3 ms·
The other thing you didn't touch on is: lack of variance. As markets consolidate, most companies will use one, maybe three different AI products to rate people
by izacus 7y ago
The other thing you didn't touch on is: lack of variance.
As markets consolidate, most companies will use one, maybe three different AI products to rate people. So if an AI decides that you're not fit for work, you're done for - no matter where you apply, it'll be that one AI returning the exact same result. There's no variance of different people looking at applications.
- leni536 7y agoThat's assuming you never change your CV.
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoYou're assuming that an inscrutable AI is basing its decisions off of something you can change on your CV. Maybe it doesn't like your name, one of your past employers, or Oxford commas. It's effectively a black box, so who knows?
- leni536 7y agoWell sure, but HR people are not less of a black box either.
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoPeople have well-documented biases, besides reflecting biases of humans, AI systems will also have arbitrary biases that are hard to predict.
- izacus 7y agoCVs are already a horribly low signal - people lie way too much on them. I wouldn't expect AI to take into account anything you personally put on paper. Just like insurance/credit score AIs don't care about what you put down on papers much.
- rumanator 7y agoI believe you're missing the whole point. AI is often used as a fancy name for classifiers in general, including supervised and unsupervised learning algorithms. Filtering the initial batch of candidates is basically a classification problem. It is also very time-consuming to perform by hand. If recruiters are able to used supervised/unsupervised algorithms to filter out 90% of the initial candidates with a low misscladsification error and without wasting valuable time the they'll be able to operate more efficiently. The trick is how to tell how far the auto classification algorithms should go in helping pick the best candidates. Some company use stupid fizzbuzz tests to weed out candidates based on a quantifiable index by abusing a metric whose value is negligible but very effective in weeding out a considerable portion of initial candidates.
- overlords 7y agoThe markets will sort it out though. That filtered out candidate has some inherent worth and companies can take advantage of that. Competent hirers will then always use multiple AI hirers and experiment with hiring to make sure they're not losing out on talent that's been inaccurately filtered out.