2 ms·
It's precisely because they are monopolies that they can be forced to accept a wide range of students. Otherwise there will be schools which pick the best/easil
by eesmith 7y ago
It's precisely because they are monopolies that they can be forced to accept a wide range of students. Otherwise there will be schools which pick the best/easily taught students, and leave the others behind.
Those who fared worse in the current system may fare far worse in an all-private system.
1. In the current charter school system, privatization often does mean deregulation. So while I can imagine it, I assert that it's a dream.
2. If we pick wrong measures - and standardized tests are wrong measures - then we end up trying to improve the wrong thing. Eg, we end up with two weeks dedicated to test prep, instead of teaching; we end up dropping art, music, and foreign language classes in order to focus only on those topics which are tested.
The regional gerrymandering is in part so that the local communities get to decide what the right measures are. Mileage absolutely varies from person to person .. people and communities vary too.
It's not like we didn't have a decent sense of what a good education meant back in the 1970s, before high-stakes testing.
3. Again, how do private schools get to decide which students to accept? Can they make policies which end up rejecting most poor people? If the private school education costs $10,000 and the state's check is for $5,000 then poor students aren't going to afford it. While the parents of middle class students can, subsidized by the state.
Which means poor people won't have access to the same quality education as everyone else.