9 ms·
> China claims that Taiwan is part of its territory" is correct - as far as it goes, it just doesn't go nearly far enough It's correct for a certain definition
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
> China claims that Taiwan is part of its territory" is correct - as far as it goes, it just doesn't go nearly far enough
It's correct for a certain definition of the terms. Taiwan officially also agrees that it is part of China, after all.
It gives the impression that China wants to invade a foreign land whereas it is essentially a domestic dispute, the Chinese civil war.
- gurkendoktor 7y ago> Taiwan officially also agrees that it is part of China, after all. Which is worth as much as a forced confession, because there is a credible threat of invasion if the Taiwan/ROC government would officially change its name or claimed territory. And I'm sure many countries have come into de-facto existence through civil wars, so that can't be the only criteria.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoYou illustrate my point perfectly. They do not agree that they are part of the People's Republic of China, but as the Republic of China they are indeed part of 'China'. Nothing forced there.
- gurkendoktor 7y agoIf the threat of an invasion is not "forced", then what is?
- yourbandsucks 7y agoThey don't call themselves part of China under threat. Their official position is that they're the rightful government of all of China. Abandoning 'Taiwan is part of China' would mean abandoning that claim. It looks quaint now, yes, but that's the official position. And it wasn't quaint when they were holding China's security council seat. The fact that both countries have reasons to say 'Taiwan is part of China' while each claiming to be the rightful government of China is the most basic fact of the relationship. It's embedded in the names of the countries, even. ROC and PRC. I'd submit that anyone with strong feelings on the matter should really already know this.
- gurkendoktor 7y agoYes, that was the situation under authoritarian one-party rule, and there are no doubt still a few people in the ROC who dream of retaking the mainland under the KMT banner. Since then, China has added an explicit military threat under the Anti-Secession Law[1], and the ROC government has evolved into a two-party democracy. The official position has not changed, but the context has. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Secession_Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Secession_Law
- yourbandsucks 7y agoBut we agree that that's the background and Taiwan hasn't reached consensus to change the official policy, right? OP is getting dogpiled for pointing out the grade school history overview of the topic. As for whether the threat of invasion is the deciding factor on the official ROC policy.. I think it's better explained by the fact that everything is going fine with two Chinas. They trade a ton, everyone's happy. Why mess with that just because the diplomatic positions don't make logical sense?
- learc83 7y ago>But we agree that that's the background and Taiwan hasn't reached consensus to change the official policy, right? What part of China has threatened to invade them over changing their policy makes that policy a coerced statement and not an accurate representation of their intent do you not understand?
- yourbandsucks 7y agoThe part where anyone thinks it's a credible threat? I honestly thought that went without saying. You really think China's 5 seconds away from a bloody invasion? China is Taiwan's largest trading partner. Everyone's getting rich, in both countries. Taiwan is and will remain independent, everyone knows this, China doesn't care.
- 7y ago
- rangibaby 7y agoPRC has threatened to invade ROC if they declare independence as the “Republic of Taiwan”
- NeedMoreTea 7y ago> it is essentially a domestic dispute, the Chinese civil war Well surely it was as the civil war is 70 years over, since the fall of Hainan. There would be many decades of martial law before the democratic reforms. So it wasn't about what Taiwanese citizens then wanted. Who is definitively right? I have no doubt it will remain a sticking point in relations between Taiwan and PRC for decades to come. It seems unlikely that Taiwan and CCP will reach amicable agreement.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThere has not been military action in a long time but it is obviously not over. If it was over we wouldn't be having this discussion. It's like Germany and Vietnam before, Korea today. I would also note that Taiwan had a KMT President no later than 2015 and he was very much "anti-independence". In fact when asked about it he very aptly answered that the Republic of China was indepedent since its founding in 1912.