4 ms·
Honestly, I want a subscription service that allows me to see most major websites without ads. I think someday someone's going to realize just how silly the ad
by gwbas1c 7y ago
Honestly, I want a subscription service that allows me to see most major websites without ads.
I think someday someone's going to realize just how silly the advertisement game is, and as long as the payment structure is in place, we can get a much better web experience.
For example, may of us pay a small monthly fee for Netflix. I'm sure that a small monthly fee could add up to more than what most sites make from ads.
- mumblemumble 7y agoI could easily some universal way of paying to not see ads could be both more profitable for websites and less expensive for me. Because what I'm currently paying for mobile data and bandwidth at home in order to compensate for all the waste introduced by telemetry and ads probably amounts to a good bit more than what websites are making by serving me ads. But at this point the trust is so broken that I probably wouldn't pay for it even if it did exist. Because I'd expect whatever beacon is being used to say, "Paid up, don't serve ads" to just be used as another way to de-anonymize me by the less scrupulous advertisers. Which, as far as I can tell at this point, is pretty much all advertisers.
- BurningFrog 7y agoYeah, that seems to mostly be a coordination problem. As in, I'd pay $X/month for something that does that for most sites I frequent. But I'll never sign up for 100 different sites individually. Same thing for newspapers.
- mirimir 7y agoYes! Exactly! As I understand it, sites don't earn very much from each ad view. So to get substantial income, they need lots of traffic and ad views. And this gets implemented through a hugely complex process of real-time data sharing and bidding. It's ~transparent if you have a fast uplink. But if you're using Tor browser, you can watch it play out, all too slowly. So just replace that complex process with a simpler process of identifying the subscription service that the user employs, and adding the page view to their tab. In order to match current income from ads, the cost per page view would likely be very small. Perhaps $0.01-$0.10. And there could be a mechanism for adjusting that cost based on the local cost of living of a given user. Perhaps through a parameter pushed by the subscription service, which it would obtain in some more-or-less anonymous fashion.
- manigandham 7y agoThis has been tried several times. Google Contributor and Blendle are some examples. We had our own. Doesn't work because it's the paying-for-content part that people have a problem with. There's just not enough who are willing to pay the real costs of content. Many even get upset thinking that their internet connection is already "the internet".
- d0gbread 7y agoYou're describing Brave.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> think someday someone's going to realize just how silly the advertisement game is, and as long as the payment structure is in place, we can get a much better web experience. You're not the first, or tenth, or millionth person to think of this. Hell, even just limited to HN, micropayments and general content subscriptions have been discussed for a decade. Consumers are in a way that equilibrium where they don't want to pay for web content (esp text web content), and the path to getting them to the equilibrium of paying without thinking about it (like with Netflix or power) is unclear. It's not just theoretical: Companies like Google have also been experimenting with this for yeaaars, to diversify away from the risk (whether regulatory or technological or otherwise) of relying on ads as a primary revenue source. There are complications beyond consumer behavior, like bringing the colosally complicated ad ecosystem under a single payments system (since nobody wants to pay for a service that only removes some fraction of ads from the web).
- majewsky 7y ago> Consumers are in a way that equilibrium where they don't want to pay for web content (esp text web content), and the path to getting them to the equilibrium of paying without thinking about it (like with Netflix or power) is unclear. You disprove yourself by mentioning Netflix. The path is absolutely clear: Customers are willing to pay for added value that's proportionate to the cost. The problem for publishers is they do not add any value that would justify customers paying enough for their content. Few people will pay for a newspaper subscription when there are 10 other newspapers offering 90% of the same content for free. There are models that work, e.g. Patreon, but those usually don't scale up to, say, the Washington Post or CNN.
- wutbrodo 7y ago> You disprove yourself by mentioning Netflix This isn't how equilbria work. Netflix was a superior product to piracy in many ways: no perceived legal risk, reliable access, high quality guaranteed, way better ease of use. These barriers were high enough that plenty of people didn't pirate at all and stuck with nonsense like DVDs for way too long, so the incentive path pointed smoothly towards switching to Netflix, a Pareto improvement for non-pirates and a fairly easy trade-off for pirates. There's no such path for web content: adblockers are unquestionably legal, easy to set up, provide a better experience, and even non-users of adblockers have a trillion non-paywalled sources in an ecosystem where it's tough for strong brand loyalty to survive en masse. What advantages do you imagine a paywall option offering to people when their alternative is better in almost every respect? > There are models that work, e.g. Patreon, but those usually don't scale up to, say, the Washington Post or CNN.
- dageshi 7y agoA majority of people don't care enough about ads for a service like this to work and those that do use adblockers.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI'd like it too. But here's a kicker. You can pay a small monthly fee for a service to offset the revenue they lost by not showing ads. But, the service may opt to show you the ads anyway, and double their revenue. Especially that willingness and ability to pay already signals you're a better than average target for advertising. Unless there's regulation against advertising-based business models, nothing will change, because competitive pressure will always push towards free+ads, paid+ads, and/or free/paid+ads+data collection.