6 ms·
Mozilla announces PGP Support in Thunderbird, coming 2020
- bureaucrat 7y agoIt’s been 16 years and they still haven’t implemented ‘minimize to task tray’ function. God I hate their philosophy so much.
- Aloha 7y agoIs minimize to tray a really desirable feature? It's usually something I hate and disable.
- bureaucrat 7y agoPeople opened tickets on bugzilla. They have even developed an extension. (which seems to break on every major version upgrade) It’s even not that hard to implement, it’s just they are valuing their stupid politics and philosophy over user experience.
- mappu 7y agoYou can install rbtray to get this behaviour globally for all Windows apps when you right-click the minimize button.
- snailmailman 7y agoIt’s a feature I prefer. Anything I leave open all the time but only click rarely (like messaging apps) I prefer in the tray. This separates “apps I’m actively using” in the main area of the taskbar and “apps that are technically open but I’m not really using” It’s also worth nothing there’s an option to disable hiding everything in the popout menu thing, a setting i usually change. Saves a click and that space is otherwise unused in the taskbar anyway
- buildzr 7y agoI think the philosophy here has sort of changed with newer versions of Windows, this is why the taskbar now has quicklaunch icons and regular app icons the same size and place. I keep all my "stuff that just stays open" like thunderbird, spotify, mumble and firefox to the left.
- jackewiehose 7y agoThe flagged comment was: > It’s been 16 years and they still haven’t implemented ‘minimize to task tray’ function. God I hate their philosophy so much. Why was this so heavily down voted? If this is a bug report for 16 years, I would understand the frustration. After all, an email-program should put an icon next to clock in the taskbar.
- simcop2387 7y agoNot implemented in thunderbird, but take a look at birdtray to get that behavior. https://github.com/gyunaev/birdtray https://github.com/gyunaev/birdtray It's made to replace the old firetray extension.
- bureaucrat 7y agoI know. Problem with extensions is they tend to break with version upgrades. The fundamental question is: why not implement this stupid feature in the first place?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gambler 7y agoTheoretically this is a good thing, but it's way, way too late, since most people use web or mobile clients now. Mozilla should include a proper PGP implementation in their browser. In fact, I have no idea why a browser that positions itself as pro-privacy doesn't already have a way to sign, verify, encrypt and decrypt text. As far as I can tell, there wasn't even a discussion about this, which is ridiculous, considering the web (if you count it as a single system) is clearly the biggest communication platform in the world today.
- boredpenguin 7y ago> doesn't already have a way to sign, verify, encrypt and decrypt text. I know it's not exactly that, but if anyone wants to use PGP in the browser with webmail clients, there's Mailvelope[0]. What I like about it is that you can use it with GnuPG as a backend[1], so I can sign and decrypt emails in the browser with an OpenPGP smartcard without importing private keys. [0]: https://www.mailvelope.com https://www.mailvelope.com [1]: https://www.mailvelope.com/en/faq#gnupg https://www.mailvelope.com/en/faq#gnupg
- exabrial 7y agoPGP Auth would be _incredible_. Imagine being able to claim an account through keybase proofs!
- gambler 7y agoYeah, that's the thing: once you get a full suite of PGP tools as a standard feature of your browser it would make a whole bunch of other features possible.
- dngray 7y ago> Mozilla should include a proper PGP implementation in their browser. In fact, I have no idea why a browser that positions itself as pro-privacy doesn't already have a way to sign, verify, encrypt and decrypt text. Maybe something built on top of Webauthn is possible? I guess we have to wait and see.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoAs they say, this is too little, too late. About 15 years ago was the time when it would have made a real difference.
- Jonnax 7y ago"This new functionality will replace the Enigmail add-on, which will continue to be supported until Thunderbird 68 end of life, in the Fall of 2020."
- eindiran 7y agoThe comments here are overwhelmingly negative so far, so I'll say something positive: even if this comes rather late for Thunderbird, I appreciate that Mozilla chose to add this functionality. Any feature that makes PGP easier to use for the average person (especially better integration into a platform) is a win my book.
- Jonnax 7y agoThere's a lot of negativity around Mozilla in general. Like take their rewrite of their android browser. It's faster than Chrome and is currently in preview. Add-on support is work in progress but they got plenty of snarky attacks that it's not in MVP. The whole DNS over HTTPS attacks seemed focussed on Firefox, a browser with a tiny marketshare compared to Chrome who also implements it.
- dessant 7y agoFirefox does seem to attract that demographic, or it could be just a symptom of open source entitlement. I've received some of the rudest personal attacks via extension reviews on Firefox Add-ons. Take a look: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/search_by_image/reviews/1424324/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/search_by_ima...
- Jonnax 7y agoWow. That user saying that you should be satisfied with just the ratings is crazy.
- kbenson 7y agoIt definitely feels like there's a double standard at play sometimes. It's pretty routine for people here to announce after any mistake Mozilla makes that it's the last straw and they're done with it, and going back to Chrome. That just boggles my mind.
- skrowl 7y agoDoes it fix PGP not having forward secrecy?
