y ago>he was fired for the sexual harassment of a coworker OP is vague on what this guy actually did. Note that they only went to the girl after cracking the password, and she said he was "creepy" towards her. "Creepy" in this context might just mean FWU (flirting while ugly).
- CydeWeys 7y agoIf he got fired for it, it was probably bad. And you shouldn't be flirting at work.
- tbabb 7y agoI think it's very interesting how, despite knowing nearly nothing about the situation, everyone here is quick to doubt the victim, and make up scenarios (for which there is zero evidence) where the harasser is the victim.
- bcatanzaro 7y agoFor all its flaws, innocent until proven guilty is still the fairest justice system. Beyond a reasonable doubt is a high standard of proof. Because we use this standard, it is natural for people to look for reasonable doubts when talking about accusations. That is how western society works. And for very good reasons.
- Falling3 7y ago> innocent until proven guilty is still the fairest justice system Justice system administered by a state where the repercussions include imprisonment and death - absolutely. But HR is not a judicial system and should not be viewed as one. I think I take your point to be just a descriptive observation of "our social discussion reflects a habit based on our exposure to judicial systems" and not a normative statement. Even if it's the former, I think it's naive and ignores a very real culture of doubt and victim-blaming exclusive to sexual violence.
- kps 7y ago
- astine 7y agoI think that it's the conjunction of the password and the harassment accusation together that make this a fairly straightforward case. If it were just a creepy password, well, that demonstrates a certain level of creepiness but doesn't mean that he made it a problem for anyone else. It's possible to have private fantasies that remain private. On the other hand, if it was just the coworker's accusation, it would be just that, an accusation without evidence. The password as evidence of private creepiness lends credence to the accusations of harassment, and the accusation of harassment demonstrates the the creepiness was probably not just private. Together they create a case stronger than either alone.
- 300bps 7y agoNot to mention "creepy" is a charge that is often impossible to defend yourself from. It's wholly dependent on the subjectivity of the accuser and their opinion of the accused. Walk over and say good morning every day to a coworker and she finds you attractive? Charming and sweet. Walk over and say good morning every day to a coworker and she finds you unattractive? Creepy.
- the_gastropod 7y agoUgh. Please don't bring this redpill malarkey to hackernews
- malloreon 7y agoIn this hypothetical example are you walking over and saying good morning to each of your male coworkers as well? The point is, treat your coworkers the same, regardless of gender.
- anchpop 7y agoI haven't been in the workforce very long, so I really don't know and am asking genuinely. Is it ever okay to flirt with a coworker?
- DharmaPolice 7y agoYes, but the problem is that in most of the scenarios that get discussed it's not flirting but one person making advances and not noticing (or caring) that the person is actively feeling uncomfortable. The rule of thumb is sort of in line with telling a risque joke. Is that ever OK in a workplace? Sure, but if there's any doubt whatsoever how it will be received by the audience then you probably shouldn't be doing it.
- panopticon 7y agoI was sorta with you at first, but that second paragraph is straight-up nonsense.
- jackcodes 7y ago<month><animal><current_year> every 90 days is the god pattern
- dlivingston 7y agoIf I crack one of your passwords (or search your email on haveibeenpwned), and assuming you haven't changed your animal, then cracking any other password you have is trivial and takes at most 12 permutations.
- austincheney 7y agoA better pattern is something long that will exceed the bounds of a rainbow table. I love JavaScript but I really wish it didn't have the ASI feature* The example is 67 characters long written in a statement that is easy to remember with two non-alpha characters aside from the spaces. Imagine the size of rainbow table it would take to crack that.
- OJFord 7y agoI'm not sure how easy that is to remember... Was it 'really love but wish' or 'love but really wish'? etc.
- austincheney 7y agoI suspect you would word your password in a way that is most familiar for you. The idea is to achieve both cognitive comfort while destroying brute force efforts. A better example: Antidisestablishmentarianism is the longest English word I can think of## 73 characters.
- saalweachter 7y agoI think you'd have more fun trying to imagine phrases no one would ever say. "But thankfully I took Kim Kardashian's advice, and everything worked out for the best."
- 7y ago
- jedberg 7y agoHe was doing a lot more than just the password. I was being vague on purpose. The password just exposed him.
