10 ms·
What a shit article. It's well known that despite the high marginal tax rates of the past, very few people ever paid those. Deductions abound that have since
by refurb 7y ago
What a shit article.
It's well known that despite the high marginal tax rates of the past, very few people ever paid those. Deductions abound that have since been eliminated.
What you should really look at is real effective tax rates by income level.[1] What you'll find is that the top 1% make 19% of all income, but pay 37% of all taxes, with an average tax rate of 27%.
The bottom 50% earn 11% of all income, but only pay 3% of all taxes, for an effective rate of 3.73%.
[1]https://taxfoundation.org/top-1-percent-tax-rate/ https://taxfoundation.org/top-1-percent-tax-rate/
- mcv 7y agoI'm not sure how informative that is. It's natural for the poorest 50% to pay a lot less tax; they first need to have enough money to eat and live before they can even afford to pay taxes. This is simply progressive taxation at work. Although I suppose showing that the top 1% has 19% of the income while the bottom 50% has 11% of the income does show the vast income discrepancy.
- weberc2 7y agoI agree, but the parent is responding to the article’s claim that the rich pay less. This isn’t in support of the parent’s comment, just trying to clarify the conversation and root out accidental straw men.
- danans 7y ago> the parent is responding to the article’s claim that the rich pay less. The article appears to be discussing the individual tax rates paid by the wealthiest, not the percentage of total tax paid. Those are two different things. The GP appears to have introduced the latter statistic, as often happens in this debate, to distract from the actual statistic under discussion.
- refurb 7y agoI stated tax rate too. The bottom 50% effective tax rate is almost 1/10th of what the top 1%’s is. Therefore, the headline of the article “the rich pay less than than you” is pretty clearly false.
- danans 7y agoI agree the title is click baity, but the ultra wealthy do pay a lower effective tax rate than me, and I'm probably in the top 10% of income percentile. But the observations of the article itself check out. The tax system has gotten radically less progressive over the last 50 years. The argument is over whether or not it should be made more or less progressive given current realities. People can differ in their opinions on that, but the historical trend is clear as day.
- refurb 7y agoIt’s gotten less progressive? 2nd graph here [1] shows the top 1% has steady increased their share of all taxes since 1986. I have no idea what it looks like before 1986. [1]https://taxfoundation.org/top-1-percent-tax-rate/ https://taxfoundation.org/top-1-percent-tax-rate/
- danans 7y agoYou are switching stats again, and I can't tell whether you're doing it on purpose, or are unaware that you are doing it. The stat under discussion in the article is not "share of all taxes", it's effective individual income tax rate by income percentile. The latter has definitely become less progressive over time, as the article makes clear with data. If "share of all taxes" since taxes is a statistic you think is illustrative of something relevant, notice that since 1980, real family income for the top 5% has dramatically outpaced the median real family income, so it only makes sense that their "share of all taxes" would go up: https://www.cbpp.org/income-gains-widely-shared-in-early-postwar-decades-but-not-since-then-2 https://www.cbpp.org/income-gains-widely-shared-in-early-pos...
- ranie93 7y ago
- lm28469 7y ago> it's natural for the poorest 50% to pay a lot less tax People don't understand that taxes are the only way to make capitalism work overall by making money trickle down to the poorest and into public infra structures and services. All they see is $$ leaving their account.
- astrodust 7y ago"I like having a car but hate spending all that money on maintenance. It's just money out of my pocket!"
- ivalm 7y agoThe graph in article is effective, not marginal. The poorest do pay less in absolute numbers because they are poor, that's a statement of income inequality, not progressivity of the tax rate.
- throwaway926 7y agoThey have higher marginal and effective rates. The title "The Rich Do Pay Lower Taxes Than You" is so false and ill-intentioned it says a lot about journalism and the left.
- objektif 7y agoThan whom? I can tell you I pay higher than them and I am not rich. I think it is you who is trying to cherry pick data points you are obviously biased due to your ideology.
- vonmoltke 7y ago> The graph in article is effective, not marginal. The article is not very clear on that, and there is nothing to indicate such on the plot itself (which will be taken out-of-context at some point).
- my_username_is_ 7y agoIf you have a basic understanding of tax rates in the US, this shouldn't come as a surprise. The marginal tax rate always goes up as you earn more income, so for the graph to show it going down then it must be the effective tax rate. But I agree, it probably will be taken out of context and unfortunately not everyone has even a basic understanding of how taxes work.
- mcguire 7y ago"The overall tax rate on the richest 400 households last year was only 23 percent, meaning that their combined tax payments equaled less than one quarter of their total income. This overall rate was 70 percent in 1950 and 47 percent in 1980."
