4 ms·
Abrupt, unexpected breaking could cause a rear-end collision, which could conceivably kill quite a few more people than if the breaking had not occurred. Imagi
by pmoriarty 7y ago
Abrupt, unexpected breaking could cause a rear-end collision, which could conceivably kill quite a few more people than if the breaking had not occurred. Imagine a car breaking hard directly in front of 16-wheel semi-trailer. That could lead to a pile-up and quite a few people dead.
- JaggedJax 7y agoHow is this different from a human slamming on the breaks to avoid the accident? Or a human crashing into the truck. These situations can also lead to a rear end collision the same was as AEB would.
- u801e 7y agoA lot of drivers also look ahead of the vehicle directly ahead of them, so they have some sense of when the vehicle in front of them is likely to slow down so that they can be better prepared to slow down themselves. If the AEB has a false positive and suddenly slows the vehicle, it would likely catch drivers following that vehicle off guard.
- brewdad 7y agoTrue but spotting a pedestrian through the windows of the car in front of you is much more challenging than spotting a lineup of brake lights from cars ahead. Keeping a safe following distance is by far the more influential factor in a collision occuring or being avoided.
- Johnny555 7y agoIf the AEB has a false positive and suddenly slows the vehicle, it would likely catch drivers following that vehicle off guard Then stop following so closely. Problem solved. Don't tell me not to have a safety feature in my car because another driver isn't driving safely.
- tremon 7y agoReally? You've never had a car cut in front of you from the inside lane because they just had to pass three cars before making this exit? I see this happen way too often. Please stop assuming every rear-end collision is the fault of the rear driver.
- ghaff 7y agoFrom an insurance "at fault" perspective it's basically always going to be the fault of the following driver. However, I can pretty much guarantee that, if you go out on the road and randomly slam on your brakes, you'll get someone to hit your vehicle in pretty much no time flat.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>From an insurance "at fault" perspective it's basically always going to be the fault of the following driver. It is a quick simple rule that avoids dealing with he said she said situations in the days before dashcams and the inaccuracy of this approach would roughly balance out across the insurers. Sure it screws the people who aren't actually at fault but they can't (or couldn't, before dashcams) prove that anyway. This kind of thing will probably go away in the future because everybody will just have dashcams.
- Johnny555 7y agoThat's not the situation the parent post was talking about "If the AEB has a false positive and suddenly slows the vehicle" The case you're describing is exactly what AEB is designed to protect you from and if the car behind you couldn't react as fast as your AEB and he rear-ends you, then he was following you too closely.
- parsimo2010 7y agoI don't know if you started typing your comment before I got my edit up or not, so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. Yes, unexpected braking events can cause rear-end collisions, but that was not the point of this study. If a pedestrian walks in front of a car unexpectedly you can either try not to hit them by braking (or possibly swerving if the situation permits), or you can just take the action you're implying and plow right on through them because your unexpected braking might cause some other people to get hurt. My 2016 Subaru Forester with Eyesight has gotten confused and applied the brakes while weaving through the gates at military bases (these are low speed and lined with barriers), but other than that I have had no unexpected braking events in my car that weren't justified. In 40k miles the Eyesight system in my car has helped with about six close calls (I can't know if they would have become collisions), and haven't been rear ended. Right now I'm going to say that AEB systems add plenty of safety value to offset the increased risk of a rear end collision.
- sitharus 7y agoA rear-end collision is caused by the following driver being too close. A car in front could at any time, for any reason, use full breaking force and you have to plan your following distance appropriately. That said, a good way to get an angry rant from a truck driver is to talk about cars cutting in front so they no longer have an appropriate stopping distance.
- Alex3917 7y ago> That said, a good way to get an angry rant from a truck driver is to talk about cars cutting in front so they no longer have an appropriate stopping distance. If you do that then I'd imagine that the trucker is going to be more likely to just steamroll you rather than risking jackknifing.
- jschwartzi 7y agoIf you hit a pedestrian because you don't want a 16-wheeler up your backside, you're as much at fault for murdering that person as the trucker who murders you by following too closely.
- leetcrew 7y agoseriously? I get it, drivers in general are not cautious enough of pedestrians and cyclists. but if a 16-wheeler is following so closely that the other driver is at risk of getting rear-ended when they stop, the pedestrian is probably toast anyway. the semi is just going to push the car straight through the pedestrian. now instead of one person dead there's 10 tons of mass careening through the street out of control, putting a lot more lives at risk.
- onion2k 7y agoThe same is true if there is a pedestrian, so the fault lies with the truck driver being too close to stop in time. Perhaps that means the law should mandate automatic braking technology on trucks.
- layoutIfNeeded 7y ago> Abrupt, unexpected breaking could cause a rear-end collision If you’re tailgating. Don’t tailgate.
- tremon 7y agoOr they're cutting. Don't cut.