4 ms·
> it would require a huge project to ensure every legal voter had some form of ID Without an ID, how do people at polling places know they're a legal voter? U
by pdonis 7y ago
> it would require a huge project to ensure every legal voter had some form of ID
Without an ID, how do people at polling places know they're a legal voter?
Using the honor system made sense a century or two ago when most people lived all their lives in the same place where they grew up and everyone at the polling place knew everybody. But that's not the case now and hasn't been for a long time. With all the talk about securing our election process against tampering (which I'm all in favor of), if it doesn't include voter ID, it's not secure.
> the number of voter fraud incidents is vanishingly small
The number of known voter fraud incidents is very small. But if ID isn't required to vote and we just accept people's word when they say they're eligible to vote, how could you ever prove voter fraud?
- crooked-v 7y ago> how could you ever prove voter fraud? There have been expansive studies on the subject, all of which have found incredibly low rates of actual voter fraud (as distinct from clerical errors or mistakenly voting at the wrong precinct): https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/debunking-voter-fraud-myth https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/debu...
- Vaslo 7y agoFar left organization, seems like a fair and unbiased source of information
- crooked-v 7y agoWhat does that matter? It's a page of links to peer-reviewed studies, legal opinions, and article from major journalism outlets, not an opinion piece.
- Vaslo 7y agoYes, I'm sure it diligently looked at reviews that were opposite or critical of those studies and decided it would further their cause to list them. Where is the list that refutes this data? Here's a hint, a little searching on Google will show you that there are opposing organizations who, conveniently, leave out this far left website's "legitimate reviews" in favor of ones that follow THEIR side.
- Someone1234 7y ago> With all the talk about securing our election process against tampering (which I'm all in favor of), if it doesn't include voter ID, it's not secure. If it does include ID it isn't secure. So you've made voting harder but not really made it any harder for bad actors to defraud (because high quality fake State IDs can be ordered, right now, straight for abroad). Plus statistically voter fraud isn't a real problem, it is well within the margin of error and there's no indication that it has increased. Election fraud seems far more problematic (because it requires fewer bad actors), and that may require more paper ballots and oversight (e.g. stream the vote count online).
- lucasmullens 7y agoThere's no "margin of error" in an election. They're counting an exact number of votes. Are the 537 votes in Florida that tipped the 2000 election "within the margin of error"?
- Someone1234 7y agoSeems like you want to discuss a tangent rather than talking about the lack of data supporting supposed widespread voter fraud. Plus your logic works both ways, if not a single fake vote can be ignored, so too can not a single vote that didn't get cast because of voter ID laws. So if counting exact number of votes is important, how do you justify voter ID laws that disenfranchise far more than fake votes? What if one of those 537 voters got disenfranchised because of voter ID?
- rtkwe 7y agoYou don't just show up and vote pretty much anywhere any more and when you're put on the list of registered voters the information is freely out there to be challenged and validated against many other sources. People do this a lot and yet most of the errors found are things like misspellings, old registrations without any votes since the new registration was made (ie someone moved and they were still on the roles at their old location) and similar small largely inconsequential errors. > The number of known voter fraud incidents is very small. Don't forget there was a whole presidential commission set up after 2016 to hunt for any signs of voter fraud and they found, as far as I recall, nothing. Again I'm not against ID in spirit but the implementation never attempts to make sure that every voter has an ID. Fundamentally that's the issue to me with voter ID laws; in the absence of any evidence of consequential voter fraud it's just another tactic to limit the ability to vote for political gain.
- pdonis 7y ago> the implementation never attempts to make sure that every voter has an ID I would be fine with requiring voting jurisdictions to make reasonable efforts to do this if ID will be required to vote. I would also be fine with providing federal funds to allow, for example, increased resources at DMVs or other ID issuing facilities to support this.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoYou can prove fraud if you show up to a polling place and the poll worker says they already have a record of you voting. It’s not actually the honor system either they ask for your address.
- pdonis 7y ago> It’s not actually the honor system either they ask for your address. I wasn't talking about eligibility based on address (though of course that should be checked too), but based on citizenship.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoThe only way to prove citizenship on the spot would be with a passport. The government knows your citizenship status when you register to vote. Honestly I wouldn’t mind if the only requirement to vote was a passport to prove citizenship. It would probably disenfranchise lots of folks though, given only a fraction of the country has one.
- pdonis 7y ago> The government knows your citizenship status when you register to vote. Yes, but if you register at a time other than the time you vote, how do you prove at the time you vote that you're the same person who registered and had all that information checked when they registered? That's what the ID is for. A passport would also work, but I don't think that should be the only possible way to do it. Now that most states are supporting RealID, your state will most likely be able to issue you an ID that you have to prove citizenship to get.
- akhilcacharya 7y agoYou’re aware non citizens can get RealID drivers licenses too right? The only way you can prove citizenship is with a passport. Of course if you were going to the effort of attempting to impersonate someone you’d probably forge documents too which aren’t deeply checked in my experience of living in a state that had an ID requirement designed to disenfranchise black voters [0]. Ultimately it’s not a problem worth the energy of being solved. [0] https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/north-carolina-voter-id/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/north-carolina-voter-id/
- subsaharancoder 7y agoThe angst against "voter ID" as a form of voter disenfranchisement makes no sense to me, as an immigrant the first thing I did when I got to the U.S. is secure a form of government issued ID - stateID or drivers license, because I understood that having an ID enabled me to do something as simple as getting a library card so that I could borrow books for my family and I https://web.ocpl.org/n/LibraryCardApplication/#/ https://web.ocpl.org/n/LibraryCardApplication/#/ In fact the DMV is packed with immigrants trying to get stateID because they recognize the benefits accrued from having one. The process is simple and straightforward and in my view would silence the whole "non-citizens and illegal immigrants are allowed to vote".