- didibus 7y ago> It is not very different from writing something naughty in a private diary, or even thinking a naughty thing. I don't know if I'm too normal or what, but my gut feeling is that yes it's really creepy. And all these things have different creepiness to them. Thinking a naughty thing is the least creepy. A private naughty diary is starting to be creepy. If it's just a passage in a normal diary, it's not too bad, if there's a whole book just about this one girl it would get super creepy. Making your work password a naughty phrase about the girl working in front of you, definitely super creepy. Some of those I'd start to consider beginning signs of harassment honestly. The password one, it's like slowly trying to bring to the girls attention your thoughts. What's happening, are you hoping they see you typing it out one day? Everytime you type it do you stare at her and imagine whatever you typed? So ya, if there was all kinds of other similarly creepy small behaviors they'd add up to a pretty bad environment for that girl to be working in. Just my opinion. Maybe I'm overreacting, but I wouldn't do that, and so I find it very surprising and creepy that someone else does. Are they harmless, innocent, didn't know better, just have a cute crush, nice guys, maybe, but doing something unexpected to me, that I'd never think of doing, is pretty much the defining characteristic of creepy, and it naturally puts me on my guard. It's just strange behavior, and that's scary. Note: I'd like to hear some replies that are like... oh no, it's not creepy, way more people have naughty passwords or big naughty diaries of their coworkers than you think. I know I do. It's a totally normal behavior, you're the actual outlier here if you never did any of that. Otherwise I will continue to believe this is strange and creepy behavior which warrants suspicion, and possibly a good indicator that someone makes others feel uneasy and unsafe when around them.
- kelnos 7y agoI think if it was really literally just the password, it would be pretty weak grounds to fire someone. But OP says he was being deliberately vague so as not to be specific about the situation, and there was a lot more going on. The guy got fired for his actions, not his password. The password was just a tipping point.
- didibus 7y agoI'm not really talking about the firing, I had another comment elsewhere about that part. And I could excuse only the password, because one creepy behavior can be excused, a recurring number of them not so much. I still need to excuse the password though, because I think that's just creepy. If it was just normal behavior, it wouldn't need excusing, it just wouldn't even be an argument. I'm more saying that having your work password be a naughty fantasy involving your coworker is just plain creepy. I've never heard of this. I mean, even having a naughty fantasy involving your partner as your work password is creepy. How can anyone think this is totally normal and appropriate behavior? I know my wife would find it real weird if that was my password. If you do that, and are starting to feel like other people find you creepy or are suggesting you might be, and you're confused why they think that.. I just don't know what to say. If you were under the impression having such a password is common, I'm afraid you were mistaken. But, like I said, I'm giving people an opening here.. maybe I'm the one that's mistaken, and naughty sexual fantasies with coworkers as work passwords is a very common and normal choice of password. Presented with such evidence, I'd reconsider.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoIt's basically thoughtcrime.
- deanCommie 7y agoA private diary that is the official property of your employer, and that they have the legal access to read at any time. The system being managed here is a professional one. Keep your professional passwords professional. It's no different than using your work email for naughty discussions.
- TallGuyShort 7y agoI'm all for the effective strength enforcement and ejecting the creepy guy, but some people do have strong passwords that, a bad idea though it may be, embed something deeply personal to them. Just something to keep in mind before automating the sharing of cracked passwords for otherwise legitimate purposes. I consider my passwords my private information, even if they are no longer secure from a technical standpoint and shouldn't be in use. I hope people respect that if they come across them.
- sangnoir 7y agoI wonder if that process was passed by legal first. Not only does it make private (in most user's minds) information public, it also makes it legally discoverable!
- jedberg 7y agoYes, it was passed by legal and everyone else. The first warning was automated and the password wasn't revealed. It was only on the second pass once you had ample warning. But to be fair, I wouldn't do that today. I would just shut off the account on the second pass.
- AWildC182 7y agoGiven the frequency of online password db breaches, this seems like a really bad idea...
- tom_mellior 7y agoAgreed. I would hope that the first email was automated and nobody actually looked at the results of cracking the passwords. In the second week, you arguably had less expectation of privacy.
- jedberg 7y agoCorrect, the first warning was automated and the password was not revealed.
- 7y ago
- kissgyorgy 7y agoEven if the guy was creepy, you are an asshole revealing something he thought nobody could ever know. That's the same thing like reading his personal letters or similar.
- travisjungroth 7y agoEh, he was typing that phrase at a work keyboard everyday.
- avar 7y agoWould you be OK with your use of work bathrooms being made public? You can have an expectation of privacy while using other people's stuff.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThis is a bad analogy.
- keltor 7y agoActually, it's a rather perfect analogy. People have some expectations of privacy and it's not normally considered acceptable to violate this. Sometimes this stuff is untried in court or falls into a definite legal grey area and usually the policy is to err on the side of caution and simply assume that if something is commonly expected to be private, then it's private and should be kept so. If we were investigating a user for XYZ and came across a file named "Personal Diary 2019.txt" or whatever, I can assure you that HR would not want us to open that file. Possibly if HR found out they'd declare the investigation tainted and want to stop it right there.
- dkonofalski 7y agoIf HR found a file called "Personal Diary 2019.txt" on the computer that is owned by the company they work for, there is no expectation of privacy. This is not the user's personal computer that they hacked into or gained unauthorized access to. Courts have ruled on multiple occasions that you do not have an expectation of privacy on your employer's hardware.