- dfabulich 7y agoPGP support in an email client is worse than nothing. https://latacora.micro.blog/2019/07/16/the-pgp-problem.html https://latacora.micro.blog/2019/07/16/the-pgp-problem.html > Email is insecure. Even with PGP, it’s default-plaintext, which means that even if you do everything right, some totally reasonable person you mail, doing totally reasonable things, will invariably CC the quoted plaintext of your encrypted message to someone else (we don’t know a PGP email user who hasn’t seen this happen). PGP email is forward-insecure. Email metadata, including the subject (which is literally message content), are always plaintext. In 2020, someone should know better than to to add pretend encryption to email. The metadata leaks alone should lead you to conclude that this isn't worth doing. Don't use email for secure communications, period. Use a secure messaging app like Signal, instead.
- bsder 7y ago> even if you do everything right, some totally reasonable person you mail, doing totally reasonable things, will invariably CC the quoted plaintext of your encrypted message to someone else (we don’t know a PGP email user who hasn’t seen this happen). I agree with the other complaints but not this one. If my human client, who demanded I use PGP, does something stupid with the email, that is not my problem (The bits are colored blue like you asked--the fact that you uncolored them again is your fault). People forget that computer tasks in the real world are often more about liability transfer than actual security.
- dfabulich 7y agoIt is your problem, because it was your secret, and the human client just inadvertently revealed it. Instead, you both should have used a secure messaging app like Signal, which doesn't have a prominent UI button to forward messages in plain text.
- acqq 7y agoWhoever wrote what you quoted avoided to mention that the plugin (and I’d expect this new implementation) can protect the user from replying in plaintext to the encrypted message. And using PGP in some scenarios has an advantage for the users and is indeed less convenient for eavesdroppers. It seems that the later are especially motivated to promote fear against PGP.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kbrosnan 7y agoThis is is the Thunderbird Project's announcement. That group did the work, Mozilla provides a legal and financial framework for Thunderbird. Mozilla's work for Thunderbird is similar to projects like the Software Freedom Conservancy or Apache Software Project. User donations account for a lot of the work that has been done in the last year. It has allowed them to hire full time and contract workers for Thunderbird. If you want to see the project continue to progress dropping them a recurring donation would be awesome [2]. [1] https://blog.mozilla.org/thunderbird/2017/05/thunderbirds-future-home/ https://blog.mozilla.org/thunderbird/2017/05/thunderbirds-fu... [2] https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/ https://donate.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/
- amluto 7y ago> Thunderbird is unable to bundle GnuPG software, because of incompatible licenses (MPL version 2.0 vs. GPL version 3+). Instead of relying on users to obtain and install external software like GnuPG or GPG4Win, we intend to identify and use an alternative, compatible library and distribute it as part of Thunderbird on all supported platforms. IMO this is great news. GnuPG is, IMO, awful. Every time I use it I dislike it more. I recently set up a new subkey using a hardware token and the whole experience made me wish that someone would implement a better way to deal with OpenPGP messages.
- urda 7y agoSeeing a ton of negativity around PGP in this thread, sound like it's refresher time for HN readers: - PGP isn't always the proper solution. - Yes, you do need to be aware of what metadata is involved and what it exposes. This applies to all systems. - Secure communication is much more than key selection. - Mozilla taking steps to integrate it into Thunderbird should be applauded.
- bananamerica 7y agoEvery time I try to set up an email client I end up going back to gmail.com. What are the advantages of the hassle? They never seem to do what I want them to.
- m12k 7y agoIn Denmark, due to the GDPR, almost non of the digital letters we receive from the government can be sent by email (since they would contain personally identifiable information such as Social Security Numbers), so instead we just get a notification by email that tells us to log into a special 'secure' hosted mailbox. Except it's not hosted by the government, but some company that won a contract to build and host this - but now it's going to be built and hosted by another company that won the latest contract. This all seems kinda crazy to me, the public paying private companies to build and run one proprietary solution after the other. Does anyone know if there is some modern protocol/system that provides an alternative to email, and guarantees end-to-end encryption and other privacy-improvements?
- secfirstmd 7y agoI'm not quite sure about your characterisation of "due to GDPR" in this instance. Personally identifiable information does and can flow to regular email, though obviously it is better that it doesn't where possible.
- m12k 7y agoReally? It was my impression that not being able to guarantee encryption along the way (basically you might be sending a postcard instead of a letter) made it a non-starter.
- dngray 7y ago> In Denmark, due to the GDPR, almost non of the digital letters we receive from the government can be sent by email (since they would contain personally identifiable information such as Social Security Numbers), so instead we just get a notification by email that tells us to log into a special 'secure' hosted mailbox. I doubt GDPR has anything to do with this. We don't have GDPR in my country and they use offerings from Symantec Encryption Server.
- TheChaplain 7y agoI believe the actual reason for built-in PGP/GPG support is due to TB dropping support for XUL addons and going the same road with WebExtensions as Firefox. The current PGP/GPG implementation Enigmail is XUL, and been available for years.
- jlgaddis 7y agoAccording to the linked wiki page [0]: > To process OpenPGP messages, GnuPG stores secret keys, public keys of correspondents, and trust information for public keys in its own file format. Thunderbird 78 will not reuse the GnuPG file format, but will rather implement its own storage for keys and trust. First reaction: Yay! We'll get to manage everything twice! Second reaction: I am hopeful they'll support private keys stored on smartcards (i.e., Yubikeys, "real" smartcards, and OpenPGP cards) although, if the support in Firefox is any indicator, I wouldn't bet on it actually being "usable". [0]: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Thunderbird:OpenPGP:2020 https://wiki.mozilla.org/Thunderbird:OpenPGP:2020