3 ms·
FWIW, every program looks like one that usually is set to start at startup; the intent is to have the dialogue only show up when you start an app for the first
by judge2020 7y ago
FWIW, every program looks like one that usually is set to start at startup; the intent is to have the dialogue only show up when you start an app for the first time. Since so many background apps were running at startup they all slowly needed to ask for their permissions.
> create a migration UX
Might not be possible if the previous MacOS isn't full-on tracking what folders a program is accessing, and it still would likely encourage allowing all permissions if the user has more than 30 different programs accessing enough folders.
- oconnore 7y agoIf you were ok running your previous apps you should also be ok with gathering usage data for a week before the OS attempts to do a hard cut-over to a more secure model.
- thirtyseven 7y agoIt seems like this would be very difficult to implement securely. You basically would have to preserve the old, unsafe mode and hope that nobody circumvents whatever restrictions you put in place to make sure that it only applies to the pre-migration apps .
- judge2020 7y agoIf all of 10.14 were tracking it there probably wouldn't be much issue, but i'll bet the average MacOS user doesn't have more than 5 startups apps that would show this dialogue; that combined with this happening exactly once during the upgrade process means it's not a big priority for Apple to address.
- vincnetas 7y agoHave a migration tool window with table where all requests are appended instead of popup being displayed. Blink that tool anytime a new requests comes in, have explanations on migration tool window. Apps who ask for permission will be hanging in background until you approve/deny permissions from migration tool. You can do migrations on your time when you need particular app, and not be forced to choose permissions for all apps at once.