- folbec 7y ago- They are NOT speaking of the 1% (such as medical professional or high income technical professionals) - They are NOT speaking of the 0.1 %. - They are speaking of the 0.01%. One person out of 10000. Not multimillionaires. 100 millionaires and billionaires. There is a very good reason why the tax foundating speaks of the 1% and not of the 0.1% or 0.01% : it is usefull to protect billionaires.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dmix 7y agoBut when the politicians use this stuff to change the law it will most certainly be the first two (expanded far more broadly) who will be targeted. They always say hand wavy stuff about billionaires whenever they get asked about paying for grand projects. But we’ve all seen how that works out in real life every time. I highly doubt that sort of categorization will ever carry over when it matters.
- commandlinefan 7y agoYou’re being wildly optimistic if you think the first two (the top 1%) will ever be meaningfully impacted by any tax law change. There’s a reason the super rich all line up in support of “higher taxes”: they know that these policies always affect the middle class and never touch the upper class. That makes it harder for anybody else to break through from middle class to upper class, which is exactly what the (upper class) politicians are shooting for when they pretend they’re going after “the 1%”.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> There’s a reason the super rich all line up in support of “higher taxes” Uh, they don't all do that, so there can't be a reason that they all do. Some of them do, some of them fund tax protest groups that work to shift he tax burden further from the rich to the working class.
- 7y ago
- xenocyon 7y agoYour source is a controversial one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_Foundation
- throwaway926 7y agoThese numbers are consistent across studies, and across countries. So try harder next time you want to discredit sources of data you don't like.
- xenocyon 7y agoAs others have commented, their very choice of the top 1% when talking about the super-rich is a disingenuous one.
- objektif 7y agoAlso why are we comparing the very rich to the very poor only? What about the middle class? Certainly rich pay a lot less than the middle and middle upper class.
- weberc2 7y agoMaybe it is, but that Wikipedia article doesn’t illustrate any controversy (unless I missed something), only that we should take the source with a grain of salt.
- rtkwe 7y agoThat's 37% of income taxes not 37% of all taxes. Also important is those numbers will be based on the federal and reported income numbers not based on the amount they actually earn much of which can be shifted around to specifically avoid the top marginal rate.
- refurb 7y agoThe total tax rates are available if you google it, including state tax, sales taxes, etc. The trend is more muted (the poor pay a slightly higher percent of the total), but the rich still pay the majority of taxes and have a much higher effective rate.
- mcguire 7y agoThe total tax rates are available in the chart in the article, from the research by Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman. The rich do not have a much higher effective rate.
- coldtea 7y agoIf society was a rich person with 1 billion paying $1M in taxes, and a regular person with $50K income paying $10K in taxes, the rich person would have paid nearly 99% of all taxes. And yet, they would have paid a pittance compared to their income (not to mention wealth), and it would absolutely no impact on their purchasing power or lifestyle (where the 10K of the 50K could make the difference between having savings, or having a health operation, or sending the kids to college, and many other important things). That's how irrelevant and unilluminating is this kind of metric...
- refurb 7y agoI’m not sure what point you’re trying to make, but it doesn’t seem to contradict my statement that “no, the rich don’t pay less taxes than the poor”.
- coldtea 7y agoI don't want to contradict the statement. My point is that the even the more taxes they pay, they're not enough. They should pay way more than the poor, not merely more.
- dmix 7y agoIn your example they’d also be making 99.9%+ of the income. I don’t see how that’s relevant when the OP already used relative terms.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tolmasky 7y agoDoes "with" 1 billion mean they made 1 billion in income that year, or does it mean they have accumulated a billion over some longer previous period of time, meaning they probably conservatively(?) paid close to 500 million in taxes on making 1.5B, and now just unrelatedly, they are paying a million for whatever they did this year? Just want to understand the specifics of your example, since the 10K on 50K seems to be very close to current tax rate, so I'm assuming these aren't random hypothetical numbers. I can't make the slider go up to 1B in income here (https://smartasset.com/taxes/income-taxes#tvFxGKBdZE https://smartasset.com/taxes/income-taxes#tvFxGKBdZE), but according to that if you make 10,000,000 in SF, you'll pay $5,207,046 in taxes, so over half. Whereas, matching your statement, you'll pay 10K on 50K, so 1/5. From an income tax perspective, >50% certainly seems significantly larger than 20%. Of course, this is pure income, so its as if we're talking about an athlete, and things of course change if the capital is not income. Similarly, none of this takes into account sales tax, etc. etc. Of course, the other key question is what the taxes are for. If the purpose of the tax is to "impact their purchasing power or lifestyle", then I guess until you tax them to the point where they make 40K it will never match the 50K person? If the purpose of the tax on the other hand is to raise revenue for programs then it seems to be quite effective.
- gnicholas 7y ago> Deductions abound that have since been eliminated. Yep, and those "deductions" are now referred to as "tax shelters" (post-1986). Basically, high-earners could invest a relatively small amount of capital into a "business" that was certain to generate large tax losses. These were things like llama farms or avocado farms. The entire purpose was to generate deductions, since the capital invested was smaller than the tax losses generated. The "investor" literally didn't care if he ever got his money back, since the deductions alone were worth the "investment". Pretty much no one paid the highest rates of the past, because people who have that much money are well-advised, and it was very easy to avoid having that much taxable income.
