2 ms·
> Are you trying to do blind population representation? Are you trying to "groups" of people (for some definition of "group"), etc. This interacts especially p
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Are you trying to do blind population representation? Are you trying to "groups" of people (for some definition of "group"), etc.
This interacts especially poorly with first past the post.
Suppose you have a state which is 60% Republican and has 10 districts. Do you draw 10 districts that are each 60% Republican? Then the Republicans may get all 10 seats, but in theory the Democrats at least have a chance in any given district, so nobody can do anything too outrageous or they could still be ousted. Whereas if you draw the districts along party lines then you get 6 Republicans and 4 Democrats but they're all safe seats which means that nobody is really accountable to the voters anymore.
Switch to range voting and the problem goes away, because two closely aligned candidates no longer split the vote which means there is no longer any such thing as a safe seat, nor can one side or the other claim disproportionately many seats because more closely balanced districts would elect centrists.