4 ms·
Your music library doesn’t disappear - if you bought music from iTunes. The music you bought would/could be on your computer. If you bought it within the last d
by scarface74 7y ago
Your music library doesn’t disappear - if you bought music from iTunes. The music you bought would/could be on your computer. If you bought it within the last decade, it would be DRM free.
- nixpulvis 7y agoAh yes my music! You mean songs that have been overwritten by whatever match they decide is close enough (in some cases). Or you mean my music, that I've listened two maybe 200 times each. Or do you mean my music, that the artists themselves gave to me. I don't much care for your argument, even if you're legally correct. This would be less of an issue if the way people actually acquired music was still by buying the album, but that's not the case in the vast majority of people's experiences.
- scarface74 7y agoNo, I mean music that you purchased from iTunes and downloaded onto your computer and hopefully backed up. As opposed to music that is part of a subscription where you explicitly knew was being rented.
- nixpulvis 7y agoI'm sorry, when was the last time you rented something to put into your "library". The way they sell these subscription services doesn't make it at all clear to the users what they are buying. P.S. plus think about who this model helps the most. It's surely not the artists themselves, especially if the songs I know and love can't be played anymore. What artist would want their work to become inaccessible to those who love it?
- scarface74 7y agoAre you really saying that most users don’t know when they stop paying for Apple Music or Spotify they will lose access to their music? The iTunes Music Store where you buy music and pay a one time cost has been around since 2003 and has been completely DRM free since 2009. That’s like saying people don’t know content isn’t on Netflix forever.
- nixpulvis 7y agoNo of course we know they would go away if we stop paying, that's not my top issue. I've committed to paying $10/m (hoping prices don't change to much). Of course this isn't perfect, since it's not unimaginable that I'd need to stop paying for music monthly at some point. What really offends me when music disappears while I'm paying monthly for the service. TLDR; the entire subscription model is user hostile in most cases, like this one. And I'll argue it's also rather hostile to the artist here too.
- scarface74 7y agoDo you also get offended when you pay for any of the subscription video services and content is removed? If you don’t like music going away, especially with Apple Music, just buy the music you don’t want to lose and add it to your library. It integrates with the subscription service.
- wolco 7y agoI don't like seeing content just disappear from netflix. One of the worst features. If I rent from the store I know how long I have. If I find something on netflix it could disappear while I'm still trying to get through it. If I save it chances are it won't be there in a few months.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd that’s been true for premium TV like HBO forever where movies would be in heavy rotation for a few months and then not available.
- nixpulvis 7y agoLet me make up a story to help explain. In a far off land of yesteryear, you live happily and healthfully in a small settlement. Despite not being a farmer yourself you own a rooster who wakes you up in time for work every morning. After years of being awoken by the same rooster, a salesman comes to you telling you of a fancy device which will wake you up at ANY time you wish, not just when the sun rises. You think, this is great! I'll buy one, and wake up later on the weekends (ironically forgetting you still own a rooster...) Of course you knew how to feed the rooster, but this magic device needs power and breaks sometimes... and the only person around to help is, of course, the same salesman. He goes way out his way for you at first, offering free power, and quick repairs. But as time goes on, and as the masses make use of these alarms, he's unable to keep up the same level of service to you. Well that and he's too busy spending all the coin you've given him. Finally you find yourself with a dead rooster (oops) and a broken alarm clock, with the only repairman out on vacation, while you're missing work in the mornings. Sadly rooster alarm clocks have fallen out of style, and the thought of owning one sounds as crazy then as it does to us now.
- djsumdog 7y agoiTunes has had bugs that try to remove duplicates and end up deleting peoples' own remixed material. Amazon discovered they didn't have the rights to a book in Canada and deleted it off people devices. The book? 1984. I think the iTunes issues have been fixed, but it's still stupid to not have your own backup independent of stuff accessible by "cloud" services. I buy everything I can off bandcamp and download it to my machine. I occasionally buy off Amazon music, but I really hate it when that's the only option an artists has and would prefer to buy/rip a physical CD at a show. I keep my music on a 512GB microSD card (crazy these things exist now) and I always keep my own backups of my own content; buy DRM free whenever I can on Gog/Humble over Steam. I prefer to have things I own, not licenses to software and content that can be revoked at any time.
- scarface74 7y agoAmazon’s books contain DRM. iTunes music that you bought within the last decade was DRM free and could be played and backed up anywhere. Apple couldn’t “revoke” DRM free music that you backed up.
- awayfromhomenow 7y agonot all of Amazons books contain DRM. There's a big movement (mostly authors of Baean Books, afaik) that ask that the books be published DRM-free.
- ryukafalz 7y agoAnything published by Tor Books as well. (Us sci-fi fans are lucky!) Generally, if the book I'm looking for is sold DRM-free, I'll buy the ebook for convenience. Otherwise, I'll go look for a used paper copy.
- WalterBright 7y agoThe people who publish books on Amazon have the option of them being DRM-free or not. The books I publish on AMZN are DRM-free.
- im3w1l 7y agoWhen I last installed itunes on a new computer, not all my past purchases showed up as available for download anymore. I talked with support and they explained that as I had bought them when I was living in another country I could no longer download them.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd that’s the whole part about downloading the DRM free music you bought and keeping a local backup.
- im3w1l 7y agoSure, I do have a local backup. But restoring from backup is inconvenient, and an important part of why I bought on itunes instead of ripping my own cd's was to reduce hassle and make my life more easy. EDIT: And to restore from backup you have to know you're missing it. They never gave me any errors or warnings. Just a few things were missing. They're basically gaslighting their users.
- nixpulvis 7y agoThe knowing it's missing is a great point! I was going crazy because I felt like my music was changing but I couldn't really tell, since I mostly play on shuffle. Took a little while to notice what was going on.
- alexis_fr 7y agoSeems like people didn’t know. Legitimate users didn’t know, while experts did. More seriously, what prevented an Apple user from uploading it on Torrents? Was it watermarked so Apple would find the culprit?
- scarface74 7y agoNo watermarking besides the standard AAC tags saying who the owner is. Steve Jobs argued for DRM free music as a means to interoperability instead of licensing FairPlay way back in 2007 in his “Thoughts on Music” post. He argued that most music was already DRM free and easily copied and only a small percentage of music on most iPods was bought from iTunes.