2 ms·
This is called the single lump of labor fallacy otherwise known as the brown people are coming for my job. In your interpretation there is a finite or relativel
by michaelmrose 7y ago
This is called the single lump of labor fallacy otherwise known as the brown people are coming for my job. In your interpretation there is a finite or relatively nonelastic number of jobs and importing a bunch of people drives down the cost by substantially inflating supply.
There are multiple problems with this thought. The imports are in many relatively low paying sectors already an expected part of the market and withdrawing them would actually be the shock to the market. Americans may in some cases not be willing or legally able to pick fruit for a price that results in a price you would actually be willing to pay at the super market.
More importantly the surge in population creates jobs. The new citizens need cars, food, doctors. Their children start operations like Google that employ thousands.
I would suggest this post is more appropriate on your personal Facebook.
- JamesSchriver 7y agoAnd here we are, utterly ignorant and navel gazing self-serving excuse making, couched in lazy thinking. You did quite a good job of covering almost every single fallacy, including the gaslighting fake fallacy. You even covered the propaganda excuse of the noble savage you racist types never fail to trot out because you think the USA is more deserving of the "children start operations like Google" than the originating countries and societies as you drain their potential and use the exceptions of starting Google as an excuse for exploiting and sabotaging the originating countries. You can use that racist self-righteous snark somewhere else, but reality does not change facts, no matter how much you simply parrot the gaslighting propaganda of the ruling class that loves it when self-righteous useful fools like you get all adamant about spreading their propaganda for them. It's really no different than any other propaganda hack of any other ruling class serving tools. You're no different than the Chinese hacks that are encouraged to spread the same level of pro-CCP nonsense; just as self-righteous and just as big of a fool. There are no problems with my thought any more than when CCP propaganda spreading hacks try to gaslight people like you do. It's embarrassing that you would even use such a lazy argument as "Americans may not be willing to work". Even your subconscious knows that it's utter nonsense, hence your use of "may". Reality is that Americans do not want to work for slave analogue wages; as was clearly evident when ICE raided the plant in the south that left the company having to hire local American workers that were then also paid higher wages. And no, people who are not hypocritical, would have no problem paying higher wages for groceries, which would also lead to lower profits of the companies producing them, because they have to pay workers living wages, which allows them to make more money that it will cost them to buy more expensive groceries. Again, such utterly lazy and shallow lack of any thought. I come here hoping for intelligence, yet there is little to be found.