4 ms·
Is the purpose of taxes to fund the government or punish the rich? Because if it’s the former, then looking at the share of taxes paid by billionaires is highly
by rayiner 7y ago
Is the purpose of taxes to fund the government or punish the rich? Because if it’s the former, then looking at the share of taxes paid by billionaires is highly relevant.
In the US, billionaires make just 1.3% of all income. 80% of income is earned by the bottom 99%. Confiscatory taxes would definitely achieve the second purpose, punishing the rich, but would have little effect on how much taxes ordinary people would have to pay to fund government.
- coldtea 7y ago>Is the purpose of taxes to fund the government or punish the rich? Obviously it should do both. Joking aside, if the purpose is to fund the government as good as you can (that is, societies central pool of resource to be able to produce democratically controlled and publicly available "nice stuff") then it makes sense to take as much as you can from the rich (which can afford it) and a normal amount from the average/poor (which can't afford to pay much). A tax could be: 1) None. Then a country wouldn't be able to maintain e.g. an army or basic infrastructure, and either the country would be at the mercy of other countries that can, or the majority would be at the mercy of moguls that can afford to pay for those things. Some third world places are close to the latter. 2) Flat ($10K for a lawyer making $2M/year, $10K for a single mother of two juggling 2 jobs and making $40K). Most would agree that's bad. 3) Fixed ratio (e.g. 30% of said lawyer's income, 30% of the income of the single mother of two juggling two jobs). The lawyer is then left with $1.4M, more than enough to live in luxury, pander his kids etc, buy 4 new cars per year, etc, whereas the mother can barely survive and do basic spending or cover an emergency with the $28K that remain. Not sure how you find it, not a big fan. 4) Progressive scale. The government gets more from the lawyer (and as people getting richer) and not a fixed ratio. The reach still keep more than enough to do whatever BS they want (e.g. $2M - 60% is still 800K/year). Plus most of their money is not in income but wealth, and the ultra rich have already hid it through 2000 schemes. >In the US, billionaires make just 1.3% of all income. Property beyond a certain level should be taxed way worse than income. It's just hogging resources from society and giving to much power to money-based, as opposed to bloodline based, neo-feudal lords. Let's throw that majority of the wealth that they own into collective infrastructure for that "bottom 99%" (which, after all, earns 80% of income and pays more taxes).
- harryh 7y agoProperty beyond a certain level should be taxed way worse than income. It's just hogging resources from society This is an argument for taxing consumption, not wealth. If I have $100M sitting in a bank account it isn't consuming any resources at all.
- coldtea 7y agoIt could be out and working in the economy, instead of sitting, so, yes it does. Capital is a resource too...
- harryh 7y agoBank deposits aren't removed from the economy. That money is loaned out to other people. That's what banks do.
- coldtea 7y ago>Bank deposits aren't removed from the economy For the ultra rich they go to so many channels, as to be effectively removed (else, they'd also be taxed as income to begin with). A deposit in Switzerland or Turks and Caicos doesn't do much good (if anything) to your local economy... And of course, as a rich person you have all kinds of assets like real estate too...
- harryh 7y agoDo you really think Turks and Caicos banks only loan money to islanders? Not much to invest in there. Capital easily flows across borders to the best investment opportunities. Real estate is a bit tricky since it can be both consumption and investment. While I'd rather see taxes on imputed rent like they have in some countries to cover the consumption part, property taxes do a pretty good job.
- jlmorton 7y ago> Is the purpose of taxes to fund the government or punish the rich? Government exists because of and for society, and the purpose of taxes is to create the greatest net benefit to society. Taxes are not to punish anyone, they are levied to fund services for society. Determining the optimum rate is complex and open to debate. But fairness is entirely irrelevant to the question. Whether the top marginal rate is 10%, or 90%, it should be whatever maximizes the usefulness to society. We have a capitalist economic system, and it works pretty well for us, but that doesn't mean anyone has an inherent natural right to their capital. When it comes down it, property rights are all fictitious and exist only because society says it does. It's hardly wrong for society to decide to recoup some of what it has created.
- tptacek 7y agoRight, but Rayiner didn't make any arguments about anyone's "inherent natural right to their capital" and I kind of doubt he believes in any such thing. His argument is subtler and much more important than that: if what we want are social services that resemble Europe's more than our own, what needs to change aren't the taxes on the top 1% of earners, but rather increased taxes on the middle class. Since I've seen Rayiner argue repeatedly on HN that European-style universal health care is a good idea, it stands to reason that what he's saying is that taxes need to increase across the board, not that any one cohort of payers needs to be shielded from increase.
- coldtea 7y ago>if what we want are social services that resemble Europe's more than our own, what needs to change aren't the taxes on the top 1% of earners, but rather increased taxes on the middle class. How about increased wealth taxation on the 1% of earners, and the 0.1% of owners?
- xyzzyz 7y agoIt might work as punishment for some wealthy people, but won't bring enough extra income to significantly expand government spending.
- bsanr 7y ago>Is the purpose of taxes to fund the government or punish the rich? Yes. Though "punish" is an unnecessarily emotional word to use to describe a secondary function of taxation, which is to influence the structure of the economy writ large. It's been mentioned before that high marginal tax rates on top earners were almost never triggered, which is true. Instead of becoming personal income that could be used to wield undue influence on personal whims, wealth created by large enterprises (virtually the only way to accrue billions and billions of dollars of net worth) stayed within those organizations, where it could justifiably be used to raise wages and improve infrastructure, and where whatever use it eventually saw was validated by a support structure of interested parties with real sway.