3 ms·
It's not a religion in any complete sense, but it's kind of obvious that a gigantic leap of faith is involved (starting with the use of the definite article in
by gruseom 18y ago
It's not a religion in any complete sense, but it's kind of obvious that a gigantic leap of faith is involved (starting with the use of the definite article in the phrase "The Singularity", as was shrewdly pointed out by a recent commentator here), and I do think the leap can fairly be called religious. Why?
First, despite what you and others say about "empiric evidence", Moore's Law doesn't at all imply a concomitant leap in programming power (is our capacity growing exponentially?), and extrapolation from actual achievements to date points in a decidedly more mundane direction.
Second, the "singularity" predictions are the latest in a tradition of extravagant millenarian claims that people have been making about AI for decades. These claims have consistently turned out to be overblown, if not vacuous, in retrospect. Extrapolate from that historical trend and you arrive at quite a different (and rather more plausible) picture.
Third and most interestingly, the emotions and language surrounding the "singularity" are distinctly religious. This really stands out in what I've seen of the discourse. Since many advocates of "singularity" are of an intellectual cast that objects to the more popular religions, it seems to me as if some are directing their religious impulses into technology. As someone brilliantly says in the OP, it's "The Rapture For Nerds". (Notice that definite article again.)
By the way, I don't mean "religious" as a criticism per se. Personally, I think religious impulses are part of being human. What fascinates me about The Singularity discourse is the incongruence between its technological subject matter and its vividly religious emotional language.