- greggman2 7y ago> since the capital invested was smaller than the tax losses generate Can you give an example of how that works? As a non-rich person if I invest $100 it seems like the largest taxes I can pay is $100 (100% tax). How do I generate > $100 tax loss for a $100 investment?
- gnicholas 7y agoIt's been almost a decade since I studied this in law school, and we don't do anything with this stuff in practice anymore since the laws changed long ago. But the gist of it was that tax losses could be allocated to the parties that wanted them, and not necessarily proportionate to their percent of capital invested.
- sgc 7y agobuy real estate/business/other investment using leverage, and take deductions on the entire value if the tax code allows for it (which it often does). You just need to make enough to pay down the loan (increasing your equity) and break even on cash flow, and you are doing great. It helps keep rents lower since otherwise all landlords would need to cash flow. But it drives up property prices and thus the break even point due to higher demand, so maybe they offset each other - but how could we know? The important take away here is that modern legislation dictates much of what our economy looks like. With other tax regulations we would invest completely differently, for better or for worse.
- fencepost 7y agoWhich taxes are you counting there? Including sales taxes? And I take with a huge block of salt any tax article with phrases like "These charts don’t tell us whether the top 1 percent contains the same people year after year, experiences a complete turnover annually, or something in between." Good heavens, I hadn't realized that a 100% turnover in the top 1% of earners was possible! Those investments must be doing terribly.
- wnissen 7y agoNo, just income tax, the only portion of the tax code that is nominally progressive. Payroll taxes are explicitly regressive, going away at an income of roughly the top 5%. Sales taxes are flat. Even income taxes aren't as progressive as you would think, because a large fraction of upper-class wealth comes from dividends and capital gains, which are taxed at a rate below the income of a household earning $78,951 year! The biggest tax deductions are for homeowners (including second homes) and retirement savings, which overwhelmingly go to the wealthy. The idea that the wealthy pay a high tax rate is absurd if you look at the whole picture. https://smartasset.com/taxes/dividend-tax-rate https://smartasset.com/taxes/dividend-tax-rate
- shay_ker 7y agoI... think you're almost making the point to lower taxes on the bottom 50%, but increase taxes on the top 1%? Is that what you meant to indicate?
- yourbandsucks 7y agoWe should establish a checklist of common ideologically biased fudges. Sounds like you're doing the "pretend SS and medicare don't exist" fudge, right here.
- tanderson92 7y ago> It's well known that despite the high marginal tax rates of the past, very few people ever paid those. Deductions abound that have since been eliminated. I read the article, in which this expected point is addressed. From TFA: >They have constructed a historical database that tracks the tax payments of households at different points along the income spectrum going back to 1913, when the federal income tax began. That is actual payments, not whatever the tax law says should be paid. Did you think academic economists wouldn't address this point?
- ameister14 7y agoI'm not who you're responding to, but I tend not to assume competence on the part of academic economists. I've listened to enough of them speak and read enough of their proposals/think tank papers/books to know that a sizable portion of them are perfectly happy making some absurd assumptions and running down a logical chain from there without addressing the obvious points.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoThe distribution of income is a decision we’ve made as a society. Over the past few decades we’ve allowed more wealth and income to flow into a smaller number of hands, then we’ve enacted policies that reduce the effective tax rate on those particular taxpayers. This might be ok if we were collecting enough tax to fund our government, but in an environment where we’re running huge deficits, it’s not ok (nor is it fair, or particularly good for our democracy.) One or both of those things needs to change.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoIt’s also due to technology allowing fewer and fewer people to “own” more of the production in society.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoOver the past thirty years, a lot of the "technology" has been Chinese people building things overseas and shipping it to the US. There's technology in that, but it's mostly logistics and shipping, not robots or anything fancy. NB: I'm not saying automation doesn't matter, or that it won't matter going forward. I'm saying that if no automation had happened at all, we'd almost certainly still be in this situation. The bulk of the distribution changes result from human decisions, not tech.
- danans 7y ago> It's well known that despite the high marginal tax rates of the past, very few people ever paid those. Deductions abound that have since been eliminated. Read the article again carefully, paying attention to the interactive graph, you will notice that it is discussing the change in total effective tax rate, which is why the total tax rate for the super wealthy in 1950 was 70% when the top marginal rate was 91%. Still massively higher than today's effective individual tax rates on the wealthiest. > What you should really look at is real effective tax rates by income level.[1] What you'll find is that the top 1% make 19% of all income, but pay 37% of all taxes, with an average tax rate of 27%. That's not the effective individual tax rate at all. That's burden of tax revenue by population income percentile. You appear to be mixing terms.
- mcguire 7y agoThat doesn't include FICA, state, and local taxes.
- trystero 7y agoThe chart actually shows the effective tax rate, with deductions accounted. https://twitter.com/gabriel_zucman/status/1181036959738675200 https://twitter.com/gabriel_zucman/status/118103695973867520...