5 ms·
>But another argument is shaping up to be central to the plaintiffs’ case: Florida has no consolidated system for determining what felons owe or certifying that
by duxup 7y ago
>But another argument is shaping up to be central to the plaintiffs’ case: Florida has no consolidated system for determining what felons owe or certifying that they have paid up. It’s a situation that ex-offenders say makes it virtually impossible for them to prove they are eligible to vote.
This seems absurd.
You can't vote because you owe us money... but we're not going to tell you how much you owe, if anything at all.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWhy is paying up linked to voting? This just creates an incentive to strenuously police and fine minorities so they can't put you out of office.
- duxup 7y agoOh I think that is the intent for sure.
- TremendousJudge 7y agoyou literally just answered yourself?
- japhyr 7y agoYes, exactly, it's a modern day poll tax and many people in power want such a thing.
- abawany 7y agoRegrettably, it is not just people in power - the HP newsgroups had plenty of individual contributors that favored things like poll taxes, voting for property owners only, etc.
- quickthrower2 7y agoThis might be UK bias, but I take "poll tax" to mean a fixed tax on each resident for community services (as opposed to say a tax based on the value of the residence), but has nothing to do with voting. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_tax
- xigency 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_taxes_in_the_United_States#Voter_registration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poll_taxes_in_the_United_State...
- zeveb 7y agoIt's not a poll tax — it is apparently an element of the amendment Florida's voters passed, which requires that felons fulfill all elements of their sentences.
- Spooky23 7y agoIt’s consistent with all of the bullshit that southern white people in power have used to suppress black voting since the end of reconstruction.
- crooked-v 7y agoFor Florida politicians, it's a feature, not a bug.
- eranimo 7y agoSpecifically, Florida Republicans.
- taborj 7y agoI think it has to do with the wording of the law passed by the voters. Someone else linked the exact verbiage, but it basically hinges on the wording around having "completed" their sentence. If part of that sentence was repaying money, then until they've paid it they haven't really completed their sentence. That doesn't cover why the state can't keep track and report out who needs to pay what, of course.
- delinka 7y ago> ... because you probably owe us money, and we can't be arsed to find out
- specialist 7y agoFriends of mine worked 15 years to rationalize WA State's reenfranchisement of ex felons. For a time the most regressive in the USA. Kafkaesque. So vague and complicated, correctional and election officials themselves couldn't figure out how to administer the system. The whole mess was like a third rail (untouchable). Even explaining the actual system to law makers, to demonstrate need for reform, took a huge reverse engineering and research effort.
- duxup 7y agoThat's strange. Another state I was familiar with really just had a list that some agency had... but honestly the list was only populated by in state known felons and IIRC there was no mechanism to check the list unless someone was actually arrested FOR voter fraud or something and that happened all of a handful of times when a bitter family member or spouse turned them in. Outside that if a felon asked a judge they were almost always taken off the list because just showing the effort to care usually was enough for judges who just sent a letter to the folks with the list. I remember thinking it was a pretty good system... if you had to have one. Would rather not have such a system though.
- specialist 7y agoI don't recall the details of our mess. But I do remember the exfelon needed the original court (judge?) to signoff once all the outstanding fees had been paid. So process involved multiple separate bureaucracies, each its own moving target. Worse, the interest rate on the fees made the principle grow faster than could ever be paid off, effectively resulting in permanent disenfranchisement for a large fraction of exfelons.
- jfengel 7y agoIt's not absurd. You just have to realize that it's not about being fair, or even about getting money. It's about suppressing their vote. Viewed through that lens, it's quite logical. Evil, but logical.
- wry_discontent 7y agoThis is the hardest thing for me to convey to my liberal friends. This _is_ the system working as it was designed. They can't wrap their heads around the idea that some people aren't interested in advancing democracy, and that they must just be behaving illogically.
- eadmund 7y ago> They can't wrap their heads around the idea that some people aren't interested in advancing democracy, and that they must just be behaving illogically. I would think anyone who has ever seen 50%+1 of the electorate support an unjust law would be less than interested in advancing democracy. Democracy is a means: good government and liberty are the ends. That's a good part of the reason why the United States are not a democracy but rather a republic: we don't normally put laws up to the people directly for a vote, but in fact put many things beyond the reach of democracy. Freedom of and from religion, for example. I don't really see how permitting felons to vote is likely to lead to either good government or increased liberty, although certainly the citizens of Florida had every right to amend their constitution to extend the franchise to felons, and the politicians of the state have a duty to obey their constitution.
- anoncake 7y ago> Democracy is a means: good government and liberty are the ends. WTF. > That's a good part of the reason why the United States are not a democracy but rather a republic: I guess it makes more sense if you think that rule of the people is somehow the opposite of not having a monarch.
- no_one_special 7y ago