- parliament32 7y agoI'm conflicted about this. I know I'd be pretty upset if an employer starting talking to me about a plaintext password that's supposed to be hashed. The problem is that they brute forced it and then sent it directly off to HR? Yes, as a sysadmin it's perfectly acceptable to be searching for weak passwords, but reading the plaintext yourself for fun then scurrying to HR is kinda a slimy thing to do. As an admin you have an obligation to your users to not be nosy, and if you find out something you shouldn't, keep it under your hat. Just because you have the ability to peek into the CFO's mailbox and see what everyone's salary is, doesn't mean you print out the spreadsheet and take it to your boss demanding a raise. It's kinda like if you got in trouble for playing Farmville or whatever while sitting on the toilet at work, which they found out about by installing cameras in the stalls. Yes, I shouldn't have been doing that, but how you found out is also a huge issue and I'd feel pretty violated. You should probably re-read the sudo warning: We trust you have received the usual lecture from the local System Administrator. It usually boils down to these three things: #1) Respect the privacy of others. #2) Think before you type. #3) With great power comes great responsibility.
- jedberg 7y agoI wasn't reading the cracked passwords for fun, I was verifying the output. And it was well known that we cracked the passwords, and he had already gotten the first warning that it was cracked, so he knew we knew it. That's why I didn't feel bad taking it to HR. I already had a sense that he was doing bad stuff, and the password just solidified it for me.
- bcit-cst 7y agoYeah that is some NSA shit.
- jedberg 7y agoNot really. It was well known that passwords were being cracked, and the guy in question was even warned already that his password had been cracked the week before.
- yoz-y 7y agoTangential but sometimes it is interesting to use a passphrase that you are ashamed of, that way you are never tempted to reveal it.
- bakul 7y agoA proper policy would’ve been to not have any human look at a user’s password and just email them a warning about their weak password. A password should be considered a PPI (personal, private information) and off limits to others, no matter how creepy (exception being a legal warrant). These days you might gotten in trouble!
- jedberg 7y agoAgreed. That's why if I were doing it today, I would just shut off the account after the second warning. Although I don't think it's PII if it's all internal company data, especially if it is known that IT will crack your password.
- bakul 7y agoA password is supposed to be very hard to guess by others but not so hard for you to remember so it can be said to be PII! And no, it is not assumed that IT will crack your password. Because how do you know how far IT would go to crack your password and how do you know they are not looking at your data as well? Employee/company officers' email may contain data that could be highly sensitive and something IT should not be looking at.
- laughinghan 7y agoit is not assumed that IT will crack your password At this company, it was public knowledge that IT will crack your password. At the vast, vast majority of companies, it's public knowledge that they are looking at your data and email as well. If you are under the impression that your employer doesn't, you should double-check because you are almost certainly wrong.
- ben509 7y agoIt shouldn't be personal identifiable information. But PII asks what that information is, not what it should be. Given that people reuse passwords or put things like DOB in their passwords, a conservative classification should treat passwords as PII. If a company is cracking passwords, it should stop that to protect IT from liability. Example: someone reuses a password, and an IT employee sees that during a cracking operation, and that person's account by chance is hacked, now that person can accuse IT of misusing the password. Maybe those disclaimers will protect them, but it's always smarter to avoid liability entirely than rely on fine print that a court can disregard.
- maehwasu 7y agoI'm excited for your coming adventures, in which our intrepid hero breaks into people's diaries and then tells their friends about the naughty things they wrote. Brave!
- throwGuardian 7y agoYou essentially got someone fired for thought crime. While in this instance, that thought crime coincidentally had a real life corroboration, it was a just a lucky happenstance. You were not in the ethical right here! It could have been that you reported to HR a romantic fling between two consenting adults, while they had no intention of their private lives spilling over into the public eye. Disapprove of your actions, and further disapprove of your schadenfreude at someone's firing
- raldi 7y agoThis is the best password policy there is. The only time I was lucky enough to live under it was for a couple years in college. Who cares how many uppercase letters I used or the last time I changed it? What matters is how crackable it is. v#ja&zp is better than P@ssword1
- coldtea 7y ago>* One guy actually got fired for his password. He was already being super creepy and making the girl who sat across from him uncomfortable, but she never told anyone. Then we cracked his password, which was a very naughty phrase about the girl who sat across from him. I reported it to HR, who asked the girl, who then said he was creepy, and so they acted swiftly on the reports and got him out of there.* So, he never did anything specific to call for, but just "was creepy" (which can often mean he was not very pretty and/or awkward socially / in expressing his feelings, as opposed to someone who would assault or anything close). And he had a password (in private) that was lewd or whatever, which he did not intend to share with anybody. Yeah, let's fire the guy...
- 1000units 7y ago"Think of her comfort!" is the lonely childless Bay Area man's version of "Think of the children!"
- unkulunkulu 7y agoWhat would be a weak creepy password? I feel those properties run opposite. Weak enough to be bruteforced and creepy enough to get fired. Good job on that fella’s part I would say!
- jedberg 7y agoA string of dictionary words and a very common name.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoGreg did that at Blekko as well. That is why you always crack the sysadmins password first, and use that. So when they crack it they know that you known that they know.