4 ms·
I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, or use my speakers, or
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, or use my speakers, or read my keyboard.
If you bombard users with dialogues for every little thing, all you will do is train them to habitually click yes. Now you have lowered security, because users will ignore the more serious warnings too. And you've wasted everyone's time in the process.
This was exactly why UAC dialogues were largely a failure. And to think that UAC appears only once per app...
- dpkonofa 7y agoYou expect applications to have access to your desktop? You should only ever expect the user to have access to the desktop and, even then, the only apps that would ever prompt for access to the desktop are those that aren't updated for High Sierra and above. On the latest versions of macOS, the Desktop folder is shared by iCloud. This is definitely not an instance where security has been lowered nor is this the standard behavior of the new OS.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> You expect applications to have access to your desktop? Yes! That's what applications do, they read and write files. Most other software is, more likely than not, either a game or a web page. Does every app need to access my desktop specifically? No. But if we're trying to protect "normal users", I don't think most of them have the wherewithal to think through "what exact locations does and doesn't app X need to access?"
- CDSlice 7y agoBut they should only read and write files that you give it permission to. E.g, Word should only be reading and writing whatever files you open to edit, it shouldn't be able to access all the files in your Applications folder. If it needs temp files it can write those to it's designated section of the file system.
- wayneftw 7y agoIt should read and write whatever files it needs to without bothering me for every little thing. For instance, supposing they want to show you a welcome screen with all of your documents from your Documents folder (or anywhere else) - I don't want some asinine popup asking me for permission. Word is a well-known application. I installed it. I trust it and the corporation that wrote it. That's enough for me. The alleged problem is not even solved by a permission dialog. I should answer OK to the fact that it needs to access all of my Documents, forever, and that's supposed to be more secure? Why not just ask me for permission to my whole drive so it can scan for documents everywhere? Apps will just start asking for more and more permissions like they do on iOS, which is annoying. macOS is slowly but surely being turned into iOS. It's software for the lowest common denominator - the average idiot - which I'm not, at least when it comes to technology. Thankfully, my workstations are all Linux but I still have to deal with both macOS and Windows on a daily basis. But at least on Windows, the permissions annoyances can be avoided by simply not using UWP apps from their app store. I hope there's a way to turn this off on macOS but knowing Apple I doubt there will be because clearly they're on a mission to wipe macOS off the table. Perhaps that would be a good thing though. More people will move to Linux.
- danieldk 7y agoFor instance, supposing they want to show you a welcome screen with all of your documents from your Documents folder (or anywhere else) - I don't want some asinine popup asking me for permission. Word is a well-known application. I installed it. I trust it and the corporation that wrote it. That's enough for me. But this is not how it works. Word from the App Store is sandboxed. If you open a document in Word, this is done using the native file opening dialog. This is a separate, privileged process. The file is symlinked into Word's sandbox as a result. This means that Word has access to that file from that point onwards. So, it can show a welcome screen with documents that you have previously opened (which is what applications typically do, very few applications will show all documents). This is how things have worked ever since Apple required sandboxing for App Store apps. The problem is non-App Store apps that are not sandboxed. They have unfettered access to every file. I guess these extra permissions are to provide a certain level of protection against such apps, which is good. Word is a well-known application. I installed it. I trust it and the corporation that wrote it. There are many well-known incidents of trusted applications being compromised and backdoored. E.g.: https://blog.malwarebytes.com/threat-analysis/mac-threat-analysis/2017/05/handbrake-hacked-to-drop-new-variant-of-proton-malware/ https://blog.malwarebytes.com/threat-analysis/mac-threat-ana... To make things worse, the hash was updated in Homebrew cask. So even if you used a package manager, you would have installed a compromised application. Trusting applications may have been ok in the age of shrink-wrapped software. But now that applications are distributed over the web, allowing unfettered access is insanity. More people will move to Linux. The Linux ecosystem is also moving towards immutable base systems (Fedora Silverblue, NixOS) and restricted, sandboxed applications (Flatpak). Sure, it will always be possible to install a 70ies UNIX-style distribution. But the world is moving to sandboxing and putting up more restrictions, because the computing world became more hostile. macOS is slowly but surely being turned into iOS. This is getting tired and old. People said the same thing ten years ago and yet here we are, macOS is still an OS for 'general purpose computing'. I think Apple is finding a nice balance between securing the average user through sandboxing and SIP, while keeping giving the knobs to disable protections to advanced users. I say this as someone who currently uses Linux 95% of the time, but I wish Linux was as far as macOS with application sandboxing and system integrity protection.
- dpkonofa 7y agoApplications do not need permission. The user that is currently controlling the application needs to be able to use that application to read and write files but there's no reason that the application needs access when it's not in focus and, with the sandbox model in Catalina, applications have the ability to ask for explicit read/write permissions without prompting the user if they've already given access to install it. The biggest protection here is that the folder is shared via iCloud in most instances. Asking for explicit permission is really the only way to do that safely.
- w0utert 7y agoThe typical desktop for most user is a dumping ground for whatever it is they are currently working on. Or in some cases more or less anything they've been working on for the past years. A dumping ground full of potentially sensitive documents, work-in-progress files that are not supposed to leak beyond the computer, etc. Do you really think any application on your computer should be allowed to read and write them because "that's what applications do"? 90% of the 'applications' on my computer I didn't even install myself, like uninstallers, updaters, helper applications, background services, whatever. These have no business looking at files in my Desktop folder. And particularly not if its on iCloud and shared with other devices like my phone.
- tinus_hn 7y agoApplications can write files perfectly fine without the ‘can access the desktop’ permission. When you tell the application to open a file using the system dialogs, the system automatically grants the application access to read and write the file. The permission is needed only when the application wants to go around the normal way of opening files.
- dwaite 7y ago> I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, or use my speakers, or read my keyboard. I would like to know if an application: - Is scanning the contents of my documents or desktop outside of files I specifically selected or it previously created - Is monitoring data going on the clipboard - Wants permission to make alert sounds or play other audio even if my sound is silenced/muted - Wants to listen to my microphone - Wants to monitor sound being output by other applications, such as VOIP - Is monitoring for keystrokes even when it is not in the foreground. > If you bombard users with dialogues for every little thing, all you will do is train them to habitually click yes. Now you have lowered security, because users will ignore the more serious warnings too. And you've wasted everyone's time in the process. If the new permissions were about security, they would all be denied and applications would have to figure out how to cope. They are about user privacy.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> If the new permissions were about security, they would all be denied and applications would have to figure out how to cope. They are about user privacy. As I see it, those are the same things within this context. The effect is the same. Users are just going to click yes. They aren't going to think through "what other files are on my desktop right now?"
- JustFinishedBSG 7y ago> I expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. You mean the place where your mom stores her confidential banking statements ? > It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, You mean the place where you often copy paste passwords ? > or read my keyboard. You mean the place where you type your sensitive infos ?
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoThis is precisely why I chose those examples. My keystrokes contain sensitive information—the ability to read them comes with enormous potential for misuse. However, if my keystrokes can't be read, my keyboard isn't useful for much. At some point, the only way to be truly secure is to switch off the computer—that's why voting should be done on paper ballots! Once a computer is switched on and connected, everything is a tradeoff between usability and security. Personally, I have work to get done. At what point is Apple the only one able to make useful software? And by the way, while Apple is pretty good at user privacy, they are by no means at the top of my list, particularly after the whole Siri debacle.