3 ms·
Pinker is perhaps the single most uninformed public “intellectual” in society today. His ideas are slightly above Gladwell yet somehow he commands respect. I re
by keiferski 7y ago
Pinker is perhaps the single most uninformed public “intellectual” in society today. His ideas are slightly above Gladwell yet somehow he commands respect. I really don’t understand it.
- freddie_mercury 7y agoAd hominem attacks don't really improve the level of discussions on HN.
- keiferski 7y agoI don’t consider it an ad-hominem attack. The man has consistently shown that he is vastly undereducated on things he has public opinions on. The quote linked to above is a perfect example - it reads as if from someone who skimmed the Wikipedia article on Nietzsche and spent zero time attempting to understand his thought. For anyone who has even a passing knowledge of Nietzsche’s ideas, Pinker’s quote is just hilariously, woefully ignorant. Nietzsche was not a pessimist - if anything he was an optimist. It’s only in the (uninformed) public imagination that he is some kind of nihilist pessimist. Judging from Pinker’s quote, his knowledge of Nietzsche doesn’t go deeper than public hearsay. Considering that nearly all of Pinker’s works suffer from this same flaw, I have no problem dismissing him.
- ulisesrmzroche 7y agoNeither does nagging like this
- kashyapc 7y agoBy any stretch I'm not "blown over" by Pinker's work, but calling him "most uninformed" is uncharitable. Sure he has his blind spots, and sometimes gets carried away and says things that are not at all in his wheelhouse. But overall, I think his work is a "net good".