3 ms·
This is actually a big deal because what was ruled on was the legal matter of whether a business could be sued based on their website. The facts of what consti
by gnicholas 7y ago
This is actually a big deal because what was ruled on was the legal matter of whether a business could be sued based on their website.
The facts of what constitutes a sufficiently-accessible website necessarily have not been discussed, because Dominos was trying to boot the case before any factual determinations were made.
Their argument was that, as a matter of law, they could not be sued under the ADA based on their website. This argument prevailed at the District Court, lost at the Ninth Circuit, and was unanimously declined to be heard at SCOTUS.
That sends a loud and clear message, and this will essentially become the law of the land for at least the next few decades.
Note: I have not deeply read all the opinions, but I am a lawyer who is familiar with appellate procedure and the ADA.
- BurritoAlPastor 7y agoIt’s a little more tightly scoped than that. From what I’m seeing, no parties are arguing that websites are themselves Title III “public accommodations”. Rather, the 9th circuit held that the Domino’s websites were part of the Domino’s services at their brick & mortar restaurants. In other words, this case only directly applies to physical businesses with an online component (buy-online-pick-up-in-store or similar). I’ll be curious to see – assuming that Robles eventually wins – if this case is ever used to argue that an online-only business is subject to Title III. It doesn’t seem like a slam dunk connection. (Not a lawyer, but I do enjoy reading court documents.)
- jcranmer 7y ago> was unanimously declined to be heard at SCOTUS We don't know that. It takes 4 votes for SCOTUS to agree to hear a case, and the voting breakdown is usually not revealed unless some justice decides to write an opinion disagreeing with the decision.