4 ms·
I have an interesting take on this, from knowing a bit about Chinese culture (lived there) and for having friends and coworkers who are Chinese. Culture in Chi
by baby 7y ago
I have an interesting take on this, from knowing a bit about Chinese culture (lived there) and for having friends and coworkers who are Chinese.
Culture in China is about unity. If you look at Chinese history, and if you watch Chinese movies, this is a recurrent theme. Unification through blood and war. This is the goal and China will get stronger and more stable over time. At what cost? Tiananmen, xinjiang, hk, the gfw, and so on... people know about it but are willing to ignore them for the greater goal.
Why this shocks us so much, as non-mainlander, is that our Overton window is much further left (the window of what is considered “normal” or “accepted” public discourse). We have lived through slavery, camps, revolutions for human rights. So there’s definitely a human asymmetry here, which makes it harder for any of us to find common ground.
I don’t think there are much solutions here, and I think that in time Chinese people will learn the same lessons we have learned.
I also think most of their distrust in western media is not because they necessarily disagree with it, but because it doesn’t promote their greater goal. And eventhough they know weibo, wechat, et al. Are heavily censored they continue to obtain their news from there, never ending the cycle.
- novok 7y agoIsn't the culture more like: There were many attempts to violently force the political union of a large group of people for the ambitions of a warlord, but in the end, it never working out? The provinces have also always acted fairly independently, which is still the case today right? AFAIK the culture is more like loyalty to your family and village, and "Heaven is high and the emperor is far away". Heck even the languages of china are mutually unintelligible. Maybe in the end, china should split up into several separate countries, like the khmer region split up into thailand, cambodia, laos and vietnam. Maybe it should be split up into beijing-land, shanghai-land, guangzhou-land, tibet and xinjiang-land.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway5752 7y agoIt is impossible to understand Chinese views towards Western values outside of the context of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_of_humiliation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_of_humiliation
- webwielder2 7y agoBlowback's a bitch.
- throwawy4trueth 7y agoThe solution is quite simple: mind your own business. Let time and history to tell. China never send army or CIA to overthrow other countries. If the other side don't want to do the business that's fine. Westerner like to spread their values, often with force.
- Qub3d 7y agoGiven the name, age, and almost hilariously stereotypical grammatical errors, I can only assume you are at best a troll and at worst some sort of astroturfer or Chinese national. China has absolutely used state power to affect foreign states. Consider all the infrastructure projects funded by Chinese money in Africa[0] and consider what the ultimate motive is. [0]:https://qz.com/africa/1326618/china-is-building-expensive-roads-in-uganda/ https://qz.com/africa/1326618/china-is-building-expensive-ro...
- Sag0Sag0 7y agoOne one hand you are right. On the other hand state sponsored infrastructure projects are far less dramatically wrong than state sponsored coups. And the US has initiated lots of coups over the years, much more than China.
- throwawy4trueth 7y agoAssume your imagination is correct, can you argue with which part is false instead of who I am and what motive is? The way you draw your conclusion reflects some interesting information. [edit]: Thanks for the link. It seems China is building infrastructure for other countries. Of cause it's not free but it's better than bombing other countries in the name of promoting value of freedom. A lot of people from victim countries see the bombers as evil but I think they(bombers) are just cult believer consider themselves liberators.
- kcanini 7y agoWhat sort of infrastructure is China building in Xinjiang?
- downrightmike 7y agoIf you go back over the last few thousand years, you'll see that every dynasty was overthrown by peasant revolt. It is just a matter of time.
- oska 7y agoYour comment is not an interesting take at all. But it is incredibly patronising.
- ktln2 7y ago"Culture in China is about unity. If you look at Chinese history, and if you watch Chinese movies, this is a recurrent theme." This is because the governments (ROC and PRC) deliberately construct and promote this ideology. The idea of Chinese nation 中华民族 did not exists until roughly 100 years ago.